6 ms·
I think there's something of an ulterior motive behind these stories. They present Chinese ingenuity in a charmingly harmless way - uneducated but plucky tinke
by jdietrich 13y ago
I think there's something of an ulterior motive behind these stories.
They present Chinese ingenuity in a charmingly harmless way - uneducated but plucky tinkerers, building some madcap machine out of scrap. In doing so, they subtly misrepresent Chinese industry by omission. China is rapidly transitioning away from low-skill, low-margin manufacturing to high-skill, high-margin R&D. The old jokes about Chinese R&D being a photocopier are wearing increasingly thin, as firms like Huawei become global players.
The article opens with the line "One visible sign of China's recent economic growth is the rise in prominence of inventors and entrepreneurs.", as if the photos that follow are in any way representative of invention in China. The real story is that Chinese R&D investment now amounts to over $160bn/yr and is set to surpass that of the US within the decade.
I'm reminded of the aphorism "First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." It seems we're still laughing at the 700m Chinese citizens who are uneducated peasants, rather than preparing to fight the 700m who are urbanised and increasingly well-educated.
- CamperBob2 13y agoIndeed. I'm old enough to remember when everybody in the US laughed at Japanese cars and the idiots who were foolish enough to buy them.
- kiba 13y agoWhy fight when you can co-opt them? Rather than thinking the chinese as just competition, we should also think of them as a world asset.
- sliverstorm 13y agoRather than thinking the chinese as just competition, we should also think of them as a world asset. I'm sure it'll be great for the world and all, but what happens when they aren't quite as thankful for you as you are for them?
- lostlogin 13y agoThe opposite is also a possibility. And that's even more concerning.
- westicle 13y agoWhy exactly do you want to fight them?
- auctiontheory 13y agoThis is Hacker News. And these are some pretty darn impressive hacks. Why not just appreciate what they've accomplished by their ingenuity, without adding all this geopolitical drama?
- yread 13y agoThis is Hacker News. We're critically thinking individuals. When somebody tries to spin a story for geopolitical goals it is fair to call it out.
- mc-lovin 13y agoWhat are the geopolitical goals of The Atlantic here?
- sliverstorm 13y agoThe same geopolitical goals The Atlantic has every night, mc-lovin. World domination.
- calibraxis 13y agoNot quite; the US's goal is world domination, which everyone knows. The Atlantic? Haven't looked closely, but its owner self-identifies closely with US government. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_G._Bradley https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_G._Bradley) The US press tacitly accepts US world domination: "'Withdraw all foreign forces and withdraw all foreign arms.' That official was Condoleeza Rice and she was not referring to U.S. forces, she was referring to Iranian forces and Iranian arms. And that makes sense, too, on the assumption that we own the world because, since we own the world U.S. forces cannot be foreign forces anywhere. So if we invade Iraq or Canada, say, we are the indigenous forces. It’s the Iranians that are foreign forces." "I waited for a while to see if anyone, at least in the press or journals, would point out that there was something funny about this. I could not find a word. I think everyone regarded that as a perfectly sensible comment." (http://www.zcommunications.org/we-own-the-world-by-noam-chomsky http://www.zcommunications.org/we-own-the-world-by-noam-chom...)
- mc-lovin 13y agoWhat exactly is the Chinese threat you are alluding to? What is going to happen when China does start working on high skill high margin stuff? And why would The Atlantic want to distract people from this? I'm just not getting your point here.
- kamaal 13y ago>>What is going to happen when China does start working on high skill high margin stuff? Chinese manufacturing was a threat, Indian outsourcing industry was also a threat. But the nature of threats was different. Chinese manufacturing and Indian software services was a threat ONLY because of their cost factor. And that was hardly any advantage these big nations had over the US, and the US didn't care because the day a cheaper alternative was found- It would mean the end for both China and India. The scary situation is when you find populations of the scale of China and India. With all their human resources, desperateness, passion and energy attack the big-ticket problems in the world. That is the kind of scenario which builds next super powers which replace the existing super powers.
- tluyben2 13y agoI find the scary situation that the educated, passion filled people might not be able to sustain the uneducated, solely desperate people when all these 100s of millions of factory workers are no longer needed (for whatever reasons, but robots seems likely). In India, the people I knew from 10-15 years ago who started booming software companies are firing / closing their doors because the prices are the same (or higher) as in parts of europe and the US while the quality definitely is not. The latter is communication barriers, culture etc, whatever, it happens a lot though. My friends are really desperate from work, unable to provide the higher quality requested by companies in the west while, on the other hand, also unable to provide the prices which makes lower quality attractive (to some). I'm more into software development than manufacturing, but I would assume similar (and other) cracks are appearing in China as well. Especially with cheap(er) robots (also used in the west) and optimized factory processes. Do you know examples, besides these inventors which are (probably) exceptions, of Chinese passion/energy attacks? The problems we hear about usually are huge projects which either are abandoned after building (unsafe, unusable) or destroy massive parts of nature and get people thrown out of their houses by the state. Both I wouldn't consider attacking big-ticket problems; former does nothing, the latter replaces one problem with a few others. But that might just be propaganda which is peddled in the west to 'educate us'. I'm eager to see good examples.
- benjamincburns 13y agoTo borrow an analogy from the art world, I'd agree with this if there was some well of 'negative space' in this article which was shaped like Chinese manufacturing. There isn't. The article also didn't discuss Indian ingenuity - is there something going on with that as well? To me this is article is utterly inspiring. This is about the hope of the individual. It's about a bunch of smart, motivated people taking big risks to better themselves and the people around them. They're thinking big, dreaming big, doing big, and surely ignoring the people around them who are telling them that they can't. Are some of them missing the mark? Absolutely! But if there's a statement being made here, it's an incredibly positive one.