5 ms·
There was an article on BI a few days ago saying how "Americans don't care" about the AP spying (from a survey), and that they cared a lot more about IRS and Be
by mtgx 13y ago
There was an article on BI a few days ago saying how "Americans don't care" about the AP spying (from a survey), and that they cared a lot more about IRS and Benghazi.
But let's put things in context. The IRS scandal, and especially the Benghazi one, have been trumpeted at least 10x more than the AP one. Maybe 100x more. With such "awareness campaign" is it really a surprise most people responded in the surveys with IRS or Benghazi?
So what this really means is that the media themselves don't really care about the AP spying - which is actually quite frightening, and a worse situation than I thought. You'd think they would want to turn this into another Watergate or something - but apparently not. Same for the Fox News journalist.
These two stories would be reason enough to call for the impeachment of the president in my book. I mean it threatens a core power in the society - the press. The Benghazi story, and even the IRS one to "some" degree, are the real distractions here.
- jbooth 13y agoYeah, I hate that circular logic. Americans drink more coke than pepsi, look at the advertising budgets. You hammer something on prime time every night for 6 months and people will think it's a bigger deal than the story you don't. There's not an actual scandal behind Benghazi. Literally none. They're alleging a cover-up, "of what?", "they're covering it up!". That's the whole story and somehow it's 6 months of airtime. The IRS story is just bad CYA by the administrators there. Political groups applying for charity status is in fact something that the IRS should be auditing and cracking down on, regardless of political party, and there were a lot of tea party groups applying for charity status -- The dept head was actually a Bush appointee, they just weren't tactful enough about how they set their filters to make it look more bipartisan. This leak case, on the other hand, is actual erosion of press freedoms. And the media (?!?!?!!) seem to care the least about it.
- shardling 13y agoWell, the New Yorker has been printing exactly your stance on this, so at least some elements of the media care. :)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- spinchange 13y agoWithout asserting criminality, the Benghazi affair was entirely deserving of serious inquiry and investigation but regrettably we such have such immature and partisan Government that the opposition party chose to make it a completely farcical political spectacle. So much that, it is easier for reasonable people to assume there's nothing to any of it other than political attacks when in fact there clearly was some kind of bureaucratic ineptitude and they were officially blaming a YouTube video for weeks.
- Nrsolis 13y agoI'm not sure if I agree with you about Benghazi. Brandon Webb and the guys over at SOFREP have been doing a fair bit of reporting on the subject. tl;dr: Benghazi was a colossal screwup and exposed how JSOC operations in the area put State Department people at risk.
- jbooth 13y agoObviously, if people died, then someone screwed up bad. But the "scandal" hasn't been about who screwed up. It's been about whether Obama used the word terrorism enough times in the aftermath, and nebulous accusations of "cover-up" with no actual allegations of wrongdoing that's being covered up. It's pathetic.
- hga 13y agoThat part of the scandal is about Team Obama blaming this on the Emmanuel Goldstein du jore, who's still in jail. Otherwise you have to accept the Administration's narrative that Arab mobs routinely bring RPGs and mortars to their protests of insults to their religion.
- cinquemb 13y agoMaybe it is because the media has traditionally been at the end of the strings of the State[0], so to be surprised about such actions seems kinda naive. Some people probably stopped taking orders… But it is interesting/amusing to see the State encroaching upon itself and its own devices in the pursuit of terrorism or whatever thing we're supposed to be fighting these days. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CIA_influence_on_public_opinion#Use_of_mass_media https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CIA_influence_on_public_opinio...
- hga 13y agoLying to everyone about Benghazi to maintain a narrative about terrorism prior to the election satisfies most people's definition of a scandal. And for some reason the people on the ground, even in the country, were told to stand down rather than attempt to help, something that no one can remember ever happening before. Really now, this is the first Ambassador killed in the line of duty in 33 years (previously under Carter, of course) and you're sure there's nothing suspect about it?!??!!! Your claims about the IRS abuse completely fail, since no "progressive" organizations suffered such abuse. One group even resubmitted their application, just changing the name to include the word Green and sound progressive, and it sailed through the process. And stonewalling != investigation, many groups were delayed for 3+ years, two election cycles, and are still left hanging. Compare to many many other examples, like Obama's Organizing for America -> Organizing for Action 501(c)(4). You may have no problems with the heavy hand of the government suppressing those you politically oppose, but I assure you the other side does, and as I note elsewhere in this subthread this sort of thing has grave consequences.
- jbooth 13y agoIf it were just about my political preferences, I'd be thrilled that conservatives can't shut up about Benghazi. It didn't play during the last election, it won't play during the next one, and makes Republicans look like frothing at the mouth idiots. But I'm actually concerned as an American about real issues, even real criticisms of Obama that get no attention while this idiocy goes on.
- hackinthebochs 13y agoAnd this is why they say to keep politics off of HN. None of your assertions are backed up by fact. It's really disheartening to see this nonsense here.
- hga 13y agoIn other words, you have no basis to deny my words, so you want them banned on this forum.
- tshile 13y agoAs an American that doesn't care, I can say that the media is in quite a hypocritical situation with this one. They've had 10 years to look into this, to take a stance, to confront the US Government on the issue. For 10 years they've ignored, or not cared, about issues like wire tapping, searching through emails and phone records, etc without a warrant. Issues like locking up an american citizens indefinitely without a right to trial. Issues like using drones to kill americans. They've ignored these issues for going on 10 years because, I assume, they felt they were immune to them. That they had protections against them that 'regular' Americans didn't. Now they find out and they are just as susceptible to those rules as the rest of us an want to put a rallying cry for us to come to their side? Even further they want special legislation protecting them from it, while leaving the rest of us unprotected? Please. The media deserves absolutely zero sympathy on this one. Maybe if they were doing their jobs, maybe if they actually cared about the American people the way they claim, they wouldn't be in this mess.
- hga 13y agoI wonder if you oughtn't reconsider how important the IRS+ scandal is (for some targets, it went way past the IRS, even audits by them, e.g for Truth the Vote the FBI, OSHA and BATF all piled on). This systematic suppression by the ruling class* of their opposition implicates the 1st Amendment freedoms of religion†, speech, assembly and petition (e.g. unruly "Town Hall" events). There's a lot of maxims out there that generally start with "soap box", put ballot box and/or jury box in the middle and end with "bullet box" at the end, and pushing a very large fraction of the polity out of the public square tends to have grave consequences. So far some of them are a massive distrust of one of the essential organs of government (tax collection) and an asterisk that honest historians are going to have to put after mentioning Obama's reelection. That Team Obama is going after the press just completes the attacks on every single provision of the 1st Amendment (at least if you accept that "secular humanism" or whatever you want to call it is now the established religion, although in all fairness that far predates Obama). * This is not entirely or perhaps even mostly partisan, for most of the people being suppressed are existential threats to the Republican party establishment, just ask ex-Senator Lugar who's now spending more time with his family. On the other hand, Kimberly Strassle of the WSJ reminds us this started out in 2008 against anyone who opposed Obama, as well as anyone opposing Democrats: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324659404578501411510635312.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142412788732465940457850... † Religious organizations were asked impermissible questions that touched on the details of their theology and the like.
- jbooth 13y agoYou're not contradicting my contention: Lots of political groups were applying for charitable status, they're not allowed to have it, and it's the IRS's job to flag those groups, filter them out and inform them that their donations are not tax-deductible. Any political group asking for charity status was not being persecuted -- they were being very properly informed that they're not a charity. If any actual charity was caught up in this dragnet, then that charity was persecuted. Look at it this way: This IRS dept (overseen by a bush appointee) in a particular year sees a lot of bogus charity 501c4 applications using the word "foobar". They set up a filter on the word foobar to flag any entries containing it for manual review. Completely reasonable, right? Now change "foobar" to "tea party". That's where they screwed up on CYA, they should've added a bunch of democratic party type keywords to the list and then they're good.