3 ms·
Wow. Are the students told that beforehand? I think a shocking consequence is students will now feel unsafe telling the truth about troubling events (abuse, et
by grecy 13y ago
Wow. Are the students told that beforehand?
I think a shocking consequence is students will now feel unsafe telling the truth about troubling events (abuse, etc.)
- genwin 13y ago> Are the students told that beforehand? That would defeat the purpose of the survey. I guess if there's a time for someone to learn the hard way when to keep private info private, high school is better than later.
- grecy 13y ago> I guess if there's a time for someone to learn the hard way when to keep private info private, high school is better than later. Does that include crimes against minors?
- ihsw 13y ago> students will now feel unsafe telling the truth about troubling events That's the idea -- helping those students is a significant and easily ignored cost center.
- bigiain 13y agoCynical-me thinks this is ideal education - proper preparation for "the real world": Answer every question not with "the truth", but instead work out what "the expected answer" is and give them that...
- genwin 13y agoI've hounded my kids on "the expected answer" many times. Recently my son was told to write an essay on gun control. I shudder to think what might've happened had he not given the expected conclusion on that one.
- C1D 13y agoWhat is the expected opinion on that. I'm not from the US.
- genwin 13y agoFor a school the expected opinion is that less guns is better.
- jkubicek 13y agoThat's highly dependent on the school. At my high school (rural Iowa) I can't see anyone taking issue with a pro-gun stance on a essay.
- theorique 13y agoSchool teachers and school administrations tend to be skewed leftist / liberal relative to the average of the country as a whole. Therefore, a student speaking in favor of 2nd Amendment rights or coming out sounding too "pro-gun" might find himself tagged for observation by the administration as an "extremist" or a potential threat.
- lmm 13y agoIf you have that little faith in the school why are you still sending your son there?
- genwin 13y agoIt's an issue with all public schools, except maybe in rural Iowa (see below). I don't like it but it is good training for life.
- Maxious 13y agoWhich was the whole point the teacher was making - you have a right to not incriminate yourself (by giving a false answer or not answering), even when asked by authority figures (judges, police, teachers) to do so. A lot of people feel that they must fill in every value of every form "or else". While really, if you value your privacy you should ask if every value is really required.
- cdash 13y agoYou don't actually have the right to provide false answers in many situations and doing so could actually be a crime.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Maxious 13y agoI can definately think of immigration cards/interviews as a case where that is true.
- csense 13y agoI heard somewhere that lying to police is punishable by something like three years in jail in the US. Unless you killed someone or are a repeat offender, lying may well get you a harsher sentence than your original crime. And of course, it's very easy to lie accidentally: You may honestly be confused, mis-remember, make a mistake, or tell them a true fact that doesn't fit with incorrect information they obtained from another source. Especially under the stress of being suspected, investigated, arrested, etc. Rule one of dealing with the police: Don't help them under any circumstances. Shut up and lawyer up immediately. For more information, watch this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc
- maxerickson 13y agoIt varies based on the jurisdiction. It is illegal to lie to federal law enforcement. There may not be laws against lying to state and local police (though I would imagine there are other laws that would be easy to break by lying to them).