3 ms·
> Though there are QA positions that require a higher level of expertise and knowledge, the people doing regression testing on a game are not them. I suspect t
by stcredzero 13y ago
> Though there are QA positions that require a higher level of expertise and knowledge, the people doing regression testing on a game are not them.
I suspect that's a self fulfilling prophecy there.
> The difference between a really great QA tester and an okay QA tester is probably less than 2x.
If you're going to treat people like QA people like they're low skilled, and that they really make no difference as people, then you're going to get wind up with people like that. QA can be more than just kitty on the keyboard button pushing. Customer service has been thought of this way, and unsurprisingly, companies got lots of mediocre and bad outcomes. Zappos shows that this doesn't necessarily have to be the case.
- sdoowpilihp 13y ago> If you're going to treat people like QA people like they're low skilled, and that they really make no difference as people, then you're going to get wind up with people like that. I wasn't saying that. What I was trying to say is that this style of Quality Assurance tends to have a throughput that scales linearly. There are a lot of professions like that, even highly skilled ones. For example, traditional hand drawn animation (think Bambi or any other classic disney movie) requires highly skilled artists. And though some of those artists maybe faster than others or more proficient, it is nowhere on the scale of what you might see with a profession such as software development. A few A+ developers can probably build a system that can support just as many users just as fast as a much larger C team. The same isn't true for a feature animated film, in which a single person will hit a physical limit to the number of drawings they can create in a day, or for QA'ing a game, where the number of areas that can be tested or bugs that can be found is also bound, and where the quality of the product created does not directly influence productivity by orders of magnitude.
- stcredzero 13y ago> The same isn't true for a feature animated film, in which a single person will hit a physical limit to the number of drawings they can create in a day, or for QA'ing a game, where the number of areas that can be tested or bugs that can be found is also bound, and where the quality of the product created does not directly influence productivity by orders of magnitude. This makes me wonder how Valve does QA. Also, note that QA of this kind has the same kind of scaling as customer service. The raw measured throughput may not vary that much. Quality could vary a lot, however.