3 ms·
This is established, but it doesn't help ONE bit in determining the age of the captured pirate. Here is how to find out his age: hand him over to the provision
by mahmud 18y ago
This is established, but it doesn't help ONE bit in determining the age of the captured pirate.
Here is how to find out his age: hand him over to the provisional unrecognized government of that part of Somalia, it's called Puntland, and let THEM use their local resources, find out who he is and who he went to school with.
If we handed Saddam Hussein to the provisional Iraqi government, and didn't bother bringing him here, then why would we get our hands dirty with the trial of some low-life criminal? I will tell you why, because someone in .gov thought it was a good idea to project the new administration as a transnational law-abiding citizen of the world, yet still capable of delivering ass-whooping solutions where necessary. It goes hand in hand with the Obama administration's image of itself as a Canada with a better military. All the sensitive feel-good B.S. of the /other/ developed nations, plus all the interventionist, gungho mentality of Bush Jr.'s
- tokenadult 18y agoHere is how to find out his age My first reply to you was to the issue of letting him go. The United States authorities who captured the pirate have good legal authority to keep him in their custody. But as to the issue of finding out his age, that is certainly an issue that his defense lawyers will bring up at his trial. That is always brought up if there is any doubt about a defendant's age. Any competent witness who has information about his age is likely to be called at trial, either by the defense or by the prosecution. If the provisional government of Somalia is in good working order, the witnesses will be produced at the trial and testify.
- mahmud 18y ago"Any competent witness who has information about his age is likely to be called at trial" And provide an opportunity for the prosecuting government to indulge itself as righteous and morally upright. This is cultural posturing at best, using one hungry man to an advance an agenda and project a world-wide image. There is no need to drag the issue any further; no American was harmed and no American ship was robbed. He is no Eichmann, hunted down to face justice. And he is no Hannibal, driven to Rome in shackles to face the imperial might he had the audacity to challenge. He is a hungry man with a rusty AK who risked his life in an unseaworthy vessel to take a shot at instant wealth, LA gang style. But my feeling is that the government will ride this pony until it gets what it wants, not just the global image improvement when he is slapped with an easy 10 year sentence, but possibly an American base or an outpost in his part of the world.
- tokenadult 18y agono American was harmed Are you seriously saying that being confined on a lifeboat with four armed men for days at sea is not any harm at all? In general, threatening people with deadly weapons crosses the line into "violent crime," even if none of the weapons are discharged. And the ship was carrying RELIEF SUPPLIES for Somalia, which were delayed in delivery to the pirates' compatriots.
- mahmud 18y agoI hope no one in the state department thinks like you or we would end up with a billion dollar budget to build air-conditioned American military bases in Boosaaso to protect our interests, safe-guard passage of ships and do a little nation building on the side. If they keep him here that will only invite more "pirates", an easy visa to the U.S. :-P (the guys you're trying to reason with are strung out on methamphetamines; good luck winning that debate.)