3 ms·
Amidst the general decline in quality of publications on the Web, it's great to see Wired, which put out lots of fluffy, inaccurate stuff in the past, publishin
by leephillips 13y ago
Amidst the general decline in quality of publications on the Web, it's great to see Wired, which put out lots of fluffy, inaccurate stuff in the past, publishing so many solid, interesting articles. This was fun to read, had actual equations and graphs, and made sense. I remember reading the headline about charging a phone in 20 seconds and not bothering to look at the details, because, no way.
- crymer11 13y agoInteresting, certainly. That said, I found this article frustrating to read because of the many spelling and grammatical errors; I don't want to start on stylistic issues. Does Wired not have a copy editor on staff? For example, two that quickly caught my eye: * "... just a plain boring capacitor." should have a comma between coordinate adjectives. * "... the case were stuff is in the middle ..." should be "where" instead of "were".
- aidenn0 13y agoIs my sarcasm detector broken? This is a fluffy inaccurate post masked by a bunch of equations any apt high school physics student could have gotten from their textbook. Nobody uses mica capacitors for high energy-density applications, electrochemical EDLC's have much higher energy densities. Furthermore switching regulators that can operate the phone relatively independent of input voltage are cheap and efficient. Yes the other articles about this were bizarre, no, cell phone battery replacement (where nobody seems to mind plugging them in at night, and ED is king) are not a good application for any capacitor in the foreseeable future, but this article is hardly better. More nitpicks: "The news reports don’t actually state how much energy the storage device can store." when the story showed up on HN, I searched google news for a few words from the headline and found the ED in one of the top 5 links. I don't remember the exact number, but it was on the order of a SLA starter battery (so lower than a deep-cycle SLA battery). Clearly not in cell-phone territory.
- leephillips 13y agoI was not being sarcastic, so don't worry about your detector. This was the way a physicist would take a first look at the problem, so I could relate and I enjoyed it. You and some other critics here are taking the author to task for not writing a detailed electrical engineering analysis, but I don't think that's entirely fair. Although the article is not completely accurate in that sense, it's also not "fluffy", and much better than the stuff that caused me to write Wired off until recently. Scoff if you must, but physicists are fond of their spherical cows and mica capacitors.
- aidenn0 13y agoTo take the spherical-cow analogy further, this article is a bit like responding to a headline of "New non-spherical cow shape way more efficient than spherical shape, promises free milk for everyone!" by doing an approximation with a spherical cow. Particularly when a tiny bit of googling turns up actual numbers claimed for the cow in the experiment.
- benjamincburns 13y ago> You and some other critics here... You're probably referring to me, since I've been posting all over this thread and I did nothing to preface my criticisms. I really didn't mean to "take the author to task," and I was as astonished and happy as you were to see this piece in Wired. This was just something I became interested in when the news first hit, and for whatever reason I've enjoyed talking about it and breaking it down more than usual. The only thing I'd criticize him for was that he's basing his back-of-the-envelope on some arbitrary things (the 6V rating and choice of a ceramic/mica dielectric, for instance) rather than trying to base it on an appropriate lower bound. Had he done the latter he would've reached the same conclusion but with a far less outlandish example. It's only bad because relatively small supercaps which would have worked for his example do exist (much to the chagrin of the news stories he's criticizing), and his example makes it look like he's suggesting otherwise.
- leephillips 13y ago"You're probably referring to me" No, your comments were informative while politely avoiding direct criticism of the author. And you make another good point here.