6 ms·
That doesn't mean they always come up with the "right" answers, or that there isn't vehement disagreement, but yes, they do in fact, thing long and hard about i
by rhizome 13y ago
That doesn't mean they always come up with the "right" answers, or that there isn't vehement disagreement, but yes, they do in fact, thing long and hard about it, and whether it is the right thing to do.
And so the definition of behavior that would qualify as "evil" varies even within Google itself, making the motto even squishier.
- DannyBee 13y agoOf course it varies, but that doesn't change anything about the value. You really think the moral values of right and wrong are completely consistent across people? The reason it's a corporate value is because it's part of the culture. There is an actual conscience at the company, and you try to hear, understand, and deal with concerns people have, internally and externally. You try to do the right thing, for the right reasons. The fact that you may not always achieve this, or that people may disagree on what the right thing is, changes nothing. The outside problem is that most people think "Don't be evil" means "don't do anything I <the user> morally disagree with". This would be a pointless value, as it would be both impossible and meaningless to achieve at any scale. There are plenty of moral values on which large populations of people have diametrically opposed views. For example, from the perspective of a large population of people, Google's stance on gay marriage is evil.
- rhizome 13y agoOne problem is that it's a slippery slope. Effectively, the ethic would appear to be that anything and everything can be done/implemented as long as nobody involved calls it evil.
- DannyBee 13y ago1. That isn't a slippery slope. A slippery slope is where once you start something, you can't stop it as it slowly erodes. In essence, once you start something down a slope, it will roll all the way to the bottom. There is nothing about what you have said that demonstrates this is a slippery slope. Maybe you meant to make the argument that once something is okay, you start down the path to everything being okay. This would be false, since outcomes, reactions, and viewpoints of previous things are raised when new things happen. It's not a court where once a ruling has been issued, that is the rule. 2. I'm really trying to understand your concern here, but, as written, seems to boil down to "if everyone is a bad person, bad things can happen". Since I assume this is not what you are trying to say, could you elaborate a bit?
- rhizome 13y agoEach decision builds a foundation of a status quo, defined as the sum total of the "this is not evil" decisions and designations made in the past, which constitutes a form of momentum (especially among those who don't want to rock the gBoat). This momentum is a force that affects the value system of the company's implementors and gating roles. It boils down to "bad things can happen even if everybody thinks they're working for good." Myopia becomes a bigger problem the older a company gets.
- DannyBee 13y agoBut for the reasons i've explained, it does not do this, and this is not how it operates in actuality. Maybe if the company had no turnover, no leadership changes, no nothing you could make this argument, becuase it would always be the same people. But it's not the same people, and even where it is, nobody sits around and asks "in light of us deciding this wasn't evil in the past, is it now okay to do X". That's not the question to be answered. It's not "is this evil in light of us having done similar things in the past", it's "is this evil". Don't get me wrong - The past is evidence, and data, for sure. It would be stupid to ignore reactions, viewpoints, etc. But the world changes, decisions look different in hindsight, society changes. If there was no evolution of thought, you would be right. But there is.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoTo expand on what DannyBee said, it can be a valid form of argument to say there is a slippery slope leading from A to B, but it turns into the "slippery slope fallacy" when it's not obvious how A necessarily turns into B and the possibility of a middle ground isn't acknowledged. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope
- pron 13y agoSuppose for a moment that Google really is as benevolent as you believe. You yourself admit that they do have a lot of power. In a democracy, we try not to put too much power even in the hands of an elected official. Isn't it a problem that so much power resides with a corporation? Should society trust Google's good intentions? But I even have doubts about Google's benevolence. What, a company that adopts a "don't be evil" motto is less likely to be evil than a company that doesn't? I'd be suspicious of a person that feels the need to declare that he'll do his best not murder anyone. By adopting the motto, Google had acknowledged the fact that corporations do tend to do evil. But is it because they intend to do so? Do chairmen and CEOs wake up in the morning all giddy about doing some evil or naughty, harmful, mischief today? Even Bernie Madoff didn't start out like this. And yet, corporations do evil in spite of people's best intentions. So Google said: we'll try to be careful. That's actually not bad, because I hope that that slogan makes the Google executives aware of the temptations and pitfalls that await all big firms. But I do not for a second believe that Google's executives are so much better than all other good people running large corporations that actually do evil. Because, hey -- power corrupts. Nobody likes getting up one day and realize they've become a Bond villain, so they don't: that is, they just don't realize it. Also, nobody really is an actual Bond villain (well, Hitler). Even good people do bad things. My point is, people do need a little help from the outside to protect them from themselves, and with that much power, Google needs a lot of help. Google has become a big problem.
- rhizome 13y agoShould society trust Google's good intentions? I would question whether society even knows enough about Google's intentions to be able to judge them as good or bad.
- DannyBee 13y agoIt's not clear what you are suggesting with the power questions. Breaking up Google? As for whether society should trust Google's intentions: I hope not. Society should be, in general, distrustful of corporations, and, for the most part, they are. That doesn't mean Google doesn't have good intentions, or that one should assume bad faith everywhere. At the same time, what was questioned originally was the operation of that corporation and it's people, and that's what i responded to :) As for the adoption of the motto: The original outside publication of this was done while going public, and was intended to make clear to wall street that Google wasn't going to maximize profit at the expense of everything else, where everything else usually involves doing morally questionable things. I think you read way too much into it. "But I do not for a second believe that Google's executives are so much better than all other good people running large corporations that actually do evil. Because, hey -- power corrupts." All I would say to this is I hope you get to meet them some day. Except for one, I can say they really are better than all the other good people i've met running other large corporations. They are honestly good people, and honestly care about doing right. In the end, I guess we just disagree. I don't believe Google has become a big problem, and I don't think Google needs a lot of help from the outside to protect them from themselves. In fact, I think help from "the outside" would make things a lot worse. For example, the last time I looked, the outside wants Google to try to detect when people are doing bad things, and report them.
- Selfcommit 13y agoThat sounds quite a bit like a "Good Intention" There's a saying about a road covered in those...
- DannyBee 13y agoWhile a nice sound bite, do you have a better suggestion?
- rhizome 13y agoThey could give stockholders veto power over product changes.
- rictic 13y agoI'm not sure I follow the logic. Large financial institutions hold a lot of stock, and their ethical track record is.. fraught.
- DannyBee 13y agoFor starters, they already have. Larry and Sergey have the majority voting power, and they have veto power over product changes :) But that's probably not what you meant, so i'm going to assume you meant give "non-preferred stock holders veto power over product changes". I'm not sure what this would accomplish, since institutional investors are not exactly who you want deciding the fate of products. Timeline wise, they are too short term of thinkers. Ethically, they are often very suspect. Strategically, most lack the knowledge to make the right decisions, and even if you gave it to them, they lack the experience. What you are suggesting is almost identical to hiring a large set of outside consultants, bringing them into a well-functioning company, and letting them veto every product decision at the exec level or below. Worse the consultants would be experienced in say "women's shoes", and the company would be one that did something like "making airplanes" I'm pretty sure i know where this leads, and it isn't "don't be evil" :)
- cbsmith 13y agoHey, when you find that world where what is "evil" is so damn absolute that there needn't be any thought or debate as to what course of action would avoid doing evil, can you pick up a unicorn for me? I could use one.