3 ms·
This is a hack piece. The paragraph most indicative of this? "This guy failed to make a major dent in music, and then moved into gaming because he thought he
by angersock 13y ago
This is a hack piece.
The paragraph most indicative of this?
"This guy failed to make a major dent in music, and then moved into gaming because he thought he was good at Battlefield. He knew, KNEW, that he would be a valued member of any team, and he would rapidly move up to the ranks. He gets angry that he has to do many different tasks, although that's often part of the job. He gets mad that management doesn't allow them to be unprofessional on chat programs. He gets mad that he doesn't get the raise he thinks he so honestly deserves. He stops coming into work during his last two weeks. He seems to think that someone liking an idea puts him on the path to being a designer."
I know that Ben has made his living being an enraged mouth-breather on the 'net for many years now (before Penny Arcade, he was a resident ragemonger at Ars Technica), but really the sad thing here is that he'd still write this.
Do we really want to mock people for the audacity of trying to contribute to a team? For asking for a raise after doing work, only to have it bounce through two or three layers of bureaucracy? For trying to succeed doing something they love, making a go of it for years, and then trying something else?
This is just mean-spirited, this is just cruel. This surely cannot be the type of sentiment we'd like to see in the games industry, and even though we can't ignore it we ought not endorse it.
Then again, what do I know? I don't get payed to be an angry asshole on the internet making fun of other people who are actually trying to do cool things.
(I have to do it for free.)
- josh2600 13y agoBoth pieces feel hackish to me. In the valley, the monoculture here suggests that this man in the QA environment did not do enough to succeed. In other cultures, it might be said that he wasn't given an opportunity to succeed. I suspect the truth is somewhere in the middle. What do we know about big gaming companies? AAA titles are expensive and if you pay people a lot of money to test your games, that lowers your margins. OP should concentrate on getting some marketable skills and the replying author should consider not wasting his breath. Both of these articles would be better off never having been written.
- loupeabody 13y agoMean-spirited indeed. I don't really see what rebutting in such a venomous tone is meant to inspire in readers, besides more vitriol and less constructive discussion. It's a shame that this sort of writing is broadcast with such a high profile. In defense of Ben though, I feel the original piece is pretty crass. That is, the author, Nathan, assumes so much self-importance that he feels justified in trying to incite an industry-wide strike of QA contractors. I suspect his experience, or at least his attitude towards working in QA, is pretty common among QA contractors. I seriously feel like if the average Ruby Tuesday's waiter had an outlet like Kotaku to vet his/her frustrations about unresponsive management and lack of respect, they'd say something similar. Not to completely disqualify the Nathan's feelings, there certainly may be systemic organizational and operational issues with QA and other parts of the games industry, but there's nothing outrageous about it.
- stcredzero 13y ago> That is, the author, Nathan, assumes so much self-importance that he feels justified in trying to incite an industry-wide strike of QA contractors. I see some parallels with the world of customer service call centers and the hospitality industry. The much of industry and management see the job as low skilled and the employees as disposable. If you look closer, there's actually a big difference between the crappy employees and the good ones, it's just that direct measures are difficult and there's a culture of looking down on those professions.
- bashinator 13y ago> if the average Ruby Tuesday's waiter had an outlet like Kotaku to vet his/her frustrations about unresponsive management and lack of respect, they'd say something similar. They do - it's at http://www.reddit.com/r/TalesFromYourServer http://www.reddit.com/r/TalesFromYourServer and honestly, I have a lot more sympathy for what most of the people telling their stories there go through.
- gohrt 13y agoFast food servers in Seattle are on strike for higher wags right now, so, your analogy is... interesting.
- enraged_camel 13y ago>>I know that Ben has made his living being an enraged mouth-breather on the 'net for many years now (before Penny Arcade, he was a resident ragemonger at Ars Technica), but really the sad thing here is that he'd still write this. His ragemongering is what made him successful. He's an immature douchebag and he writes for an immature, douchebaggy audience. It makes complete sense that he would write a piece like this. I was very disappointed when he was hired by Penny-Arcade. Character-wise, he really, really does not fit in with Mike and Jerry.