5 ms·
It's like MS is being obtuse on purpose. People complain about having the entire focus of the system switch to tablet mode, just to find a document or launch a
by MichaelGG 13y ago
It's like MS is being obtuse on purpose. People complain about having the entire focus of the system switch to tablet mode, just to find a document or launch a program. Not because of the few pixels representing the start menu. They obviously know this.
At first, I thought Win8 start screen would be nearly equivalent to the start menu. It is not. First, on RDP, it is an utter and total nightmare. Whoever thought Windows Server should use the start screen should be sacked. Last week I lit up 2012 servers for a client, and they thought the shell was a joke, literally. Even MS TechNet admits that doing things might be a bit of a hassle.
On normal desktop, it's extremely distracting to flip to start screen instead of opening the start menu. Also, the search feature is broken. Instead of having one global search, you need to type the query, then arrow down a few times to select the kind you wanted (like settings).
Finally, even when you get results, they're in tablet-tile mode, which is an annoyingly cartoonish way, and in case of long names (as MS likes), you get the name clipped.
If MST3K was reviewing it, this would be a part they just sorta chuckle and say "They really did that."
- shubb 13y agoNot that it makes the Start screen any less wierd, but win+W keys open up search for settings, without having to press down at the end.
- skrebbel 13y agoeasy to remember cause it's short for Win+Wtf?
- sigkill 13y agoYour post is spot on. The search, the frigging search is completely broken on Win8. I hate it that you can't have a universal search so much that I've started using Launchy. Alt-Space for me to search anything is a pretty damn good two key replacement for the one-key search button. I tried binding it to the pause/break button on my laptop but it doesn't receive the key except when the desktop is in focus.
- iamshs 13y agoI hate the non-inclusion of the universal search, it is annoying, I heard Apple has a patent on that but then MS and Apple have some kind of agreement too.
- aaronbrethorst 13y agoSteve Sinofsky was, undoubtedly, ultimately responsible for the 'no Start button' thing. Sinofsky is now gone. Microsoft, like any other company, is made up of people.
- ishansharma 13y agoI second this. Main reason I switched back to Windows 8 was broken search. MS just broke something for sake of change. In Windows 7, to change proxy settings, I just write proxy and hit enter. Windows 8, write proxy, hit down/move mouse and then do it. For someone who routinely changes system settings, this is a nightmare.
- skrebbel 13y agoThat said, the settings search did actually become much better. You can search not only for the names of control panel screens, but for what you want to do. I've been pretty impressed, they've had somebody enter giant lists of weighted keywords somewhere.
- wvenable 13y agoSearching for what you want to do seems to work pretty well on Windows 7.
- drharris 13y agoI think the difference is that Windows 7 has easy search for what you want to execute, where 8 allows you to search for intent.
- MichaelGG 13y agoSearching for things like "Change network" in Windows 7 seems to work just fine - you get a list of common tasks. They might have added more aliases in Windows 8 based on feedback or research. I don't think it's anything fundamentally new.
- kelvie 13y agoYeah I hated that about Win8 as well. As downgrading seemed like too much of a hassle, I recently found out that you have to use Win+W to search settings. Why they separated settings and applications is beyond me.
- mattmanser 13y agoI really dread new MS Server releases, every one comes with major improvements so they're a no brainer but have three or four jaw-droppingly bad regressions.
- yuhong 13y agoOn RDP, the hot corners was such a problem that MS had to update the client to present a menu with the charms. Restoring the Start button would fix this.
- UnoriginalGuy 13y agoYou shouldn't be using RDC on Server 2012 with or without Metro. You should be using either Powershell and or RSAT. In general the interface on 2012 is a marked improvement over 2008 R2.