2 ms·
Similarly, would you claim that the main purpose of solitary is to act as a disincentive? If so, it clearly works as effectively as prison does in keeping peopl
by Someone 13y ago
Similarly, would you claim that the main purpose of solitary is to act as a disincentive? If so, it clearly works as effectively as prison does in keeping people out of it.
If you want either to work as a disincentive, you first must make people be in control of whether they enter that next state of hell. This article clearly shows that prisoners aren't; they can just get sent to solitary (for decades!) because the wardens don't like them or find them a nuisance.
IMO, especially in the USA, many people aren't really in control w.r.t. the "do I want to go to prison?" question either. If you happen to be born in a poor neighborhood, you have to be exceptionally strong mentally not to get involved with petty crimes such as marihuana dealing, and if you do, you can get locked up. When you get out, you return to that poor neighborhood, and, having a record, you are certain that you cannot get a job anymore.
- Houshalter 13y agoHow does it not work? How many people don't commit crimes to avoid prison, and how many prisoners behave to avoid solitary? Of course decades of solitary confinement for standing up to guards is absolutely ridiculous, but the general principle that people avoid the threat of punishment still stands. I still have sympathy for (most) people that commit crimes, and I think it'd be inhuman not to. That's why we don't have the death penalty for all crimes, regardless how effective a deterrent that would be. On the other hand, if you know the consequence of committing a crime and decide to commit it anyways, I don't have as much sympathy. You can't say that people have no choice whatsoever. Just because you grew up in a poor neighborhood doesn't make committing crimes ok.