3 ms·
The USSR occupation of Eastern Europe / Warsaw pact countries after WW2 did suffer from guerilla warfare, with some squads lasting until 1960'ies. And that was
by PeterisP 13y ago
The USSR occupation of Eastern Europe / Warsaw pact countries after WW2 did suffer from guerilla warfare, with some squads lasting until 1960'ies. And that was even with the full "good practice" of lots of boots on the ground, resettled bureaucrats, total control of whole economy with cushy positions for local collaborators, and no fear of using collective punishment.
For example, if some village peasants feed the guerilla troops (willingly or not), and you shoot or deport anyone suspected of that, not bothering about possible false positives while rewarding snitches/collaborators; and using mass media to make sure that everyone knows the consequences - then in a bunch of years that will reduce support for insurgents. But western troops under media coverage can't really do that effectively.
Also, using Afghan army to make peace in Afghanistan seems ineffective - there are well known benefits to classical approach used by USSR, earlier imperial Russia, Ottoman empire and Roman empire; you conscript troops from the occupied areas and send them to pacify other occupied areas with different and preferably alien/hostile culture. Conscripting Afghan soldiers to pacify Iraq, and conscripting Iraqi soldiers to pacify Afghanistan would reduce the risk of corruption, fraternizing, and defection. Again, USA probably isn't willing to do that.