3 ms·
As the Steam platform has demonstrated, if you make paying the easy solution and piracy the hard one, the target audience (viz. people willing to pay money) wil
by shmerl 13y ago
As the Steam platform has demonstrated, if you make paying the easy solution and piracy the hard one, the target audience (viz. people willing to pay money) will choose the easy one.
Steam is still DRMed and can be annoying enough. Try to get Loom there to play on your Scummvm and good luck with that. I don't use Steam since I don't want to support DRMed approach. I use GOG and other DRM free distributors for gaming. If DRM isn't very obvious and disruptive it doesn't mean it's not there and it doesn't make it any more ethical than a hidden camera which you are unaware of. I'd say it's better when it's noticeable, at least you can be aware of its risks.
> Policing content is not the sort of "market censorship" they care about.
Tell them about it when their distributor will pull the plug and go out business, informing them that their DRMed content will be lost forever. I'm sure they'll appreciate the view that they shouldn't care about it in such situation.
> It's not true that this represents any threat to DRM.
You don't need to technically threaten something that's already broken. Most DRM is broken in short time. However DRM needs to be threatened on practical and legal levels. Practically by byocotting the DRMed content, and legally by repealing DMCA 1201 and similar laws created to back up DRM.
- mortenjorck 13y agoSteam has a unique market position, with an extremely loyal user base. The really interesting thought experiment I see is this: What if Steam quietly went DRM-free tomorrow? What would change? What wouldn't?
- shmerl 13y agoNetflix also has a big and arguably loyal user base, same goes for Xbox, PlayStation and other heavily DRMed platforms. Does it indicate that DRM approach is ethical or that simply many people are oblivious to its potential problems? As often, many ignore it until they are bitten. If that happens, people learn about DRM the hard way. About Steam going DRM free - I'd like that, and I'd subscribe to their service if they'd do it. But they are heavily involved with DRM addicted gaming companies, and unlike GOG don't put any effort into convincing them to publish their games DRM free. GOG invests a lot of time and effort to do it. For Steam it would either mean an enormous amount of reworking their contracts, or simply cutting off a significant part of their catalog. They aren't as principled as GOG to do that.
- gordaco 13y agoSurely a single data point is not much, but in that case they could count me as another consumer in their extremely loyal user base.
- Shorel 13y agoMy opinion is that Steam's DRM is as ethical as it can be, and the only thing wrong about it is accepting other additional schemes like GfWL on top of it. I will oppose other forms of DRM, like everything Sony has done, but I think companies like Valve have to be rewarded for doing something good for game studios and players alike. I see your stance the same as I see the RMS stance on software licenses. Too extreme to be practical for all purposes.
- shmerl 13y agoIf you want to grade what's worse, DRM or closed source software, I'd say that the first one is worse. While closed source software restricts user's freedom for modification and redistribution, DRM goes way beyond that and violates much more. I'd say it's practical, reasonable and not extreme to be opposed to any forms of DRM. There is simply no excuse for it to exist. Unlike Valve, other distributors (GOG/CDPR) proved that DRM free gaming distribution is practical. So I don't see Valve as a best example in the gaming industry. Music is DRM free. Digital books publishing offers more and more DRM free options. It's the video industry which lingers behind the most.
- b0rsuk 13y agoIt's not totally bad, but can be better. * No lending your game to a friend * No selling. Piracy exists not only because people don't like to pay. It also exists because of... generosity, and human nature in general. Pirates get warm fuzzy feeling when they share something. Unlearning To Share: The Industry’s Hatred Of Generosity http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2013/05/23/unlearning-to-share-the-industry-hatred-of-human-nature/ http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2013/05/23/unlearning-to-sha...
- Qantourisc 13y agoSteam is kind of the least worst DRM, why: it has more advantages ! - Easy installation, no hassle with CD's: Check - Automatic updates: Check - Price: Sales from time to time: Check - Does it get in the way ?: Only slightly. However there are quite a few bad risks attached: - Need internet ? Yes :( - Can the block your account and screw you over ? Yes :( - What if they go bankrupt ? So all in all I don't prefer steam, but for Linux atm it brings in a few games :)