2 ms·
I wonder if you oughtn't reconsider how important the IRS+ scandal is (for some targets, it went way past the IRS, even audits by them, e.g for Truth the Vote t
by hga 13y ago
I wonder if you oughtn't reconsider how important the IRS+ scandal is (for some targets, it went way past the IRS, even audits by them, e.g for Truth the Vote the FBI, OSHA and BATF all piled on). This systematic suppression by the ruling class* of their opposition implicates the 1st Amendment freedoms of religion†, speech, assembly and petition (e.g. unruly "Town Hall" events).
There's a lot of maxims out there that generally start with "soap box", put ballot box and/or jury box in the middle and end with "bullet box" at the end, and pushing a very large fraction of the polity out of the public square tends to have grave consequences. So far some of them are a massive distrust of one of the essential organs of government (tax collection) and an asterisk that honest historians are going to have to put after mentioning Obama's reelection.
That Team Obama is going after the press just completes the attacks on every single provision of the 1st Amendment (at least if you accept that "secular humanism" or whatever you want to call it is now the established religion, although in all fairness that far predates Obama).
* This is not entirely or perhaps even mostly partisan, for most of the people being suppressed are existential threats to the Republican party establishment, just ask ex-Senator Lugar who's now spending more time with his family. On the other hand, Kimberly Strassle of the WSJ reminds us this started out in 2008 against anyone who opposed Obama, as well as anyone opposing Democrats: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324659404578501411510635312.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142412788732465940457850...
† Religious organizations were asked impermissible questions that touched on the details of their theology and the like.
- jbooth 13y agoYou're not contradicting my contention: Lots of political groups were applying for charitable status, they're not allowed to have it, and it's the IRS's job to flag those groups, filter them out and inform them that their donations are not tax-deductible. Any political group asking for charity status was not being persecuted -- they were being very properly informed that they're not a charity. If any actual charity was caught up in this dragnet, then that charity was persecuted. Look at it this way: This IRS dept (overseen by a bush appointee) in a particular year sees a lot of bogus charity 501c4 applications using the word "foobar". They set up a filter on the word foobar to flag any entries containing it for manual review. Completely reasonable, right? Now change "foobar" to "tea party". That's where they screwed up on CYA, they should've added a bunch of democratic party type keywords to the list and then they're good.
- hga 13y agoYou are very confused. 501(c) status is about being a non-profit, not necessarily a "charity". Only a few of the current 27 categories of 501(c) organizations can reasonably be called charities, look at the list: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/501(c)_organization#Types http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/501(c)_organization#Types, e.g. see 501(c)(16) for farmer's coops. 501(c)(4) organizations are mostly not charities, e.g. the NRA's lobbying arm, the Institute for Legislative Action, and the current version of Obama's Organizing for America (Organizing for Action) are examples that passed IRS muster, and the vast majority of the ones maltreated by the IRS were going for that status.
- jbooth 13y agoOFA only switched to a tax-exempt organization in January 2013. I don't know the full story behind that, but I feel that their activity before 2013 was primarily political and shouldn't be tax-exempt (and it wasn't).
- hga 13y agoAnd their first big campaign as a 501(c)(4) was gun control, and that's not political? Note, I'm not saying that's wrong, in fact, it mirrors the NRA's ILA on the opposite side of that fight. Look, we had an established system for doing this sort of thing, and it makes no sense whatsoever to make political organizations organize as for profit entities, monetary return on investment is not their game. And donations for political purposes to 501(c)(4) orgs are not tax deductible for the donors. What we'd like is a return to the level playing field pre-Obama, but I don't know of anyone who believes that will happen, e.g. the IG finished the audit of the program in the middle of last year, obviously didn't release the results, but most damningly didn't stop the abuse, which continues to this day.
- jbooth 13y agoThat's actually a legitimate argument. In theory, there could be a tea party group that was doing issue advocacy and not campaigning for candidates. In practice, many of them were in fact advocating for candidates, and the IRS screwed up by not scrutinizing all issue groups equally. You've actually changed my mind a little on this. I don't believe that this was some nefarious obama socialist plot (under a Bush appointed supervisor) as you seem to but I now think that the IRS actually screwed up as opposed to failed to cover their ass. So good job. Honest question: If extra review of obviously-political groups calling themselves social welfare organizations were perfectly balanced across the political spectrum, would you support it?