3 ms·
The other popularly suggested solution is sort-of the opposite: use double-blind reviewing, where the reviewer doesn't know who the authors are, at least formal
by leephillips 13y ago
The other popularly suggested solution is sort-of the opposite: use double-blind reviewing, where the reviewer doesn't know who the authors are, at least formally.
- kenko 13y agoThis is the standard in most disciplines. I wish the authors of this article had done the same test with journals that do blind reviewing. I'd bet they still got a lot of rejections of previously accepted articles for bizarre reasons, since in general acceptance depends a lot on the particular reviewers you draw.
- leephillips 13y ago"This is the standard in most disciplines." Any citation for this? I'm curious, because in physics, although this is often suggested, it has not been generally adopted.
- kenko 13y agoReally? I guess I should've said "this is standard in most disciplines ... that I know about". I'm really surprised that it isn't done in physics!
- tensor 13y agoIt's not done in CS either. It varies greatly by sub-topic though.
- gcr 13y agoIn computer vision conferences, reviewing is almost always double-blind. In computer vision journals, reviewing is only half-duplex blind -- the reviewers can see who you are, but not vice versa.
- akjj 13y agoTwo counter-arguments: First, in many disciplines, it is common to circulate pre-prints of papers which are being refereed. In this case, anonymity for the authors is impossible, practically speaking. Second, the OP describes a snob effect, but there is also the reverse: Some referees will be more patient in dealing with badly organized or poorly written papers from a junior researcher. Not necessarily lower standards, but spending more time figuring out the paper, making suggestions for improvement.
- leephillips 13y agoAnd it can be obvious who the authors are in a field you are following closely; which, ideally, you should be if you are reviewing papers in that field. That's why I said "formally".
- tensor 13y agoThis paper extends our previous work on .....