3 ms·
I offer this as a thought experiment for people on both sides of the debate: Is it acceptable to shout "Fire!" in a panic-stricken manner in a crowded theater?
by ColinWright 14y ago
I offer this as a thought experiment for people on both sides of the debate:
Is it acceptable to shout "Fire!" in a panic-stricken manner in a crowded theater?
If not, then you accept that there are circumstances when "free speech" is not applicable. If so, please defend your position, when such an act may lead almost directly to serious injury and perhaps death.
This question removes the connection with rape and perhaps might help to focus attention on "speech with consequences".
- pionar 14y agoYes, it's offensive, yes, it's disgusting, but how exactly does it "have consequences"? Do you really think someone is going to go rape a woman just because of this tasteless rhyme? That's ridiculous.
- ColinWright 14y agoDo you think speech like this has no consequences at all? That's what I'm trying to find out, whether people believe this sort of thing genuinely has zero effect. Personally, I think speech and communication in general goes both ways. It reflects what the source thinks and feels, and in turn affects what the listener/reader thinks and feels. I think there is an effect. Do you think there is none? And then there is the other aspect. Do you believe that speech with consequences should be censored or controlled? Or do you believe that all speech, even shouting "Fire" in a crowded theater, should be uncensored and uncontrolled? You appear not to have answered the question I actually asked.
- glomph 14y agoAll speech has an effect otherwise no one would bother talking. The question is not whether it has an effect, but whether it causes enough harm to justify stopping it. Older than the fire in the theater example (which if I remember rightly comes from a supreme court case in the US) is John Stuart Mill: >An opinion that corndealers are starvers of the poor, or that private property is robbery, ought to be unmolested when simply circulated through the press, but may justly incur punishment when delivered orally to an excited mob assembled before the house of a corn-dealer, or when handed about among the same mob in the form of a placard. But he then of course gives one of the most brilliant defenses of free speech in all circumstances other than direct harm ever written. Do you think this is going to cause direct harm?
- djent 14y agoI know you're trying to remove the connection to rape to help solve the dispute, but bear with me. Would shouting "Tape her and rape her" in a crowded theater be acceptable? It would certainly be disruptive, and you'd be asked to leave, but it wouldn't carry any serious consequences to the other theater-goers. I guess my point is that the comparison of rape and "fire" is not appropriate.
- theorique 14y agoIf so, please defend your position, when such an act may lead almost directly to serious injury and perhaps death. Almost any speech more threatening than a mild children's book could legitimately be suppressed by these criteria. Action film? Might encourage people to act violently. Jackass and other prank/stunt shows? Might encourage people to take stupid physical risks. Video games? Might normalize violent behavior and actions and cause people to act violently. There's a reasonable argument for age restrictions in 'adult' material. Children or feeble-minded individuals might not 'get' that comedians joking about rape doesn't make it OK, or violent acts in video games aren't to be emulated by amateurs. But restricting speech that might have 'consequences' has the potential to restrict all speech, as long as a bureaucrat can come up with a wild story about how a long chain of cause-effect from that speech might eventually cause harm.