42 ms·
I'd really like to see a low-tax, low regulation part of the US (WA, NV, TX, or TN) where someone buys a few thousand acres and lets people build "temporary" st
by rdl 13y ago
I'd really like to see a low-tax, low regulation part of the US (WA, NV, TX, or TN) where someone buys a few thousand acres and lets people build "temporary" structures (with power/fiber/wifi/etc.) for living and solo-working, combined with some more permanent structures for offices, meetings, socialization, etc. Essentially like a 2-5 year Burning Man encampment campus for various startup projects.
If someone's "personal burn rate", while living comfortably and efficiently, were $10-15k/yr (while still eating great food, socializing, medical care, etc.), it would make mostly-equity compensation as part of a founding team really viable.
The point would be to get the benefits of density without the costs of luxury.
- Wingman4l7 13y agoI think you forgot a crucial bit of infrastructure that's a lot harder to slap together than power or internet: plumbing.
- rdl 13y agoSeptic tanks and water tanks work pretty well in semi-ruralish areas; you could either have a couple of trucks, or lay pipe. Or, have no plumbing in the temporary structures themselves, but have shower/bathroom trailers (which, admittedly, would suck a bit) separate from the temporary structures. I assume you'd build more infrastructure with time; putting in a real sewage plant would be expensive up-front and not really worth it for ~50 people on 2000 acres, but maybe in time. (You could even probably do zero-grid, with wifi/wimax/4g coverage to a couple of hard points with fiber, and decentralized electrical generation on each structure using solar/wind + batteries, at least to start.)
- redblacktree 13y agoReal-life SimCity?
- rdl 13y agoI may be influenced by living from 2004-2010 in either bombed out wrecks or "camps" in warzones, where this kind of stuff is routine.
- lostlogin 13y agoWondered if you were going to fess up and admit that you see anything better than a war zone as luxury. Out of curiosity, what's your ideal home?
- rdl 13y agoWell, the thing I'm trying to solve is density of hackers vs. cost. A suburban area completely taken over by hackers might also work. My ideal home is something that is less than 10% of my net worth.
- lostlogin 13y agoNow that would be nice - the house my wife and I life in is about 175-200% our net worth. I'd never thought of a condition like that.
- rdl 13y agoWhat I'd really like is a hangar with some vault/storage space nearby, so the hangar can be reconfigured for various projects (with tools/etc. on roller carts to a great degree, or in side partition areas with roller doors so they can be opened up to the main hangar space). Steel span structures are fairly cheap, but I suspect I could buy an old factory (ideally something fairly clean) for less than construction cost somewhere. A shotcrete shell with steel mesh would be fine too.
- sliverstorm 13y agoOr roads.
- sliverstorm 13y agoAre you proposing we endorse a shantytown? History has shown us those go downhill fast, and I don't see how temporary shelters won't turn into a shantytown (and amusingly enough become permanent, much like every piece of shanty-code I write)
- rdl 13y agoA shantytown full of rich (at least, in earning potential elsewhere) startup/burningman type people which grows around convenient fiber might be different than one full of labor surrounding a mine.
- sliverstorm 13y agoI don't really buy it. The hallmark of shantytowns is everything is "half-assed". I can't see tech workers breaking out the saws and sandpaper and building quality neighborhoods in their spare time, and nobody will invest real money and labor into something you intend to bulldoze in 3-5 years. You will also get a domino effect; people with money and the desire for a nice place to live will automatically avoid your shantytown, filling it with people that don't mind living in squalor, leading to a more squalid shantytown- thus looping back on itself.
- erikpukinskis 13y agoSo basically you're saying "that's hard and vaguely similar things have failed before." That's not much of a contribution to the discussion.
- sliverstorm 13y agoI'm saying "that doesn't make sense and the closest analogues failed before, please try to convince me more". This isn't a courtroom, but until rdl puts forth a solid case, the burden of proof is not upon the detractors.
- nitrogen 13y agoI can't see tech workers breaking out the saws and sandpaper and building quality neighborhoods in their spare time... Why not? Building physical things for yourself can be just as satisfying as building virtual things for others.
- brianobush 13y agoput this on a boat and we could have a tax haven like Sealand!
- rdl 13y agoblueseed would be more reasonable now :) although at sea you'd have much harsher environmental conditions, so construction would be more difficult and expensive, vs. on land.
- istorical 13y agoThere's no need for someone to buy a few thousand acres and let people build structures. You could move to several 250,000+ population cities in the Midwest and there are already startup communities, incubators, and coworking spaces. I live in Omaha and went to school in Lincoln, NE. Omaha is getting gigabit internet soon from CenturyLink, Kansas City has Google Fiber. I worked at an incubator in Lincoln for the summer after my sophomore year in college and got the chance to build whatever I wanted to build with a team of five other students with all expenses paid. There are startups here that have problems finding enough qualified technical talent. I actually laughed really hard when I interned in Palo Alto and saw the internet speeds at our office. Anyway, my point is that the problem isn't one of infrastructure. It's a chicken and egg problem in meatspace: if there were huge startups hubs in cheaper cities then it would be an easy decision for many to move to lower cost of living cities, but it's hard to start a movement. Silicon Valley's present success is the result of decades of tradition. What makes the small towns in the South Bay interesting places to live isn't the infrastructure but the density of interesting people. Edit: I should add that the cost of living in the Midwest for a decently frugal, childless hacker willing to live with roommates is indeed $15,000 or less.
- acgourley 13y agoJust a datapoint that I (as a healthy young adult) live on 18k. It's a comfortable life in a beautiful neighborhood near UC Berkeley. You could do better if you moved into an oakland apartment or bart-enabled suburb.
- manglav 13y agotangent: can I email you? I'm moving to SF in September and trying to conserve my funds, and it seems you know the area quite well. I'd be happy to buy you a drink in exchange for your time.
- dfc 13y agoWhere are you going to get staff for the great medical care facilities? I'm dating a girl who just graduated from medical school and I can't imagine any of her friends wanting to move next to shantytown. Do you think the burning man-esque campus would work over a 2-5 year time period with burning man level of sewage treatment facilities?
- rdl 13y agoBe within a medevac flight of Seattle or Austin.
- dfc 13y agoRotor wash destroys shantytown after dotcom mogul is medevaced to Seattle. News at 11.
- rdl 13y agoI lived in a GP Medium tent next to (100m) a medevac HLZ. Even a Chinook isn't a big deal if you set it up properly. You don't land right on top of the tents. Any kind of terrain feature helps, or just distance. I don't see why people assume "can have your own housing in a high density area" is inherently shoddy construction; 4 x 20' containers and about $20k in work could build something quite nice. "Writer's cabins" are exactly this model (although you don't get the option of building your own workspace; maybe something where you get space, or a shell, or a furnished cottage). I'd trust an engineer to build something a hell of a lot more than a YA fiction writer or particularly a postmodernist. :)
- dfc 13y agoI was running with the shantytown line just to be a pain. I dont hate the idea. I actually think it would be cool if you changed the "DIY/bring your own shelter" to a rehab existing structure and used the program as part of a city program to clean up decrepit neighborhoods.
- 13y ago
- lojack 13y agoYou'd be surprised with how easy this is to do without making any major changes to ones lifestyle. A bit over a year ago I quit my relatively high paying job with $1k in savings, moved to the midwest, and I've been living comfortably on around $15k/yr (I'm taking the luxury of removing my student loan payments from the equation). I don't own a car, live in an inexpensive house thats shared with a few other entrepreneurs in a similar situation, I stay reasonably frugal, and share many expenses. We all work out of an incubator that provides us with free office space (wouldn't significantly affect our numbers if we had to pay). Bootstrapping in the midwest has worked quite well for me, but there's certainly disadvantages. For one, a lot of the local investment capital is old money. Old money that is extremely conservative with their investments. If we ended up receiving capital, we'd likely be forced to move to a more expensive city largely because of proximity to the investor and more importantly for skilled labor. The good developers all tend to flock to SF or NYC where the pay is high. They still exist in the midwest, but you really need to hunt to find them. I'm an advocate for the midwest, there's challenges, some of which your concept may alleviate, but IMO it's perfect for bootstrapping a small team.