5 ms·
MoarVM: A virtual machine for NQP and Rakudo
- masak 13y agoI just wrote a post about MoarVM, too: http://strangelyconsistent.org/blog/a-vm-for-6model http://strangelyconsistent.org/blog/a-vm-for-6model . Slightly more slanted towards how this fits into the evolution of Perl 6 implementations.
- disinterest 13y agoWow, they are really good at starting things.
- patrickas 13y agoRight... start things... keep evolving them and getting better... and hopefully never end. I think that's the plan.
- disinterest 13y agoNever end? More like never deliver.
- patrickas 13y agoIt seems to me they deliver a release every month. http://rakudo.org/downloads/star/ http://rakudo.org/downloads/star/ Same as firefox... or chrome... or any other project on a continuous release cycle.
- disinterest 13y agoFirefox and Chrome have actual users who get stuff done, probably because their developers have a track record of releasing useful software. Perl 6 has a track record of not being useful, but I'm sure /this/ time they'll buck that trend.
- espadrine 13y agoYour belief that Perl6 won't go mainstream doesn't lessen their achievements. Beyond that, your attitude is easy to compare to a 2000s "SSJS will never succeed".
- disinterest 13y agoIf 13 years of futility still leave you optimistic, your mind is far more open than mine.
- PommeDeTerre 13y agoWhat exactly is the achievement here? I'm not certain that yet another mostly-incomplete virtual machine will really help the Perl 6 community much. They've already got that with Parrot. The whole emphasis on targeting virtual machines, whether it's Parrot, or the JVM, or now this MoarVM, has harmed the ability of Perl 6 to be implemented. We've seen one partial implementation after another, for years on end. Unfortunately, we can't actually use any of these implementations for anything serious, like we can with Perl 5, Python, and Ruby. This makes Perl 6 unusable, which is quite a shame.
- chromatic 13y agoWe've seen one partial implementation after another, for years on end. That's the second most disappointing part. The Parrot developers had a strong push between two and three years ago to redesign the internals to be a better fit for Rakudo along these lines (better runcore, easier JITting, improvements to the core object model, representation polymorphism), but the reaction from the Rakudo developers was a mixture of "No, thank you!", "Not yet.", and "If you have to, but don't change any APIs or behavior that Rakudo counts on." It's a shame this couldn't have all been done at the same time. The available volunteer knowledge and interest might have saved two or three years of Perl 6 floundering around in the netherworld of big promises and very modest realities. The most disappointing part is realizing that this sets back the potential delivery date of a usable Perl 6 by at least another couple of years. I guess that shouldn't be a surprise by now though.
- 13y ago
- jedharris 13y agoRegarding "What achievement can Perl 6 claim?" At least one is 6Model itself -- a generic object semantics and API which has been back ported to Perl 5, has been ported to the JVM (with a lot of optimization still pending) and as we see here is a reasonable design for part of a VM API. As far as I know 6Model is the only candidate around for a low level object model that is flexible enough to implement the object semantics in most languages, low level enough to be be efficiently implemented in most VMs, etc.
- jedharris 13y agoIf anyone is curious look at https://github.com/jnthn/6model/blob/master/overview.pod https://github.com/jnthn/6model/blob/master/overview.pod There may be more comprehensive / current documentation out there but I don't know where.
- chromatic 13y agoa generic object semantics and API which has been back ported to Perl 5 Do you mean Moose or the abandoned Perl 5 MOP experiment?
- jedharris 13y agoBoth, I guess, though claiming Moose is better PR.
- jedharris 13y agoI don't know enough history here. The current Moose docs say "Moose is built on top of Class::MOP" so maybe there was a different MOP effort that succeeded? That MOP is probably closer to 6Model than Moose itself.
- chromatic 13y agoMoose and Class::MOP predate 6Model. As far as I remember and can verify, Moose 1.0 was out (spring 2010) before 6Model even existed or had a name (late 2010). Moose did take inspiration from the object model designed for Perl 6, but it grew out of attempts to implement that object model in Pugs, not Rakudo. You might even say that it was the first full implementation of the Perl 6 object model.