4 ms·
Presumably part of the low return of VC is due to declining marginal returns due to too much money. If SF VC funding were somehow constrained to $1b/yr, you'd
by rdl 13y ago
Presumably part of the low return of VC is due to declining marginal returns due to too much money.
If SF VC funding were somehow constrained to $1b/yr, you'd get crazy percentage returns, since either only the top deals would get funded, or they'd be funded at super-favorable valuations (allowing more deals on the same money).
- rayiner 13y agoWell that's true in any sector. Returns go up when capital is scarce. But SF with $1b/year in VC funding would be economically insignificant, even if the returns were great.
- rdl 13y agoI guess my real point is that if my choice as an LP were a16z or some other asset class, I'd maybe even slightly overweight vc as an asset class. If I were an LP who could get into YC (maybe they would take a non profit like Watsi if they raise an endowment?), obviously overweight. But if you couldn't get into a top fund, and didn't personally know the founders of a 30-50mm fund which you thought would do exceptionally well (500 Startups?), I'd underweight or just avoid the asset class.
- rayiner 13y agoI don't disagree with you. If I were CALPERS and needed to throw around money $5 billion at a time for it to be worthwhile, I might avoid VC entirely. My point is more about what it says about the industry as a whole. Total Silicon Valley VC investment is in the neighborhood of $11-12 billion/year. If the rate of return on that relatively small investment is, on the whole, less than the S&P 500, then that really calls into question the whole narrative about how much economic value is really being generated from VC-funded startups. Blue-chip companies might not be able to yield Facebook-like returns, but they can apparently yield VC fund-like returns, and do so while absorbing far more capital.
- rdl 13y agoI'd like to see the IPO market re-open, and companies IPO around when they'd be doing large Series B today, or certainly anything after a B. Seed and maybe A are not capital intensive, and are probably constrained by great ideas, founding teams, and early entrepreneurial employees. But I don't think VC is the right way to finance lower risk later stage stuff; the public markets could do a good job, and it would be a lot easier for risk-seeking investors (individuals or institutions) to get in and out of investments vs. being LPs in funds, and with lower overhead.
- hga 13y agoI don't think any analysis of post-SarBox VC returns can be useful without examining the effects of the closing of the IPO exit. Sure, a very few, very exceptional companies can take this route, but it has otherwise been shut after a good 4 decade or so run.
- rdl 13y agoIn addition to lowering returns, it unfairly prevents smart but non-rich individual investors from investing in awesome opportunities like Tesla or SpaceX in 2008.
- hga 13y agoHmmm? The Dodd-Frank Act as of July 21, 2010 excluded an accredited investor's primary residence in counting their wealth (although for many I'm sure that was closing the barn door after the house's value plummeted), but I don't remember anything like that in SarBox (the accredited investor restriction goes back to 1933, thank you FDR).
- rdl 13y agoI meant that SarBox defers IPOs until stupidly late, so "normal" investors, reliant on the protections of the public market, don't get to invest early enough to make real money.