7 ms·
The Year of Dressing Formally (2008)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- KaiP 13y agoThis professor works at a private college in Michigan called Hope College, from what I can tell he is not subsisting on taxpayer money.
- bri3d 13y agoThat professor is from Hope College, a private Christian college, so he's subsisting on taxpayer money only insofar as most other nonprofit employees are. I thought the commentary was at least mildly interesting. When I was in the Valley I experienced a strong anti-suit attitude and many I met in the startup industry would vehemently protest any suggestion that dressing formally could be a good idea. It seems like common sense to me but clothing and appearance are just communication tools the same way body language, tone of voice, and diction are.
- mcguire 13y agoI had to meander down to the troll section of the responses to find the best comment, yours. "It seems like common sense to me but clothing and appearance are just communication tools the same way body language, tone of voice, and diction are."
- StefanKarpinski 13y agoI'm not sure why you think that humanities professors at small liberal arts colleges subsist on tax-payer money. Even if they did, that certainly shouldn't prevent them from writing whimsical, entertaining and interesting pieces like this one – especially when they are English professors.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- vkou 13y agoEven if he were a public employee, I'm not sure how you that you have any right to complain about what he spends his salary on.
- derleth 13y agoBecause it is taken as axiomatic in some strains of Conservatism (Reactionary, really, but they're pleased to refer to themselves as 'Conservative') that spending tax money on anything other than the military, the police, and the privately-owned jails is unconstitutional. Because having another tax-paid F-22 is not Socialism, somehow.
- cmbaus 13y agoI just wish more American businessmen would wear decent shoes, such as bluchers or oxfords by Alden or Allen Edmonds, so I don't have to see anymore rubber soled, bicycle toed loafers at the airport: http://instagram.com/p/ZbdZfMsM4G/ http://instagram.com/p/ZbdZfMsM4G/
- davidw 13y agoPeople wear all kinds of silly fashions here in Italy, which is pretty much the fashion capital of the world. Some of them may be well made, name-brand silly fashions, but they certainly look odd 5 years out from when they were 'in'. I'm with Zuckerberg, and Jobs with his 'uniform' on this one: most of that junk is a complete waste of your time. The only winning move is not to play. You don't have to wear just sweatshirts and jeans, but pick stuff you like and get on with life and stop worrying about it.
- dsirijus 13y agoMimicry has its place for those who haven't succeeded globally by the age you're supposed to start wearing formal, or at least "decent" clothes, like Zuckerberg and Jobs did.
- mindcrime 13y agoby the age you're supposed to start "supposed to"? According to why? And what gives this amorphous "they" any standing to dictate such a thing? Fuck that... I like to dandy it up and rock the "two and a half piece" suit look sometimes (that is, waistcoat and - in my case - a cravat, but no outer jacket), but I do it because I like it, not because somebody says it's what you're supposed to do. And the rest of the time, this 40 year old sees no reason not to wear jeans and a Twisted Sister t-shirt.
- dsirijus 13y agoWhy don't you put "jeans and Twisted Sister t-shirt" version on LinkedIn profile? In the neighbourhood I'm known as "the bathrobe guy with funny facial hair", so I get you. I don't want attract people around me who will judge a book by its covers, but majority people I interacted with are living in that cave. It is pretty oblivious to walk around and think that your appearance doesn't matter to substantial number of people you do business and socialize with. If you want to leave appearance of laid-back honest doer, that's fine. Not all people do.
- jsnk 13y agoI wish I can dress nicely in suits, but I don't do it for two reasons. No one dresses in suits in technology sector. Not even CEO. Only team that dress up in our company is legal, and even they are on the more informal side compared to what real formal is. Good suits that look good are expensive. I don't want to wear daddy tier suits, but good looking suits I've seen run well over $500.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoI once worked at a place that required me to rack servers in a 3 piece suit. Once.
- zwieback 13y agoI worked for a client once (a very large logistics firm) where everyone who isn't union had to wear suit and tie, this included all vendors. We were testing some new equipment we built in a sorting facility without any climate control. In July. In Orlando.
- sliverstorm 13y agoAt least it wasn't Phoenix.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoUPS?
- zwieback 13y agoyup, I think they may have loosened their dress code for vendors by now
- toomuchtodo 13y agoMy brilliant developer co-worker worked at UPS for 8 years. Told me he had to wear a suit to work everyday, and shave as well. Not clean shaven? You get sent home. Not dressed correctly? You got sent home.
- atourgates 13y ago"One day you put on a tie, the next day you are driving a Hummer and voting Republican." My official nomination for quote of the day.
- mturmon 13y agoFor tomorrow, perhaps this: "Among other things, Mr. Flusser has led me to discover the value of the male garter for holding up slouchy socks."
- mindcrime 13y agoFWIW, wearing a suit (in the modern "business suit" sense of term) isn't technically "formal" dress. Heck, it isn't even semi-formal. Semi-formal would be a tuxedo (for men), and formal wear would be "morning dress" or "white tie".[1] "Business suits" fall into the category of "lounge suit" which is considered informal dress.[2] [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formal_wear http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formal_wear [2]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lounge_suit http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lounge_suit
- devindotcom 13y agoThe standards can change, as they have before. "Formality" is a relative concept.
- dllthomas 13y agoThey can and do, but it still pays to be aware of the range it currently spans, and I think we're plenty familiar with the lower end.
- kunai 13y agoThis. 60 years ago, wearing anything other than a suit and tie was considered informal. Even just a tucked-in shirt without a tie and black pants was informal dress. Men commonly would be seen in business suits; and usually wore hats as well.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoIn the US, black tie is the highest level of formality that most people are ever likely to encounter. This requires a tuxedo (or, on the more casual level of black tie, an all black suit, white shirt, and black tie). Nothing is "technically" formal, since there is no defining body that lays down the specification of the word with the authority to enforce that specification. Like most non-technical language, it is a target that moves with the times. If someone says they went to a formal event in the U.S., most of the time it will mean they wore a tuxedo without tails.
- 13y ago
- Strilanc 13y agoThe title reminds me of pg's post[1] from 2005 that starts with "Suits make a corporate comeback" as an example of PR. 1: http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html
- guard-of-terra 13y agoClothing is boring. It's something you have to do, as opposed to what you want to be doing. Unless it's a T-shirt with some image that relates to your personality. I'll pay for a service where I can dump my clothes and they'll produce identical new and fitted items.
- keiferski 13y agoOr you know, it's an art and a hobby that people other than you enjoy.
- guard-of-terra 13y agoI have nothing against that. Some people collect postage stamps, some play a tube, some dress.
- devindotcom 13y agoWorth noting that not everyone is of your opinion, and many are interested in clothing (and extensions of it, such as watches and jewelry) as a form of expression.
- 13b9f227ecf0 13y agoYou may feel that clothing is boring and something you can look past, but you are in a tiny minority. By failing to invest a bit in your appearance you are foolishly forgoing substantial advantages in life.
- guard-of-terra 13y agoI don't see how I'm a tiny minority. In my life I bang on keys all the day long, and keys don't care what I wear. What could change?
- benihana 13y agohere's why: http://putthison.com/post/49277992157/professionalism-several-years-ago-i-started http://putthison.com/post/49277992157/professionalism-severa... The undertaker at the pet cemetery only buries dead animals, why would they care what he wears? The answer is because other people exist.
- orangethirty 13y agoI dress the same every day. Black t-shirt with no logo, jeans, and sneakers. If its cold, I put on my black hoodie. That's all you will see. Nice ocassions? My wife takes care of that. Otherwise, it's my uniform. Clothing costs have gone down, I save time and money by not having to pick what to wear of having to wash things in differen loads. But, I mostly do it because I'm lazy.
- 13b9f227ecf0 13y ago> I mostly do it because I'm lazy. You do realize that's exactly the impression your habit conveys, right?
- adamdavis 13y agoPersonally, I wouldn't have thought to consider him lazy had he not mentioned it, but rather just someone completely disinterested in fashion. /2cents
- orangethirty 13y agoWeird thing is that since being a nerd is in these days, peoe have complimented my style. If they only knew I lack it.
- orangethirty 13y agoYes. But I'm the good kind of lazy. I choose to spend my time working on solutions to big problems, rather than working on what shirt to wear tomorrow. I do use different brands with different cuts and styles. Mostly because I grab whatever is available at the store. I also only use name brands, because the last twice as long. It's also a sort of camouflage. I blend in very easily. I like that.
- Mandatum 13y agoHaha yes, that reminds me of the movie "The Fly" - where the main character gets up in the morning and goes to his closet - with about 20 copies of the same outfit. Waste no thought on nonsense! Or in our case, waste no time on things we don't care about. Unfortunately however I've bought some new items recently and I keep getting compliments, even from strangers.. That big 'ole head of mine's gonna go spend his next paycheck on new clothes!
- rokhayakebe 13y agoMany people pretend to not care about their clothes, or the way they look, so long as they look clean, and decent. The truth is a man who wears a nice shirt, pants, and shoes will simply not want to go back if he is confident about it. And for your information, you look much much better if you sport nice, fitted clothes.
- sliverstorm 13y agoThe truth is a man who wears a nice shirt, pants, and shoes will simply not want to go back if he is confident about it. The truth is I am having a difficult time fitting nice shirts, pants, and shoes into my lifestyle. Less because I am lazy, and more because boulders and bicycle cranks and dirt are hard on nice clothes.
- rokhayakebe 13y agoIf you are dealing with boulders and dirt on your way to work, then you should find a different path, or consider ride-sharing etc... But I believe you can still ride in style.
- ryguytilidie 13y agoI don't want to belittle the author too much, but when I think about the way my time is spent, there is no way in the world thinking about clothes this much is worth that amount of time. This does, however, remind me of one of my favorite scenes from the wire: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QJn-9TP7uUM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QJn-9TP7uUM
- basseq 13y agoI wear suits at work fairly often; it depends on the client and if I'm interacting externally often in a given week (month). I like wearing a suit: I have an enhanced sense of professionalism and self-confidence when I'm dressed to the nines. I'm not a developer or in "tech" in the pure sense, and I know this depends on the "culture", but I'm also on the East Coast and a bunch of our devs have Bow Tie Tuesday and really get into it. May be a geographic thing as well: I'm as like as not to wear dark jeans, nice shoes, a button-down, and a blazer on weekends. And it isn't cheap. If you shop around, you can find a reasonable suit for under $500, which is still a fair amount of t-shirts and hoodies. However, the key to dress clothes more so than quality is fit—you should have all your suits tailored to fit you, and that's another $100 or so between jacket, pants, etc.
- nja 13y agoAt a former job of mine, we used to have "Formal Friday." Soon enough, some started to attend "Flannel Friday" instead and it became quite the office-dividing phenomenon. Regardless, it can be quite fun and effective to have informally-defined clothing days. Gives people a nice chance too try out new pieces and styles.
- keiferski 13y agoI find it amusing how people want beautiful architecture, good weather, nice greenery, and so on, but don't make the next step and want people (including themselves) to dress better. Clothes are just another facet of visual culture. That's how you get tourists with sweatpants and fanny packs outside the Florence Duomo.
- sliverstorm 13y agoPersonally I suspect the disconnect centers around utility. Beautiful architecture can be beautifully functional too. Good weather is pretty, and also comfortable. Greenery is pretty, and cleans the air. Semi-formal and formal wear are practically the antithesis of functional and comfortable. Personally, I have been making an effort to dress up a step or two, but I have to balance this against carrying more changes of clothes for my various activities outside of work.
- grimlck 13y agoIf your suit isn't comfortable, then you are wearing the wrong size and should get it tailored.
- stouset 13y agoCost of t-shirt: $15. Cost of perfectly-tailored suit: $x. Solve for `x < 20`.
- overgryphon 13y agoIf it is appropriate for you to wear a suit for an occasion (outside of church, weddings, and funerals), then you are likely making enough from the position to pay for the suit.
- Fishkins 13y agoThis doesn't apply to me, but couldn't this be a catch-22? To get a job/social status where you're making good money, you need to get a suit, but you need the money for a suit in order to get that job. Also, you could just be averse to a perceived waste of money, even if you could afford it (my case).
- DanielBMarkham 13y agoVery nicely done. Benton has a great voice and style. Loved the piece. I also made some additions to my Amazon wish list! The social engineering aspect of dressing formally was especially interesting. By dressing formally in formal class, then "dressing down" for one-on-ones, he was able to put students much more at ease. (And they also starting emailing him beginning with "Dear Professor" instead of "Hey") I'm not a suit guy by any means, but in some situations this life choice could make a lot of sense.
- echohack 13y ago> But I found that a higher level of formality improved my students' learning. My larger classes ran more smoothly. This is the crux of the article, and he provides no proof to back it up. The article says that this is an "experiment", but how did the professor log his activities? How did he measure the change in his student's perception? How did he isolate the variables of his own bias vs. the impact of new clothes vs. the impact of formal clothes? My personal opinion is that fashion is a gigantic waste of time. In any and all venues. Clothing should be first and foremost for utility. Part of that utility is creating a personal brand, which the author has stumbled upon here in his "experiment". While I'm not a fan, Steve Jobs had a great outlook on this, and is well known by his jeans-and-turtleneck look. This is an amazing insight into clothes in my opinion: Jobs found an outfit that worked, and then simplified everything in his life related to clothing. Image how easy laundry, the decision on what to wear for the day, moving, and ownership of clothes would be if you had a single, standard type of clothing to wear? Imagine how much easier it is to standardize social interactions with other people around you? You'll never have to worry about wearing 'nice' clothes again, because ALL your clothes are exactly the same.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoYou are aware that words have various meanings, right? This guy is not talking about an experiment in the formal, scientific sense of the word. Also, you are incorrect about whether this is the crux of the article. As you can clearly see from how much time is spent on each part, this is merely a happy side effect to what was a personal development for him. > My personal opinion is that fashion is a gigantic waste of time. In any and all venues. I'm not sure what you mean by waste of time. Do you mean it in the sense of, "Not something I would prefer to do?" Or do you mean it in the sense of, "Ineffective for all purposes?" One of these two meanings is demonstrably false. > While I'm not a fan, Steve Jobs had a great outlook on this, and is well known by his jeans-and-turtleneck look. I think Ryan Gosling's character in Crazy, Stupid, Love had a great outlook on Steve Jobs' outlook on fashion. "Hold on, are you the billionaire owner of Apple Computer? No? Then you've got no right to wear New Balance sneakers, ever." http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TZwjcpEEkPs http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TZwjcpEEkPs
- breadbox 13y ago
- bcbrown 13y agoThe article reminded me of a quote by Heinlein I recently came across: 'Moving parts in rubbing contact require lubrication to avoid excessive wear. Honorifics and formal politeness provide lubrication where people rub together. Often the very young, the untraveled, the naïve, the unsophisticated deplore these formalities as "empty," "meaningless," or "dishonest," and scorn to use them. No matter how "pure" their motives, they thereby throw sand into machinery that does not work too well at best.'
- qzxt 13y agoSo basically, we need to engage in superficial nonsense, because people are so immature that they can't settle their differences amicably? I'll make sure to teach my child that.
- bcbrown 13y agoThat's exactly the same thing you're teaching your child when you tell them not to point and say "Why is that man so fat?". I usually wear tees and jeans, but I recognize that formal wear has a place. I'm surprised you made such a snarky response, when you said something very similar in another thread: "I think, that as techies, we are in a unique situation, as far as intellectual development is concerned. The vast majority of the population can't appreciate technical phenomena because it is culturally viewed as "too hard" or "robotic" or "blah blah, boring". We, OTOH, actively refuse to engage with humanistic pursuits, but not out of any perceived difficulty so much as discomfort with the pretensions that come with "cultured society"."
- qzxt 13y agoSo you're comparing common decency and common sense to overbearing vanity imposed on people? If I remark about someone's weight to demean them, that's simply dick behavior. Wearing whatever the hell you like is not. Now imposing that one may be somehow inferior for not paying an exorbitant amount of attention to dress (for vanity, no less), that's dick behavior - which was the crux of OP's comment. And please, tell me how "if you strip away the pretensions from these things, more people would take to them" is the same as "the pretentiousness is necessary and the untraveled, uncultured, blah, blah, don't understand that, because, you know, uncultured".
- mediumdave 13y agoI have a hard time seeing formal clothing as anything other than an attempt to advertise an elevated social status. This seems to me to be at odds with the desire to create an egalitarian society.
- anchorsteam 13y agoThen again, flip-flops on a man in long pants is pretentious. If the only winning move is not to play then not playing is an attempt to "win".
- maxmax 13y agoPics or it didn't happen.
- ogdoad 13y agoNow that all the hard problems of humanity have been solved, tenured professors may return to more pressing matters -- with style. Splendid!