5 ms·
"Without spending a cent!" At some point states are going to start taxing for electricity going into electric vehicles to make up for lost revenue for their ro
by protomyth 13y ago
"Without spending a cent!"
At some point states are going to start taxing for electricity going into electric vehicles to make up for lost revenue for their road and highway funds. I wonder if Tesla will pay for that or start charging?
On another note, I do hope we don't end up with every manufacture building their own recharging network.
- NickM 13y agoMore likely I'd expect such a tax to be imposed in the form of additional taxes/fees on EV purchase/registration. Most EV charging is done at home, and it'd be logistically impractical to try to measure and tax only the electricity used to charge cars. Then again, I think it'll be a while until we see anything like this, since right now the trend is toward subsidizing EVs more than taxing them. Bear in mind also that the Supercharger network can be free because it's not intended for frequent use; the stations are typically placed at highway rest stops between cities, with the intent to allow occasional long road trips that would normally be outside the vehicle's battery range.
- akgoel 13y agoAs a Model S owner in Texas, I would think the easiest solution would be to record the mileage on the car at each annual state inspection and tax me on the net mileage driven between inspections.
- chris_mahan 13y agoIn California we don't have annual inspections. We have smog tests every 2 years.
- joshdance 13y agoI hope they don't invent a "smog test" for electric cars.
- chris_mahan 13y agoYeah, good observation... Anyone have any info on that?
- akgoel 13y agoIn Texas, the inspection checks for emissions, windshield cracks, headlight and signal light operation, and tire wear. When I lived in Massachusetts, the inspection wrote me up because my headlights weren't in the same plane (the service station actually had a large cross painted on the wall to see where the lights pointed to). I'm surprised California doesn't have something similar.
- beachstartup 13y agocalifornia cops issue an obscene amount of fixit tickets. cops pull you over if they notice anything wrong and you have to go through a whole bunch of bullshit to get the fixes signed off. however my personal theory on why CA doesn't have inspection is because californians take their car aesthetics very seriously and you won't find massive inspection stickers on peoples' windows (an inspection regime demands proof of inspection) also, the dealerships don't put their own badges on the back of the cars, and parking passes are generally the kind that hang from the rear view mirror. we don't want that shit cluttering up our vehicles
- chris_mahan 13y agoAs a californian who used to live in texas, I concur. Cars are like bling here.
- nathan_long 13y agoMight be close enough, but it's possible you're driving most of your miles outside the state where you live. Gas tax gets closer to tying your spending to where you drive (unless you're able to always refuel in one state).
- protomyth 13y agoIf they adopted that model for every car, it would be devastating to lower income people. That is why we have withholding on our federal / state taxes. The current model is much easier for people on a budget. We are not talking about a hundred $, we are talking thousands for many[1]. This is especially true where housing is too expensive in the city and lower income people need to commute[2]. 1) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_taxes_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_taxes_in_the_United_States assuming that electricity would need to be taxed at a equivalent level 2) mass transit is not everywhere
- MartinCron 13y agoAt some point states are going to start taxing for electricity going into electric vehicles to make up for lost revenue for their road and highway funds. Or they'll increase gas taxes to make up for the lost difference until everyone is driving electric cars. Mission accomplished!
- pkulak 13y agoThat'll get the votes for sure!
- MartinCron 13y agoThere is some logic to it. In my State (Washington) the legislature is currently looking at raising the gas tax rate to adjust for the fact that average fuel economy has gone up a whole bunch in the years since we set the tax rate. http://www.nwnewsnetwork.org/post/backers-washington-gas-tax-package-rally-capitol http://www.nwnewsnetwork.org/post/backers-washington-gas-tax... As we literally have parts of the interstate freeway falling into rivers at the moment, I think I'm OK with some more infrastructure spending.
- protomyth 13y ago"Bridges are collapsing and our roads are in disrepair. Rep. Barney voted to put the burden of fixing those roads and bridges on you and let Tesla-driving millionaires pay NO TAXES for those same roads and bridges. Vote Fred - he cares about you." I'm thinking that might not work.
- jusben1369 13y agoActually what will happen is that the tax would move from the fuel source to the mileage source. So you'll have to declare your odometer for the last 12 months and pay taxes on mileage driven.