4 ms·
I agree that tablets lend themselves to more graceful interaction in some scenarios, and that the cognitive delight of the interface is itself a feature that ma
by danso 13y ago
I agree that tablets lend themselves to more graceful interaction in some scenarios, and that the cognitive delight of the interface is itself a feature that may spark new kinds of uses.
However, I have to place bets that the future of touch is going to be 99% consumption. And the production that's done on it will be "production-lite". Can anyone who currently produces multimedia at a professional level -- e.g. video, photos, music -- imagine that a sophisticated touch interface will replace their keystrokes and mouse?
In other words: is it possible for touch-gestures to replicate even just a handful of the keyboard commands (nevermind the keyboard + mouse combos) that we take for granted? And if so, would this new set of physical interactions be more intuitive to learn than Ctrl-A, Ctrl-Z, Ctrl-C, Alt-Tab, etc. etc.?
I don't think so. Sure, "Alt-Tab" and "Alt-tilde" don't map to natural human experience the same way that swiping four-fingers (or is it 3?)...but maybe that's the point. The function provided by Alt-Tab is very computer-dependent...multi-tasking between running programs. If "Alt-Tab" seems too non-natural of a "gesture", it's because it's handling a non-natural concept.
Already, we can see the problem with how Apple has tried to map iOS features to multifinger swipe. Does anyone else have problems remembering what 3 fingers in one direction does versus four fingers horizontally? And that's not even getting to the imprecision of detection, which I'll concede is something that will improve vastly in the near future.
But it's been about 6 years since Apple made the touch interface ubiquitous. And it's still cuss-word-excruciating to do something as simple as highlight a select few words out of a line (especially if they're in a overflow input field), copy and then paste them.
And 5 years later, Apple still hasn't come up with a better way to "Undo" something than by shaking your device. I wonder how many production professionals here could retain their sanity with Cmd-Z?
- monsterix 13y ago> And it's still cuss-word-excruciating to do something as simple as highlight a select few words out of a line (especially if they're in a overflow input field), copy and then paste them. vs. > "I think there are lots of kinds of content that can be created on the iPad. When I am going to write that 35-page analyst report, I am going to want my Bluetooth keyboard. That’s 1 percent of the time. " Quoted from OP/Steve's. Aren't the functionality that you mention like highlighting, selecting, pasting text come within that 1% '35 page analyst report' frame that Steve indicated? IMHO, content created via iPad shouldn't be seen through lens of existing content, i.e text (HTML coded characters), images and plugins around it. Keyboard and desktops are good for that type of content. But with the iPad and tablets there could come by another form of content which rides on touches and gestures?
- doktrin 13y ago> Aren't the functionality you mention like highlighting, selecting, pasting text come within that 1% '35 page analyst report' frame Steve indicated? I can't speak for everyone's use case, but cutting and pasting text is certainly not something I only do at work or in 1% of situations. Sure, there are ways to circumvent it by building in functionality directly, but it's a consistent and jarring reminder of a touch screen's current limitations.
- monsterix 13y agoYes, cut-paste is certainly a very fundamental functionality given the existing landscape of computers, existing content and the way people have expressed using the medium so far. I find typing on iPad's virtual keyboard clunky enough that I generally doodle my messages to my friends/wife when on the iPad. Good thing is that I am able to write in Hindi, my mother tongue, by doodling! Cut-paste experience on the iPad is horrible. It's not just clunky rather an impossible feat for my fingers given the text being in a small area that I want select and paste elsewhere.
- danso 13y agoYou make a good point, but I'd argue that it doesn't necessarily counter mine. Because it may be that "highlighting, selecting, etc." are "1% functions" because of their physical difficulty. And the more difficult they become, the less likely we are to use them...in the same way that most sophisticated writers can forgive themselves for using "ttyl" when text messaging. Even when using the iPad (as I am now), I reflexively limit the work I put into expressing things...so whereas on a laptop I'd be using more quoted passages and linking to sources, on an iPad, I just avoid making comments that would require such complexities (so apologies for this poorly supported comment :) ) I think content on tablets/mobile should still be judged against content created via any other interface. However, we should recognize that the simplicity of what these touch/mobile devices produce is a strength worth respecting...how many memorable and powerful videos and photos have been captured thanks to the ubiquity and easy of the smartphone that never would've existed were we limited to full size cameras?
- gojomo 13y agoCan anyone who currently produces multimedia at a professional level -- e.g. video, photos, music -- imagine that a sophisticated touch interface will replace their keystrokes and mouse? I think touch might: with a generation that grows up with touch, continuing software innovation, and hardware improvements like increased precision, pressure sensitivity and even haptic feedback and surface deformation. But more likely, touch plus other modalities will replace the mouse (easily) and keyboard (eventually). Imagine a touch device that accepts either fingers or (when needed for fine art work) an ultra-precise fine-tipped stylus. Then add Leap Motion-like gestures -- you can then use finger twitches in the air, away from the screen, to change tools/modes and adjust things along many finely-stepped virtual axes. (In particular, I think this may best solve the text-selection and related problems, giving you virtual cursor control away from the touch surface, but without a mouse-like peripheral.) Then add much improved voice controls, so good that just tone of voice lets the machine distinguish between commands to it and ambient conversation. You're right that it will continue to be a challenge remembering all the gestures... so the platform that trains more people up first in its unique gestural language will enjoy some network-effects lock-in.
- chestnut-tree 13y ago"Imagine a touch device that accepts...an ultra-precise fine-tipped stylus." I'm really hoping that this will happen soon. I know many designers who would love a pressure-sensitive drawing tablet (where you draw on the surface). Apart from digital drawing and animation, even photo editing and manipulation (like masking) is immeasurably more natural and easier to perform when using a pen directly on the surface of the screen. Right now there is only one serious contender in this market: Wacom. Their Cintiq brand lets you draw directly on the screen with a stylus. But the high cost of the product and the lack of competition means that hardly any movement has been made in this area for years. I keep hoping to see rival products, but it hasn't happened[1]. That's a great surprise (and disappointment). I find it hard to believe that this is just a niche market with limited appeal either. [1] Actually, there is one new rival that is getting some good reviews http://frenden.com/post/38693256477/yiynovamsp19u http://frenden.com/post/38693256477/yiynovamsp19u
- 13y ago