5 ms·
Much popular misinformation notwithstanding, the balance of risk between vaccination and not vaccinating is extremely lopsided. No, vaccination is not perfectl
by btilly 13y ago
Much popular misinformation notwithstanding, the balance of risk between vaccination and not vaccinating is extremely lopsided. No, vaccination is not perfectly safe. But it is safer than getting sick. And for anyone who is immune compromised (the very young, the very old, people receiving chemotherapy, those with AIDS, etc) their only protection is to have everyone else vaccinated.
The question is at what point your acting on your fringe beliefs are allowed to kill other people, and what liability you should have for it.
And no, this is not a hypothetical point. We have concrete cases of dead babies and known infection vectors. We really can say, "Your decision to not vaccinate killed that baby." In that case why shouldn't you be liable for criminally negligent manslaughter?
- dragonwriter 13y ago> In that case why shouldn't you be liable for criminally negligent manslaughter? Because causing death through actions which demonstrate depraved indifference to the risk to human life is murder [1], not manslaughter. [1] http://criminal.findlaw.com/criminal-charges/second-degree-murder-overview.html http://criminal.findlaw.com/criminal-charges/second-degree-m...
- btilly 13y agoI think that "depraved indifference to the risk to human life" is a hard standard to meet when the person who didn't vaccinate honestly believed that the vaccine posed a larger risk to their child than their unvaccinated child posed to everyone else. Compare to http://criminal.findlaw.com/criminal-charges/involuntary-manslaughter-overview.html http://criminal.findlaw.com/criminal-charges/involuntary-man... where the equivalent is "The act either was inherently dangerous to others or done with reckless disregard for human life." The "inherently dangerous to others" standard is much, much easier to prove. And it is easy to prove regardless of the mistaken beliefs of the (ir)responsible parent.
- jlgreco 13y agoIn the general case yes, I think you are right. It is however fairly easy to conceive of scenarios where an individuals inability to understand risks posed by their actions becomes very blurred with a refusal to understand the risks. Typhoid Mary for example was informed numerous times that she was posing a risk and the fact that they were able to re-find her after she changed her name by following her carnage should have been proof enough to her that they were probably right. I think you could make a reasonable case that Typhoid Mary had a depraved indifference to the risk to human life, even though she claimed to not believe the doctors. Edit: If you understand herd immunity and decide that you do not care (such as eip here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5802206 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5802206) then you surely have a depraved indifference to human life. Moreso even than Typhoid Mary could be said to have.
- btilly 13y agoFor Typhoid Mary, yes. But for most of the cases, you'd have a much harder standard to meet. Here is an interesting problem. Suppose that we trace a disease through 5 unvaccinated children from the one who picked it up in a foreign country, to the one who passed it on to the baby who died. Who is liable? All 5? The one who passed it on? The one who went to a foreign country while unvaccinated?
- jlgreco 13y agoAll those who reasonably had the opportunity to provide their child with a recommended (recommended by who could be debated. I would throw out the CDC as a first suggestion) vaccine that had the possibility of preventing the outbreak, but chose not to. I think it would be better to tax or fine those who chose to abstain from vaccinating their children than to wait until an incident occurs and try to sue people. Much easier, and it does a better job of driving home the point that by refusing to vaccinate your child you are damaging herd immunity, not just potentially killing particular people.
- lignuist 13y agoWe also have concrete cases of negative effects of vaccination and as long this is the case, forcing people to take these risks, just to lower the vague risks for others people's babies is ridiculous. Maybe people shouldn't expose their babies to the public as long as they are so vulnerable. Probably safer than requiring that everybody else is vaccinated...
- jlgreco 13y agoThere is nothing vague about herd immunity; it is very well understood.
- lignuist 13y agoBy vague I mean that there is no guarantee that babies die, just because I'm not vaccinated. It's not even very likely. Taking the probability of damages due to vaccination into account, we are trading one person's safety against the safety of a baby that shouldn't be in the public as long as it is too vulnerable. So maybe the parents of that baby should be liable at first. Nobody will ever be able to guarantee a germ-free world out there.
- jlgreco 13y agoIf the baby was killed by something that you, a willfully unvaccinated person (or your child, who you willfully did not vaccinate), were carrying, and the source of the infection can be said be you (or your child) more likely than not, then that should be more than enough for a civil trial. Were we talking about criminal charges, then the evidence would need to be stronger. In reality, we can track the progression of disease much better than "more likely than not". This is something that we have gotten quite good at doing. The importance of "100% guarantees" exists only in your imagination. Nothing in the real world works that way.
- lignuist 13y agoEven in my imagination there is no 100% guarantee. And so there is no 100% safe and germ-free world for babies out there. If people take their vulnerable babies to the public, then nobody but them is responsible if this is too much for the baby. People can be agents of germs, even if they are vaccinated, so vaccination is not really protecting these babies and especially not by 100%. Requiring (or pushing) people to take medicine to protect others people's health is like putting the cart before the horse.