5 ms·
This would be really, really good news if it were true. We have demonstrated the ability to put these things into the atmosphere, with 40-50 year-old tech, and
by jerf 13y ago
This would be really, really good news if it were true. We have demonstrated the ability to put these things into the atmosphere, with 40-50 year-old tech, and as an accidental side effect rather than a deliberate attempt to do so. We have demonstrated the ability to let them decay out of the atmosphere without adding significantly more. If the CFCs had this level of impact on the atmospheric temperature, this would give us such an enormous stick in global temperature management that at the very least the fears of a new ice age [1] could be put to rest for the duration of our technological civilization, and of course there's the fact that it would also demonstrate that our CO2 contribution is also not that big a deal so our warming fears could also be all but put to bed.
It's such good news, in fact, that I daresay it's too good a bit of news. The Cynic's Razor [2] may not be quite as reliable as Occam's Razor, but it's still pretty darned reliable. (Unfortunately.) Alas, the Cynic's Razor must slash this theory away without a great deal more evidence.
[1] I fear global cooling far more than I fear global warming. I say that without regard to any immediate probability estimates of the two, I'm considering the whole life span of civilization here. Take the worst global warming scenario you've ever heard. The compare it to this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Iceage_north-intergl_glac_hg.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Iceage_north-intergl_glac_... And bear in mind that "areas with no growing season to speak of" continues a significant distance beyond the glaciers themselves. Canada and Britain completely uninhabitable. The US, Russia, and most if not all of Europe with zero growing season for any commercially-viable crop. Similar problems in the southern hemisphere. Global warming may be bad for civilization, an Ice Age is potentially death to the entire concept of civilization. YMMV.
[2] Drat! Not quite an original construct: https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Cynic%27s+Razor%22 https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Cynic%27s+Razor%22 So close.
- DennisP 13y agoEh...the worst global warming scenario I've ever heard? Positive feedbacks like methane emissions take hold, and even if we stop emissions entirely the planet tips itself into its hot mode, when sea levels were about a hundred meters higher and most life on the planet was clustered around the poles. No wait, the worst is a repeat of the greatest mass extinction ever, killing off 95% of the species on Earth, caused in part by ocean acidification leading to mass emissions of hydrogen sulfide.
- jerf 13y agoWell, fair enough based on my wording I suppose. But on the one hand you have events that happened a very long time ago, whereas on the other you have the fact that we're in an "intraglacial period" in a "current ice age" right now: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene (first paragraph, I suggest also clicking on the "current ice age" link). I'm actually more worried that warming could still somehow lead us back into the ice age (chaos is nasty stuff) than the catastrophic warming scenarios. Both are theoretically possible, but we are so much closer to an ice age than heat disaster right now. However much we may or may not moved the climate it certainly hasn't been very far away from "ice age" in the grand scheme of things.
- DennisP 13y agoWell if you're really talking about history-of-civilization timeframes, warming problems could get pretty bad. Most projections you see don't go past 2100. The last time CO2 levels were as high as they are right now, sea levels were at least ten meters higher. At the same time, the rate at which we're adding CO2 is much higher than the planet has ever seen. In geologic history, higher CO2 levels have always been associated with higher temperatures and sea levels. However, if you're worried about an ice age, it's easily prevented, because ice ages are actually pretty delicate. A single factory producing NF3 and venting it to the atmosphere would be enough to keep us out of one. (Source: Hansen's book again)