3 ms·
Part of the problem is that there's a mismatch between the education being provided and what employers need and want. A brand new Computer Science graduate isn
by mindcrime 13y ago
Part of the problem is that there's a mismatch between the education being provided and what employers need and want. A brand new Computer Science graduate isn't usually terribly qualified to do what most employers, who hire CS graduates, want them to do, which is to write code and build programs / systems.
Why is this? Well, part of it is because, as always, a liberal arts degree isn't meant to be job training in the first place. This gap is especially pronounced with software people though, since a CS degree can be very theoretical and: A. might teach a lot of "stuff" that most programmer's don't use (or don't use very often), B. doesn't always include enough of the "stuff" that programmer's do need, and C. can be overly general, when "practice" in this field is highly specialized and includes lots of niches.
Another part is because employers don't do enough to fill in the gaps and help train younger employees. Ideally, employers would hire new CS graduates and spend a year or more grooming them, teaching then the specialized skills they need in that specific domain, and helping them ramp up. But American employers are so averse to providing training, taking a long-term view, and "playing the long game" that it's ridiculous.
One thing that might help, would be if more schools started offering a Software Engineering degree in addition to Computer Science degrees, and if more students started choosing the SE degree. But even then, again, a liberal arts degree isn't supposed to be "job training" and the SE degree would still probably turn into more theory and not enough "how to actually build something" than what employers would want.
Net-net, I think employers are going to have to bite the bullet at some point, and accept that you have to hire and groom "green" people if you want to compete. And maybe universities should start offering a few more classes on the "nuts and bolts" aspects of building systems. Perhaps some partnerships between universities and local community colleges could be involved.
No matter what, though, I don't think you're going to be able to look for fresh graduates who, for example, walk in the door knowing Hibernate, Spring, PostgreSQL, Camel, JMS, Lucene, Maven, Ant, JUnit, SAX, JDOM, STaX, JSON, Hadoop, etc. But, unfortunately, employers are largely looking for folks to walk in the door ready to contribute with highly specialized skills from day one.
- btilly 13y agoDid you actually read the article? Computer Science graduates are doing OK. It is Information Science graduates who are in pain here.
- mindcrime 13y agoDid you actually read the article? Please don't do that. That kind of snark doesn't add anything to the conversation and creates antagonism where there should be none. Computer Science graduates are doing OK. It is Information Science graduates who are in pain here. No, Information Science graduates are just in more pain. And that's entirely expected, as a recent IS graduate is even less prepared to go out and work in the "IT World" than a recent CS graduate... if you assume that's a reasonable career path for them (and given the limited number of academic jobs, it probably is).
- btilly 13y agoThe whole point of the article was that there are tons of IS grads to hire, so Silicon Valley's problem is that they are too selective about which stem graduates to hire, and not that there is a shortage of talent. Replying, as you did, about the problems with computer science degree is talking about at most a tangentially related subject. Hence my response. On how CS grads are doing, new grads have an unemployment rate below the general public, in an age range where unemployment is much higher than the general public. And if you go out a few years, unemployment drops in half. This sucks if you are one of the unemployed, but overall I consider this doing fine.
- mindcrime 13y agoReplying, as you did, about the problems with computer science degree is talking about at most a tangentially related subject. I'm not only talking about problems with the degree itself, I'm talking about a mismatch between "skills sought" and "skills possessed". This is true regardless of whether your degree is Computer Science, Information Science, Software Engineering, Math or "Other". And in either case, I posit that a significant step towards addressing the problem would be for employers to return to a mindset of "we'll hire green people and train them in the more specialized skills" as opposed to expecting everybody to come in with tons of highly specialized knowledge.
- greggman 13y ago> Ideally, employers would hire new CS graduates and spend a year or more grooming them, teaching then the specialized skills they need in that specific domain, and helping them ramp up Please No. That is what they do in Japan and I'd feel that's the number one reason programmers get paid shit in Japan. They hire straight out of school with no experience with salaries starting at around $30k. At 15 years experience you'll make somewhere between $45k and $60k. Programmers in Japan make less than flight attendants http://www.worldsalaries.org/japan.shtml http://www.worldsalaries.org/japan.shtml Some people would say that's a reason they're in trouble. As the world switched to software being more important then hardware they didn't switch to valuing those that make software.
- TheCoelacanth 13y agoProgrammers get paid poorly in Japan because Japanese culture doesn't respect software. It has nothing to do with the way they are trained.
- jiggy2011 13y agoWhy does Japanese culture not respect software?
- greggman 13y agoIt does have to do with they way they are trained. If you have a culture that highers starting at $30k with no experience that has to affect overall salaries. Why pay for experience when you can just take next years cheap graduates? In fact Japan even goes so far as to not hire programmers over 35. Programmers are considered jobs for people 21 to 35. Just go read some jobs ads in Japanese.
- joyeuse6701 13y agomm, I'm not aware of any software giants from Japan, hardware giants however... Yay stagflation and such!
- jiggy2011 13y agoProviding general job training would be difficult as programmers work is very diverse and spans many industries. There is also not really such a thing as "industry standard" tools the way that there is for some other industries. Web technology is in vogue now, but you could spend 3 years teaching people rails and node.js only to have them graduate and find that the world is moving on to something else and now embedded programming knowledge is more important.