3 ms·
True, but citations are qualitative as well as quantitative, so at least researchers should know that Controversial Paper X mostly gets citations as an example
by notahacker 13y ago
True, but citations are qualitative as well as quantitative, so at least researchers should know that Controversial Paper X mostly gets citations as an example of "unusual findings, possibly due to methodological shortcomings" if they are deciding where it's worth summarising in the literature review section of their paper. And arguably (especially in social sciences) papers which provoke interesting rebuttals them are deservedly more influential than papers which are esoteric, trivial or dull.