4 ms·
Lipitor is a single terrible drug from a pointless class of drugs that actually increase average mortality in people who take them. High cholesterol is associa
by pessimizer 13y ago
Lipitor is a single terrible drug from a pointless class of drugs that actually increase average mortality in people who take them.
High cholesterol is associated with higher risk of heart attacks, but lowering cholesterol isn't associated with a lowering of heart attack risk. In addition, the side effects are vile and costs are high.
The most depressing thing about the modern pharmaceutical industry is that its two biggest cash cows, statins and the modern new-school psychotropics, have very little evidence that they actually help anyone, and involve lobbying budgets the size of small nation's GDPs to keep the gravy train going.
- hga 13y agoYou could be right about statins, although I gather for some they appear to be a good idea. My doctors are pushing them on me, I'm firing the doctors sequentially hoping to get one who will listen (e.g. absolutely no cardiovascular disease in a long lived family) ... the major argument for their being first line treatment is that nothing less works in practice (e.g. "get more exercise). However that doesn't change the principle WRT to drug development today. What "modern new-school psychotropics" are you referring to? That's a field I know a fair amount about, and I don't see the problem you're citing at all (which is not to say some aren't over-prescribed, but I believe that is a different problem). I would probably be very ill or dead without one (low dose, off label Seroquel to treat anxiety which I have a family disposition towards; it's the difference between 4 and 7 hours of sleep a night, bright light treatment gets me the final extra hour I need). It and the other atypical anti-psychotics seem to be a lot better than the older "typical" ones, and those were miracle drugs, something witnessed by my mother when she was a nurse. Similarly, the current Prozac and beyond anti-depressants are maybe not quite as effective as the previous tricyclics but their side effect profiles are a whole lot better, e.g. making it more likely a patient will wait those out long enough for the therapeutic effect to begin, and I personally benefit from a laser specific SSRI (doesn't touch anything else), since "wrong" anti-depressants can make me manic.
- robbiep 13y agoIf you're taking seroquel that is probably a good reason to be on a statin given the current medical evidence as you have an increased risk of metabolic syndrome due to being on an antipsychotic.
- hga 13y agoLow dose, though, this is an off-label use, it's not for schizophrenia or bipolar disorder where a bare minimum of 4? times that is needed (and as I remember its dosing is non-linear). I haven't followed the current info on atypical anti-psychotics possibly inducing metabolic syndrome or worse, but I do watch for signs of it. And that's not why my PCPs are pushing statins, it's because of my lipid levels. Which, strangely enough, are exactly where they were in 1999, they got a bit better for a while, and are now back to a level that wasn't considered worthy of dangerous medical intervention back then. No doubt there are those who suspect previously not so bad lipid levels are actually bad; me, having watched the drama of lipids and health since around when it first became a big thing, and all the revisions in the conventional wisdom, I'm ... a bit more conservative with all that.
- robbiep 13y agoWell sounds like you have a good handle on your health inputs! Good on you.
- carbocation 13y agoStatins are among the most scientifically supported class of drugs ever created. Your assessment is both wrong and potentially harmful if somehow treated as credible. I have zero financial bias in making this statement.
- pessimizer 13y agoNo they are not, and my assessment is not wrong. I also have zero financial bias in making this statement. Does it add to the discussion?