3 ms·
The best evidence we have so far indicates that this is a very bad idea. Do we have evidence that indicates the alternative is any better? There's nothing that
by sliverstorm 13y ago
The best evidence we have so far indicates that this is a very bad idea.
Do we have evidence that indicates the alternative is any better? There's nothing that says both options can't be terrible.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- snowwrestler 13y agoThe U.S. has not followed a program of austerity, and our economy and hiring is recovering faster than Europe's.
- sliverstorm 13y agoApples and oranges. The U.S. didn't crash as hard, and doesn't have some of the EU's unique challenges.
- jckt 13y agoLikewise the converse statement is true and, I believe, important to mention explicitly: the USA has a uniquely advantageous position in this world.
- fauigerzigerk 13y agoBut those unique challenges don't indicate that the U.S approach wouldn't work, they just explain why it isn't chosen.
- alipang 13y agoSweden here. Went through heavy austerity in the 90s. Things going comparatively good now, just to give you some anectodal evidence for the contrary position.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- JamisonM 13y agoCanada too, but it a largely inapplicable data point in both cases. First of all for both countries there is no evidence that our lending rates would have increase without the 90's austerity, so its actual value was dubious in the first place. Secondly, as nations mostly on the edge of the global financial storm we are not very interesting, we do not have a huge overhang of private debt that has drastically collapsed demand and crushed our tax base. (Canada has a large amount of private debt but since house values have held that debt is not an "overhang" it just sitting there, I can't speak for Sweden.) That is what put these countries in the positions they are in.
- fauigerzigerk 13y agoInterestingly though, things are going to be reversed in 2013: "The 17 countries that share the euro will have halved the pace of budget consolidation in 2013 compared to 2012, as the overall budget deficit of the euro zone fell by 1.5 percent of GDP in 2012 but will only shrink a further 0.75 percent this year, the European Commission forecast this month. The United States plan to reduce their budget deficit by 2 percent of GDP in 2013 against 2012. Unless policies change the overall euro zone consolidation will be only 0.1 percent of GDP in 2014, the Commission said, against 1 percent in the U.S." http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/05/27/us-eu-economy-idUSBRE94Q0EL20130527 http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/05/27/us-eu-economy-idUS... But the U.S is coming down from a higher level.
- JamisonM 13y agoSure, post-WW1 France vs. Britain are a fairly good natural experiment that was conducted - France devalued and Britain did not, and despite the natural advantage of not being destroyed in the war France's economy generally outperformed Britain's anyway. In the current situation one can look at the US vs. Europe though that is more of a less-austerity vs. more-austerity example and of the course, as with all natural experiments the two subjects are not entirely the same. That, and the economic models that are consistent with recent behaviour in these economies are saying that the alternative is better. Also, we know the trade-off here - austerity is bad for wage-earners, the poor, people with few, no, or negative assets in the denominated currency. Inflation is bad for net asset-holders in the denominated currency and importers. Now, given that most of the vulnerable people in a society fall into one group that can be a moral basis for action and it is easy to see which side of the political spectrum is more likely to align on each particular side of the debate. (I post this feeling assured you probably won't read the response since a whole day has passed, but what the heck!)