3 ms·
In VC there are 5-10 funds, universally known, who are the winners, and who continue to win. They get the best dealflow, meddle the least, and generally are on
by rdl 13y ago
In VC there are 5-10 funds, universally known, who are the winners, and who continue to win. They get the best dealflow, meddle the least, and generally are on top.
The crazy thing is that KPCB used to be in that set and then essentially voluntarily abdicated to do cleantech crap.
A16Z came from nowhere to join that set pretty much as they launched.
The others (greylock, sequoia, benchmark, accel, etc) are pretty static.
- rayiner 13y agoNote the distinction between some funds being consistent winners, and the whole set of winners being consistent over time. The 5-10 funds who are consistent performers: 1) aren't the whole of the "2%" who manage to make above-market returns over some time frame; 2) can't absorb all the money investors want to put into the venture capital as an asset class. That keeps the other VC firms who aren't Sequoia, etc, in business, even if the generated returns are less than stellar. That does not mean, however, that the other VCs are "losers." They still get their 2 and 20, and as long as everyone is consistently mediocre and the top VC funds can't absorb all the capital the big institutional investors have sloshing around, they'll keep being able to raise capital. Interesting (and fairly recent) analysis of VCs from the point of view of a limited partner with investments in a range of VC firms: http://www.kauffman.org/uploadedFiles/vc-enemy-is-us-report.pdf http://www.kauffman.org/uploadedFiles/vc-enemy-is-us-report..... The mediocre return of VCs also says something about Silicon Valley. The idea of venture-capital funded startups as some exceptional economic engine is probably a myth. There is a lot of economic activity in Silicon Valley, no doubt, but you have to distinguish between expenditure of capital and return on capital. $20 million spent on a startup that never ends up making much revenue is not a net gain to the economy even if it shows up as economic activity. It's just expenditure of capital. So the success of specific VCs aside, the way to measure the economic contribution of VC-funded startups is by looking at the return on investment of the sector as a whole. And since that return isn't great, relative to blue-chip companies, that tells us one of two things about the sector: Either: 1) VCs aren't great at the job of allocating capital to the right places; or 2) VCs are doing the best job they can, and its just inherently difficult to separate the winners from the losers when it comes to startups. My gut feeling is that the answer is (2), which implies that the nature of the industry is such that it's so hard to separate the winners from the losers that the gain from the exceptional success of the winners is largely offset by the cost of funding the losers, which makes the economic returns from the industry as a whole unexceptional compared to the returns from traditional blue chip companies.
- rdl 13y agoPresumably part of the low return of VC is due to declining marginal returns due to too much money. If SF VC funding were somehow constrained to $1b/yr, you'd get crazy percentage returns, since either only the top deals would get funded, or they'd be funded at super-favorable valuations (allowing more deals on the same money).
- rayiner 13y agoWell that's true in any sector. Returns go up when capital is scarce. But SF with $1b/year in VC funding would be economically insignificant, even if the returns were great.
- rdl 13y agoI guess my real point is that if my choice as an LP were a16z or some other asset class, I'd maybe even slightly overweight vc as an asset class. If I were an LP who could get into YC (maybe they would take a non profit like Watsi if they raise an endowment?), obviously overweight. But if you couldn't get into a top fund, and didn't personally know the founders of a 30-50mm fund which you thought would do exceptionally well (500 Startups?), I'd underweight or just avoid the asset class.
- rayiner 13y agoI don't disagree with you. If I were CALPERS and needed to throw around money $5 billion at a time for it to be worthwhile, I might avoid VC entirely. My point is more about what it says about the industry as a whole. Total Silicon Valley VC investment is in the neighborhood of $11-12 billion/year. If the rate of return on that relatively small investment is, on the whole, less than the S&P 500, then that really calls into question the whole narrative about how much economic value is really being generated from VC-funded startups. Blue-chip companies might not be able to yield Facebook-like returns, but they can apparently yield VC fund-like returns, and do so while absorbing far more capital.
- 13y ago
- jonmrodriguez 13y ago> to do cleantech crap. Considering that climate change already kills 150,000 people per year [1], and that this rate will continue to (dramatically) increase, I think it's pretty rude for you to belittle the few good people who choose to fund cleantech (putting their fellow man above short-term economic "rationality"). [1] http://www.who.int/heli/risks/climate/climatechange/en/ http://www.who.int/heli/risks/climate/climatechange/en/
- rdl 13y agoThe low hanging fruit in the space is energy. Big companies do their own incremental efficiency improvements in their own processes for other kinds of "cleantech" -- using waste products as feedstock, etc. Capital intensive, fairly proprietary, close to monopsony, etc. Horrible as investments. Cleantech/greentech was originally defined as "non-energy", because energy had a long history of being investable. Energy efficiency and generation is a great sector for investment (I am so excited about Bloom Energy and Lightsail and FLiBe). I'm not at all excited about most of the ex-energy investments, and it appears most of those have failed to the extent that people consider energy part of cleantech now. They were crap as investments, and most of the non-energy investments had bad science too, as well as being badly managed. I'm totally pro-environment and pro-efficiency. In the specific case of KPCB, they did a pretty horrible job with a lot of their portfolio. Missing Tesla and taking Fiskar was a great example. They did get Bloom. But I don't think they were approaching the sector with the kind of scientific and business rigor they used in the past for their other investments, and they were punished for it.
- jonmrodriguez 13y agoThanks for the elaboration of your point of view. I agree with you now.