5 ms·
> Even 10 times higher quantum efficiency shooting wide open on optical band targets would be physically impossible. Could you tell more about the limitations?
by scotty79 13y ago
> Even 10 times higher quantum efficiency shooting wide open on optical band targets would be physically impossible.
Could you tell more about the limitations? I always felt current sensors are very insensitive and hoped that the sensitivity could be improved immensely. Even sensitivity such as cats eyes have would be awesome.
- ska 13y agoI think the efficiency of these sensors is quite good, latest generation full frame camera sensor operate well at lower ligh t than you can see in, for example. Fitting more of them into tiny arrays and maintaining exposed surface is more of a problem, and noise properties could be better. At the end of the day though, there are limits to what can ever be achieved with tiny sensors like we currently see in most cel phones; you can pack things in more tightly but you can't avoid the optical physics.
- dietrichepp 13y agoSure, I'll explain. Once you start working with extremely sensitive sensors in very dim lighting conditions, you are basically counting the number of photons hitting each pixel. Quantum efficiency is a measure of the percentage of photons which are counted. A quick Google search turns up a paper measuring quantum efficiency of a CMOS sensor, with the sensor in question measured at 37% (meaning a 3x improvement is physically impossible): http://www-isl.stanford.edu/~abbas/group/papers_and_pub/qe_spie_98.pdf http://www-isl.stanford.edu/~abbas/group/papers_and_pub/qe_s... If you want to see what that translates to, look at high-end cameras. Bigger cameras tend to be more sensitive because the pixels are larger, and the support circuitry takes up a lower percentage of the surface area, leaving more of the sensor's surface area for the actual sensor. The current generation of DSLRs can go up to ISO 25,600 (or higher, actually). Searching Flickr will show you a number of pictures in extreme low light, taken without a tripod, yielding better detail than I expect my eyes would be able to discern (note: humans, compared to most animals, have excellent night vision). http://www.flickr.com/search/?q=iso25600 http://www.flickr.com/search/?q=iso25600 If you're willing to sacrifice resolution you can get even more sensitivity, which enables you to do crazy things like shoot video of the Milky Way or a moonlit landscape. An experimental Canon video sensor shows this off: http://petapixel.com/2013/03/04/canon-unveils-a-35mm-full-frame-sensor-for-video-that-can-see-in-the-dark/ http://petapixel.com/2013/03/04/canon-unveils-a-35mm-full-fr... By comparison, film has quantum efficiency below 10%, at least according to Wikipedia. Photographers were quick to ditch film in the ISO 800+ range, and I rarely use film as fast as ISO 400 since digital is so much more sensitive.
- porker 13y agoThank you for that explanation, very clear!
- Zoepfli 13y agoSo if only a 3x improvement is theoretically possible, how do you explain that the article talks about a 1000x improvement?
- davidcuddeback 13y agoI think the GP's point was to call that claim into question. I'm sceptical about the 1000x improvement claim as well. CCD sensors manufactured for astrophotography achieve 60+% quantum efficiency.
- theguycalledtom 13y agoUsing the latest DSLRs you can film under moonlight now. https://vimeo.com/21311814 https://vimeo.com/21311814 What we need is lower noise.
- unicornporn 13y agoCan you see how many light sources there are close to the beach in many of the shots? Watch the shape and size of the shadows that girl casts on the sand. Moonlight only? Not so much...
- theguycalledtom 13y agoAre you kidding me? At 1m15s you can actually see the stars behind her.