4 ms·
I used to work for DESCO. Some seriously smart folks there and especially in the DESRES group. That's the thing though. The top engineering talent goes to fi
by busterarm 13y ago
I used to work for DESCO. Some seriously smart folks there and especially in the DESRES group.
That's the thing though. The top engineering talent goes to financial companies in New York because that's what's fashionable there. There's an actual cultural difference.
There's one other big cultural difference that has an affect on who wants to do tech startups. In SV people care about "What can you do?/What have you done?" where in NY it's more "Where did you go to school?/What's your pedigree?" and in my experience, Ivy Leaguers are generally funneled into Finance. There is a lot of money spent on recruiting them, so it's easier to just take the hedge fund job out of school than go work for or found a startup.
When Jeff Bezos, who used to work for DESCO, founded Amazon, he didn't do it in New York.
- rayiner 13y ago> The top engineering talent goes to financial companies in New York because that's what's fashionable there. There's an actual cultural difference. Right, and in Silicon Valley the top engineering talent tends to go to advertising companies (Google, Facebook, Twitter, etc). What does that matter? Advertising and finance are both industries flush with relatively easy cash right now, of course people are going to seek out jobs in those areas. > There's one other big cultural difference that has an affect on who wants to do tech startups. In SV people care about "What can you do?/What have you done?" where in NY it's more "Where did you go to school?/What's your pedigree?" That's true and is probably a bigger substantive differnce. Though, ever since Google made it a thing to recruit heavily from Stanford, tech has been a lot more pedigree-sensitive. I don't know if it's necessarily a bad thing, but it's certainly different. Indeed, if aversion to pedigree-sensitivity is a concern, I'd argue that a better place to focus your startup-founding energies would be D.C. There's good bootstrapping opportunities vis-a-vis government contracts and contracting to established defense/telecom players in the city, and the "old guard engineer" mentality in this industries places very little emphasis on pedigree (even though D.C. is otherwise an extremely prestige-conscious city).
- busterarm 13y ago> Right, and in Silicon Valley the top engineering talent tends to go to advertising companies (Google, Facebook, Twitter, etc). What does that matter? Advertising and finance are both industries flush with relatively easy cash right now, of course people are going to seek out jobs in those areas. Right, I'm not saying it matters at all other than if you're a competing business, you're going to have a hard time recruiting against these firms. It's not always just a money thing either. I don't think SV is any better than NY though. I work for an SV-based company remotely. Both cultures are kinda terrible and both cities are only chasing after 'easy money' industries without trying to bring in other business. If the money suddenly dried up in advertising, the Valley would be in a bad way just as much as a slump in Finance would crush New York. Politically, New York has to do a lot more to attract other business. Maybe an incentive to financial companies to fund/start businesses in STEM fields. Otherwise it's never going to happen.
- untog 13y agoThe top engineering talent goes to financial companies in New York because that's what's fashionable there. There's an actual cultural difference. I think that was the case, but it certainly isn't now.
- busterarm 13y agoAs much as the Occupy movement made a splash in the news, I haven't really seen an impact in the employment prospects of my circles in NY. I haven't seen a single person leave finance other than on the grounds of being overworked and burnt out.
- untog 13y agoNot sure what the Occupy movement has to do with it- I'm talking about engineers in the startup industry. NYC barely had a startup industry a few years ago, now I know a great many talented engineers employed by it. People might not be leaving finance, but I'm not sure how many engineers are going to it. It's definitely not "cool" here any more.
- tomkarlo 13y agoIt was never cool, unless you were going to be a Master of the Universe or BSD trader. It just paid really well. It still pays well.
- busterarm 13y agoExactly. It's only ever been cool to people looking to get "Fuck You Money". But it still goes back to the pedigree thing. NY is an extremely pedigree-sensitive city and it's way more impressive to talk at cocktail parties about what financial you work for than what no-name-startup/consultancy/generic-design-shop you're working for. My social circle shrunk noticeably when I left my hedge fund gig in 2008 and worked as a bike messenger; New Yorkers only care about (potential) money.
- 13y ago