3 ms·
I think the only argument against basic income/negative income tax is some form of "fairness", that taking away the need to work somehow makes people weaker or
by rdl 13y ago
I think the only argument against basic income/negative income tax is some form of "fairness", that taking away the need to work somehow makes people weaker or less moral.
I don't really believe that, but I can't think of any other good arguments against it.
The other argument is that all taxation is theft, and everyone fully earned whatever money he earns in the free economy independent of everything else.
Even if you believed this, basic income seems to be closer to this ideal than the current welfare/subsidy system. I'd be happier paying slightly more in taxes for things which don't create perverse incentives for anyone, but in reality, I think basic income (and a sane defense budget) would be a tax cut, at least after a transition period.
- shadowcats 13y agoSurprised to see you support basic income, I had always assumed you were a super Randian rugged individualist :) I also support basic income FWIW.
- jfb 13y agoPeople have been conditioned to equate wage labor with morality; anything that can be cast as weakening this is immediately politically suspect. From a policy standpoint, as opposed to a political one, I've never heard a rational objection to a basic income. I'm not a believer in the Marxist doctrine of a false consciousness, so when I say "conditioned" I don't mean "by the faceless cabal"; as the child of an anthropologist, I've long understood that culture is entirely sufficient as an explanation.