4 ms·
Because it's not obvious. Ask developers to recite the rules for correct email address, and most of them will get it laughably wrong. I blame the standard, whic
by jerf 14y ago
Because it's not obvious. Ask developers to recite the rules for correct email address, and most of them will get it laughably wrong. I blame the standard, which is far more "featureful" than is actually required, but that is the way it is.
- jfb 14y agoIt's featureful because it's old. Who routes email to UUCP any more? Just look at the sections of 5322 that are devoted to "Obsolete Syntax".
- jerf 14y agoActually, I was just thinking the core error was something else; conflating routing with identity. bob@subgenius.com is a routing instruction, 'J. R. "Bob" Dobbs' is a human identity, and '"J. R. 'Bob' Dobbs" <bob@subgenius.com>' is just a mess.
- tomjen3 14y agoSo don't attempt to register an email with comments in it, or for that matter with an ip host. We need a much more restrictive standard for emails, but until we have that we have to accept that each site will have a competing not-completely-overlapping set of standards. So make sure your email doesn't attempt to do anything too funny.
- jerf 14y agoI feel about this much the same way I feel about the endless proliferation of Markdown variants; if we could all agree on one simplification, sure, but the current situation where we haven't really stinks. For instance, ask early Gmail users about putting + in the email. So while I agree with you in principle, in practice it seems infeasible. The differences bite in practice, unfortunately.