4 ms·
The main purpose of prison is to act as a disincentive. A lot of people don't commit crimes in the first place because they are scared of going to prison.
by Houshalter 13y ago
The main purpose of prison is to act as a disincentive. A lot of people don't commit crimes in the first place because they are scared of going to prison.
- EliRivers 13y agoThe evidence appears to indicate that it's far less effective as a disincentive than people hope. For prison to work as a disincentive, people need to be capable of making sensible decisions about what to do NOW in order to create a better distant future. They often aren't. Criminals are often people who do very badly at this. They don't want to be in prison twenty years from now, but it's not going to affect how they live their life now. If prisons as thought of as primarily a disincentive, it's a very expensive way of getting not much back. I expect it's a cultural thing.
- Houshalter 13y agoHow can you know how many people don't commit crimes because they fear prison? Yes the people who currently are in prison are the ones who didn't think they would get caught, but there are people who are not in prison because they did consider that. Yes there are cheaper and more effective disincentives, but you're right it is a cultural thing. Our culture considers those barbaric (but not prison somehow.)
- EliRivers 13y ago"How can you know how many people don't commit crimes because they fear prison?" It's very difficult. We can look at the fact that the US imprisons more of its population than any other nation, and if prison is a working deterrent, this would mean that the United States is a phenomenally lawless and criminal society barely held in check by the fear of the USA's notoriously harsh judicial system. Is the USA a phenomenally lawless and criminal society? There are studies that try to evaluate the deterrence effect of prison. Some conclude yes, some no, but the weight of evidence appears to indicates that on the whole, it's a pretty ineffective deterrent. You can google as well as I can so I won't list a bunch of google hits. "Our culture considers those barbaric (but not prison somehow.)" Now that is interesting. I meant a detention system that actually works; that actually is applied with the intention of turning criminals into good citizens and making a better society. I assume that you don't consider that "barbaric", so I'm guessing you thought I meant something like state-sanctioned torture or other such physical abuse, or cutting off people's hands, or public executions in the town square, and all that sort of thing. So our cultural gap is so big that the first thing you thought of to deal with detention as an ineffective deterrent wasn't an effective detention system, but harsher punishments, whereas I thought of stopping trying to use it as a deterrent and do something useful with it.
- simonbarker87 13y agoI think that assumes that they are in the same state of mind of a well balanced person. If they are hungry, tired (of life), scared, have no other option then the risk reward may skew to them thinking that the risk of prison is worth it.
- babarock 13y agoSo unfair. Even a "well balanced person" can commit a cri me. Actually, human beings are notoriously bad at avoiding future harm. We're wired to survive immediate dangers, but it takes a lot of mental effort to realize long term dangers. How else would you explain the widespread of tobacco smoking, over-eating, and other behaviors that are extremely dangerous but not immediately punishing?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- alan_cx 13y agoClearly doesn't work then does it? One of the highest prison populations in the world. If it were a deterrent, people wouldn't commit crimes that get them in prison, would they? Either its no deterrent, or Americans are the most criminal in the world.
- Houshalter 13y agoYou don't see the people that aren't in prison because they do see it as a disincentive. America doesn't have the highest crime rate in the world either, we simply catch more criminals and have vastly expanded the number of things that qualify as crimes, as well as lengthened sentences. We might have more crime than other first world countries in general, but it's not like prisons are the cause of it. That doesn't mean it doesn't work. Besides, what are you comparing it to? All other countries use prisons as well, and what would the alternative be anyways?
- Someone 13y agoSimilarly, would you claim that the main purpose of solitary is to act as a disincentive? If so, it clearly works as effectively as prison does in keeping people out of it. If you want either to work as a disincentive, you first must make people be in control of whether they enter that next state of hell. This article clearly shows that prisoners aren't; they can just get sent to solitary (for decades!) because the wardens don't like them or find them a nuisance. IMO, especially in the USA, many people aren't really in control w.r.t. the "do I want to go to prison?" question either. If you happen to be born in a poor neighborhood, you have to be exceptionally strong mentally not to get involved with petty crimes such as marihuana dealing, and if you do, you can get locked up. When you get out, you return to that poor neighborhood, and, having a record, you are certain that you cannot get a job anymore.
- Houshalter 13y agoHow does it not work? How many people don't commit crimes to avoid prison, and how many prisoners behave to avoid solitary? Of course decades of solitary confinement for standing up to guards is absolutely ridiculous, but the general principle that people avoid the threat of punishment still stands. I still have sympathy for (most) people that commit crimes, and I think it'd be inhuman not to. That's why we don't have the death penalty for all crimes, regardless how effective a deterrent that would be. On the other hand, if you know the consequence of committing a crime and decide to commit it anyways, I don't have as much sympathy. You can't say that people have no choice whatsoever. Just because you grew up in a poor neighborhood doesn't make committing crimes ok.