4 ms·
Eleven people across UK arrested for racist comments on Twitter
- angersock 14y agoAs much as I would support an RFC to finally let us deliver facepunch-over-IP, this sort of punishment for online comments is horrifying. If the US had similar laws--well, I don't think it'd bode well for any of us.
- kefka 14y agoAnd here I am, in agreement with cricizing (read religious hateful comments) against Islam. After having looked at governments that are Islamic states, and the way they treat fellow people (religious and nonreligious), they deserve to be critically looked at. In Saudi Arabia, women who are raped are then killed for "being a whore". Little girls are trapped in a burning building because they didnt have their headscarves. And then there's the whole Sharia Law. Many Imams want Sharia installed in every western state possible. They do similar tricks as the Domionionists do here (right wing Christian extremists). If they could conduct the affairs of their own people and those innocents around them better (try humanely), then I'd not be writing this. Since they won't, I shall be vocal.
- notahacker 14y agoThis is mild by British standards. Harsh was sending a drunk student to jail for 56 days for some incredibly tasteless but obviously-trolling racist comments in a highly-publicised Twitter exchange, or the politician's wife who just lost a libel trial for writing "why is Lord McAlpine trending" when Lord McAlpine was trending because of speculation wrongly linking him to an accusation of child abuse. That said, the linked article, which repeatedly Godwins the discussion before it starts and (wrongly) speculates that Muslims don't get arrested for similar offences, is garbage.
- Blahah 14y agoThere is absolutely no context given in the article. In particular, we don't know what these tweets actually said. In general, free speech is quite well protected here (UK), but it is an offence to incite violence. The tweets and Facebook posts could conceivably have been threats of violence against individuals (groups, etc.), in which case it's no different to making that kind of threat in public in any other forum, i.e., illegal.
- dmix 14y agoIt said in the article what they are getting charged with: > The Malicious Communications Act 1988 is a British Act of Parliament that makes it illegal in England and Wales to "send or deliver letters or other articles for the purpose of causing distress or anxiety". It also applies to electronic communications. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malicious_Communications_Act_1988 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malicious_Communications_Act_19...
- josephlord 14y agoInciting racial hatred is also illegal even without any direct violent implication. I don't oppose this although it should be recognised that speech is restricted by this and a number of other laws.
- josscrowcroft 14y agoI stopped reading at the opening sentence: "Because it just wouldn't do to upset the sensibilities of those who might wish to cut your head off." This is implying guilt (or intention) on the part of the recipients of these racist messages, and seems to imply that it's OK to 'upset' (re: profile and aggravate) people if you think they're likely to cut your head off based only on their race or religion. Which is pretty low.
- joonix 14y agoDisgusting. Thankfully I live in the United States.
- DanBC 14y agoBecause US law enforcement would never stiffle anyone's freedom of speech, even if that was a ridiculous jokey comment? (http://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/01/30/u-k-tourists-deported-due-to-tweet-about-destroying-america/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/01/30/u-k-touri...)
- robmil 14y agoIt's happened quite a lot in the last few years, e.g. following the collapse of a black football player, Fabrice Muamba.[1] You have to consider the different context at play here; the UK has never had a history of "fundamentalist" (for want of a better word) free speech like there is in the US. There are plenty of laws on the books, from sending malicious communications to inciting racial hatred, that prevent speech that would be entirely legal in the US. I think that's something that's reflected (either a cause or an effect, I'm not sure which) in public opinion, too; there's certainly no widespread outcry here at these types of arrest. The only recent case I can think of where the ruling was against free speech and where public opinion was significantly against the ruling was the Robin Hood Airport tweet, where someone tweeted an obviously incredible threat to blow up an airport.[2] [1]: http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2012/mar/27/student-jailed-fabrice-muamba-tweets http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2012/mar/27/student-jailed-fabr... [2]: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-19009344 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-19009344
- lmm 14y agoInterestingly the biggest recent tweet/speech-related outcry I remember in the UK was a case of US authorities not seeing the funny side: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2093796/Emily-Bunting-Leigh-Van-Bryan-UK-tourists-arrested-destroy-America-Twitter-jokes.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2093796/Emily-Buntin...
- lutze 14y agoYeah, this article's blinkered, hyperbolic and frankly smug tone is pretty amusing when you take things like the above into context. He even sticks a "literally Hitler!" on the end for good measure.
- dmix 14y agoI apologize for posting blogspam but I refuse to post the DailyMail on HN. Either way the mods took this article off the frontpage. As a side note, the border security do not operate under the same laws as the US courts/police. It's a grey area where they can arbitrarily deny you for looking at them the wrong way. Free speech doesn't apply at border crossings. In addition noone was arrested domestically. Not the best analogy.
- Nux 14y agoRe arrests, I get why they're doing it - it's a bit tense to be a muslim in UK these days.
- pvnick 14y agoI wonder if chopping the heads off British soldiers in broad London daylight has anything to do with it?
- kefka 14y agoHOW DARE YOU mock Islam like that! We are a religion of peace and love!! Off with your head!
- Nux 14y agoKefka, stop with the hate comments already. It's not helping anyone.
- kefka 14y agoMy "hate" comments are directly related to those "hate" actions, like killing and maiming. Lest alone, shrouding words as "hate" words are poisoning, because it tries to defang legitimate criticism to "Oh lol, he's just a racist". And I do wish for a peaceful earth, full of multitudes of genetically different peoples, following different faiths and paths. And I'd like to be able to go up and ask them about that. However, we're not there, and tribal groups take hold instead. The best I can do is to highlight when a certain tribe acts up, whether that be the Catholic church, England, USA, UN, Islamic countries.. It matters not who does evil, but that it is called out (and stopped if possible).
- Nux 14y agoDooh! I'm assuming everybody is aware of the context. Now they're now afraid of a backlash. That guy killing the soldier really made the situation worse for muslims in UK.
- DanBC 14y agoFor some cultural context: two people recently murdered a soldier, and waited until police came to arrest them. While waiting they spoke to people, some of whom filmed their statements. Here's some BBC links (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-22644057 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-22644057) (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-22664835 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-22664835) Some of the arrests were before two competing groups held demonstrations in the same town. The English Defence League (hateful moronic racist thugs) and Anti-Facist something or other (a rag-tag bag of anarchists, tin pot trots, students, and anti-facists) were both holding demonstrations. Police are perhaps a bit antsy because both groups have had problems with violence, and this is exacerbated when they demonstrate at the same time. US citizens may not like our laws, but we -on the whole- do. It is a weird cultural difference between the UK and US.
- pidg 14y agoAgreed, I was quite surprised (as someone from the UK) at the point of view expressed in this article. It does highlight how different our cultures are in some respects. Most people in the UK would support this action - the police are arresting people who have made hateful, racist or threatening comments. Why is that bad?
- RK 14y agoI think the author of the article is probably someone an average person might consider an "activist" or the like, but I (an American) also feel like the report is alarming. It sounds like the kind of thing you'd expect from Saudi Arabia, rather than a democratic society. I suppose in the US we are more in the all-or-nothing camp when it comes to free speech (at least idealistically). Edit: Most people in the UK would support this action - the police are arresting people who have made hateful, racist or threatening comments. Why is that bad? The concern is that what is perfectly fine one day (and really truly legitimate) can be "bad" the next. Better not to have a category of "bad" speech at all. Otherwise you may be at whim of political fashion.
- pidg 14y agoFree speech in the UK (and the rest of the EU) is governed by Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which you can read here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_10_of_the_European_Convention_on_Human_Rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_10_of_the_European_Con... Basically, part 1 says "you have free expression", while part 2 says "unless that expression could seriously damage people's lives". Works for us.
- samwillis 14y agoThat article has very little context. I don't know if this received much coverage in the US but these arrests are for comments made in the aftermath of a murder of a British army cadet in broad daylight [1] the other day that has been called a terrorist attack. There has been a significant rise in racial aggression since the incident and that needs to be brought under control [2]. 1. http://m.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-22630303 http://m.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-22630303 2. http://m.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-22664835 http://m.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-22664835
- pvnick 14y ago>Do they even arrest Muslims for anti-religious speech? Good question. I'd actually like to know the answer to this.
- DanBC 14y agoYes, many members of various religious minorities are arrested for various forms of hate speech. The most recent well known example is the demonstration where extremists were making calls for violence on placards. But there are other less well known examples - London sometimes has problems between gangs of Sikhs and Muslims.
- wtil 14y agoAbsolutely, we've banned several Islamic fundamentalist organsations including, Al-Muhajiroun and Islam4UK. Both were proscribed under the UK's Prevention of Terrorism Act 2005.
- viraptor 14y agoI'm not sure how known this is, but in 2011 UK had a couple of days long riots in a number of cities. It was not justified in any way in my opinion - just a lot of people who took their general problems to the street and started destroying shops, cars, houses, attacking police. (that's the tldr, check wiki link for the details) With that kind of response to the social network comments, I think police is trying to prevent another such event aimed at a specific group. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_England_riots http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_England_riots Social networks were used quite a lot during that time to pass messages about the police locations and various events.