3 ms·
"It kind of worked for a short period of time, but ultimately failed." So it's almost 100% false, but actually correct?
by bane 13y ago
"It kind of worked for a short period of time, but ultimately failed."
So it's almost 100% false, but actually correct?
- nl 13y agoThey had a strategy that was designed to hold ground (the OP said the strategy wasn't deigned to hold ground). The strategy failed. That doesn't mean it didn't exist.
- bane 13y agoI see what you're saying, but I'd argue that it wasn't a strategy for near on a decade until the top brass had to start facing the hard reality of the complete bankruptcy and failure of the original strategy. Perhaps the pendulum is swinging the other way?
- nl 13y ago2001-2002: Invasion and mostly conventional warfare against the Taliban. Successful. 2002-2005: Reduction in troop numbers. Total disaster. 2006-2010: Increase in troop numbers. "Control the ground" strategy implemented. Some initial successes, but many failures. 2011-present: Troop draw-down. This is pretty much code for "hand control back to the Taliban".
- mtdewcmu 13y agoDestroying things is what armies are good at. They pretty effectively destroyed the Taliban early on. But, then, I think, it came home to roost that you can't just destroy something and then leave and expect everything to be fine if there was never anything to take the place of the thing you destroyed. We've been trying to solve that puzzle ever since.
- djt 13y ago1% false 99% of the time