3 ms·
Swine flu: Twitter's power to misinform
- nopassrecover 18y agoI'm not a big Twitter fan but pretty much this article is claiming "Twitter allows people to post what they might otherwise say in general conversation. People are saying things that can cause panic and so people who take what others say at face value without confirmation will also be panicked." The most alarming statement in this article was "The question of whether we need to somehow alter our global information flows during global pandemics is not a trivial one". Fight fear with education, not with censorship.
- lucumo 18y agoThe problem is that education about the current situation is not reaching them very well. The author suggested that health organisations put updates online as soon and as often as possible. Injecting education into the online information stream if you will. Maybe directly into Twitter even. If some (hopefully recognised) experts were to start Twittering "pork does not kill you", the fear would be culled. Anyway, I doubt this mass hysteria will really be all that huge if things don't get worse. The current situation is still pretty new.
- Tichy 18y agoThat article could not even quote any severely misinformed tweets. Is it being misinformed to be worried a little bit? Also, the article focused on tweets of scared users, there might be zillions of tweets by users who are not scared. I think if anything, the whole issue might make people reflect more on things they read and hear, which would be a good thing. Other than that, the same kind of articles have probably written years ago, if you replace "twitter" with "internet" or "wikipedia". While I don't panic, I find the whole thing interesting because I have never actually witnessed a pandemic. My first epidemic I witnessed last christmass, when the whole family suddenly had a vomitting virus. That was a bit scary. A global epidemic would therefore be really scary. Since few people have experience with this, worrying seems like a sane reaction. Or would the appropriate reaction be "I am sure the government will handle it fine, and if anything serious was going on, they would surely warn me on TV"?
- lucumo 18y agoIt is misinformed to say that you shouldn't eat pork, yes. But I don't blame the misinformed ones, as you seem to imply. I'm just thinking of solutions to help people grasp the situation better. Being afraid is - currently - somewhat an overreaction if you don't live in Mexico City. Not eating pork is probably healthy, but completely misinformed if used to ward of the pig flu. You have a point though, when you say the article focuses on one side. Maybe there are very informed tweets and maybe people are corrected if they say something stupid.
- idle7 18y agoi think the author didn't really mean censorship; altering is also possible on a micro-level with users adopting a higher level of editorial standards...
- nopassrecover 18y agoThis is twitter - that's like asking people to have a higher editorial standard on SMS messages to their friends.
- idle7 18y agowell - how about stop sending messages if you can't trust the information you are spreading? that's what i meant by editorial standards. so yes, it's censorship of sorts, but it's more like self-censorship - or self-restraint to be more exact.
- Tichy 18y agoTwitter users are still capable of using google. So if somebody tweets about a pandemic, the next reactions of twitter users would probably be to google it. I don't think they are stupid sheep who just do whatever their twitter-friends tell them. It is still useful information to hear that worries about a pandemic have arisen, no matter if the advice for actions is right or wrong.
- idle7 18y agowell, as we've seen, many people were re-tweeting false advice ("don't eat pork") without bothering to check anything on google...
- Tichy 18y agoAh, I didn't even notice that some people seem to think it is transmitted via eating pork. But did they get retweeted a lot? Still not convinced that it is worse than email, for example - like those meme-viri that keep spreading via email.
- joeter 18y agoI was testing this last night... The twitter search was interesting because after your first query, it dynamically updates a display with how many new results would be added if you refreshed the search. The trend for swine flu kept rapidly mounting. I could see this alarming the average person especially if Twitter was to distinguish their brand as the ubiquitous "realtime" search.
- diego 18y agoYou can see the chart for the trend here: http://twist.flaptor.com/?gram=swine+flu&table=0 http://twist.flaptor.com/?gram=swine+flu&table=0
- tvon 18y agoNobody ever said Twitter made you smarter...