4 ms·
I don't see an erosion here. Has the right to privacy ever allowed people to prevent access to something where there is probable cause to think there's evidence
by wpietri 13y ago
I don't see an erosion here. Has the right to privacy ever allowed people to prevent access to something where there is probable cause to think there's evidence of a crime?
- downandout 13y agoHe isn't "preventing access". He is merely remaining silent on the matter, and has not admitted ownership of the drives or knowledge of the contents or decryption key. It is important to note that the judge never held that forced decryption of drives he owns violates the fifth amendment; he simply held that, at the time of the government's request, there was no evidence that he actually owned and controlled the drives and their contents. The recent discovery of the data on the other drives convinced the judge that the drives do in fact belong to him, and as a result he is now OK with ordering the forced decryption. If you are doing bad things, you probably shouldn't use a decryption key that you could remember. Store that stuff elsewhere.
- mikeash 13y agoI think it's a wholly new situation. Previously, you couldn't be compelled to e.g. hand over the combination to a safe, but the police are free to just break into it, once they have a warrant. There's no "breaking into" cryptography, which sets it apart. In any case, I don't see how the Fifth Amendment wouldn't apply here. Maybe we'd prefer that people not be able to take refuge in it for this stuff, but that means amending the Constitution, not ignoring inconvenient parts of it.
- rosser 13y agoBased on previous rulings, the 5th Amendment doesn't apply because the State already has specific knowledge that this guy has child porn on an encrypted drive, through other means. That being the case, the act of decrypting the drive is no longer testimonial, as, by itself, it does not implicate him. If they merely believed really, really strongly that he has CP on an encrypted drive, then compelling its decryption would be testimonial, because the State would have knowledge (namely, that he possesses child porn) after the act of decryption that they did not have before it. That makes the act of decryption, itself, testimonial, and subject to 5th Amendment protection. EDIT: as has been noted else-thread, however, Wisconsin is in a different Federal Circuit than the aforementioned previous rulings, and so isn't bound by them.
- cjhopman 13y agoMy understanding is not that they have good evidence that there is CP on the encrypted drive, but rather that they have good evidence that the drive belongs to the guy and that he can decrypt it/has access to/knowledge of its contents. The idea about not having to give up a combination/password is that by doing so you would essentially be admitting ownership/access/knowledge about the contents that were protected by that combination/password.
- mikeash 13y agoI don't really understand. If the contents of the drive don't implicate him in anything, why do they need him to decrypt it? If they implicate him in something, why doesn't the Fifth Amendment apply? Seems like these are the only two choices.