3 ms·
At least in computer science, most of the major conferences are double-blind reviewed. This means that it's more difficult to figure out whose paper one is revi
by cperciva 18y ago
At least in computer science, most of the major conferences are double-blind reviewed. This means that it's more difficult to figure out whose paper one is reviewing.
Theoretically, yes. In practice, anonymizing work is hard to do -- if you're prominent enough in a field to be asked to review papers, you probably have a good idea who is doing what work, and you'll probably be able to recognize authors' individual writing styles.
I've been asked to review "anonymized" papers in the past, but with the exception of one which wasn't really in my field (I wrote back to tell the editor that I didn't think I was qualified to review the paper, and he found other referees) I've always been pretty sure who the authors were.
- beetle_b 18y ago>if you're prominent enough in a field to be asked to review papers, There aren't that many prominent people in a given discipline (and some of them do a poor job in reviewing anyway - slow, etc). It's quite normal to have a nonprominent person do the reviewing. This is, after all, peer reviewing.