5 ms·
I don't see much difference between open plan and high-walled cubes in a large room. Noise and distractions are about the same. I think if you're going to tal
by ams6110 13y ago
I don't see much difference between open plan and high-walled cubes in a large room. Noise and distractions are about the same. I think if you're going to talk about private space vs. open you have to be talking about real offices with walls from floor to ceiling, doors that close, and which are (reasonably) soundproof.
- davesims 13y agoSorry, should have changed that to "offices", not cubes. Haven't spent much time at all in cubes, and the couple of months I did it was the WORST of all worlds.
- VLM 13y ago"Noise and distractions are about the same" I found interrupt rate increased for open plan by, oh, probably a factor of ten. Look, VLM isn't talking, therefore he must not be doing anything, lets ask him about last nights TV episode. If the cube wall is high enough that you can't see if the worker drone is in there much less on the phone (aka working) or actually working as in thinking, then you don't just yell at the guy across the room. I notice a massive impedance bump between the "knowledge workers" and the "talkers". Engineering and Finance and operations got along nearly perfectly because both know that not talking does not mean not working aka ready for interrupt please bug me. On the other hand management / customer service / sales, if they're not talking they're not working, so interrupt rate was horrible from those types, hmm I have a problem and those three are talking about football so they're busy, and that guy's talking to his wife on the phone so he's busy, I know I'll bug that guy looking at a component datasheet, obviously he's the only one here not doing anything. Marketing types were kind of in between, some understand that thinking is work, some don't.