3 ms·
This is nothing new and has been around since people started to make usable software for computer systems. The idea has been tried to death with countless softw
by tluyben2 13y ago
This is nothing new and has been around since people started to make usable software for computer systems. The idea has been tried to death with countless software writing tools. MS DOS Dbase tools on top of dbase, written in clipper or what not to make CRUD applications by non programmers. There are generating tools from before that generating compile CRUD from just 'a business person definitions'. I have seen presentations from countless products like Filemaker, MS Access, Foxpro etc claiming that boring CRUD is gone and no programmers are needed anymore for application building.
When I was younger, one of the product managers for the Dutch product SDW told me that programming business software was something of the past as business people could just input 'how the app should work' and the app would be automatically built.
Outsystems have claimed this, as do Longjump and web based systems.
They all have something in common; they work for some cases, if you want more you have a problem. You CAN do it, but it's hard and the resulting 'code' (usually visual programming or 4GL) will usually be bad. Ohyeah, and you're still programming. Worse than you would have with actual developers from the start.
Note that most of them start out as simple systems, like this SteveApp. That's nice; it serves a purpose. But when you get users, people will request features and these feature will, in the end, require a full fledged programming language. So now you have non programmers creating an app up to a point which they still get and for more they'll hire you. They did a bit of 'programming' though in the built in language, which was made easy (which usually translates to visual and/or 'very much like English), so not very terse and often not very well written. Now you have 'code' like this http://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/6134596/Screenshots/uo079r9j~q3b.png http://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/6134596/Screenshots/uo079... and you only have to fix some extra features :)
- sorich87 13y agoI agree that the code generated by most software writing tools is horrible. That's why SteveApp doesn't even try to generate code in any programming language (unless you consider HTML a programming language of course). The trick used by SteveApp is to generate dynamic HTML views which have the ability to save the data over a standard server API. Dynamically generating a markup language is easier, and I think it can be done successfully with a software writing tool.
- tluyben2 13y agoI like that you are trying this anyway. I know and have worked with the tools I mentioned because I have a more than passing interest in them. Like you I do believe there must be some better way for a programmer to spend her or his time than implementing trivial but time consuming software (which, usually, has been repeated over the past 40 years 1000s of times without even referring to past endeavors).
- ippisl 13y agoI think that Ms lightswitch is designed to make it easy for developers to add features and extend the software later on.