4 ms·
Some of this advice is appallingly facile: for instance: > 7. “Turn your passion into a business” If, like me, your passion is laying around on the couch in y
by danso 14y ago
Some of this advice is appallingly facile: for instance:
> 7. “Turn your passion into a business”
If, like me, your passion is laying around on the couch in your underwear and eating chocolate then I wouldn’t assume there’s anything profitable in that. Problems are profitable. Passions, not so much
Hello, if your main passions in life are laying around on the couch in your underwear, then maybe you shouldn't launch a startup.
Second, it's hard to think of a successful startup that isn't rooted in at least one of its cowfounder's passions. The founders of Google and Facebook, respectively, really did want to organize the world's information and get laid.
The OP links to this article, also by the OP: http://venturevillage.eu/sweet-poison-of-the-internet http://venturevillage.eu/sweet-poison-of-the-internet
In it, the OP slams the stupidity of music startups, including such, I guess, loser startups as Spotify and SoundCloud...seems like the OP has a standard for immediate return on investment that most startups would never meet. Certainly, we wouldn't have Google or Facebook if their founders followed this advice.
- calinet6 14y ago> Hello, if your main passions in life are laying around on the couch in your underwear, then maybe you shouldn't launch a startup. This is appallingly haughty. There are dozens of reasons to lay around on the couch in your underwear, the important thing is that you find a reason not to also.
- danso 14y agoI thought about expounding on this but figured the main OP's error of conflation was so obvious that it wasn't worth it. "Lying on the couch" is not really a passion, it's a way to rest/recuperate/replenish your emotional reserve, insert-something-from-Daniel-Kahneman-here, etc. So when the OP uses it as an example of a passion to argue that making businesses from passions is a stupid, dangerous idea...sorry, isn't the logical fallacy here pretty obvious?
- calinet6 14y agoOf course it is, but apparently the joke isn't very obvious. Yeah he's making fun of passion; he's using a hyperbole to illustrate the anti-passion he's talking about. He's not using a perfect logical argument to say that having passion is a bad thing; he's making a joke about people who are overtly passionate about their startup to the point where it blinds them to the forces outside themselves to which they should also be paying attention. I've struggled with this as well. My passions first and foremost are science, art, design, photography, literature, philosophy. I am not passionate about sitting behind a computer screen for 12 hours a day. I do it anyway because I want to build something of value and use my full potential to do so. Following my passion is not what I'm always doing with my time; sometimes I have to put my passions aside and get down to digging. http://www.poemhunter.com/poem/to-be-of-use/ http://www.poemhunter.com/poem/to-be-of-use/ It is fun and illogical to joke about this: if I had my way I might be a nature photographer, following in the footsteps of David Muench, Galen Rowell, and Ansel Adams. I could make a modest living maybe, but it would be a hard path and it wouldn't scale—basically it wouldn't have the large impact I believe I have the potential to contribute using technology. Could I integrate all of this into my work? Of course. And I do. But if I was to follow that passion alone like a Ahab's whale, I may not reach something of true value: there's not a big problem to solve in the nature photography space. Or heck maybe there is, but probably not a good one, or maybe the market is already too crowded, or maybe that's too much of a niche. The point being: simply going after my passion isn't going to net me something of real value to the world. I have to widen my perspective a bit. In other words, I have to get off the couch and get dressed. That's the sarcastic joke. In fact, he linked to an article about the subject: http://venturevillage.eu/sweet-poison-of-the-internet http://venturevillage.eu/sweet-poison-of-the-internet -- It's pretty good. He's not saying "passion is always bad"—he's saying that passion is an inward pulling force, it blinds you to an outside perspective, and that you should be aware of that and balance your passion with the world at large. Excellent advice.
- danso 14y agoYour post contains worthwile discussion and well thought out points...but I'm reluctant to address it because you've seemed to miss the part in my post where I actually clicked through to the OP's underlying elaboration and found it to be as poorly supported as the statement of the OP's that you consider just to be a rhetorical technique.
- arbuge 14y agoNothing creates passion like traction.
- ryanSrich 14y ago> Google, Facebook Again, these are serious outliers. Building a business around a passion is dangerous. What you should do is build it around customers, around a niche market; shit build it for the profitability. Building it because it's your passion is not the thing to do. That's not to say you can't be passionate about a profitable idea but be sure profit comes before passion if you want a successful venture.
- danso 14y agoHow are they outliers? Are they outliers because of their success? Or are they outliers because their founders were passionate about their fundamental mission, and despite this passion, they managed to become huge tech companies? That's a strange use of outlier for the purpose of this argument. Ok, I'll use another example: Tumblr. Amid the news of the sale, Marco Arment blogged about David Karp was so doggedly passionate about building the community. Yes, another outlier, but if you are going to call passion one of the most "dangerous" things for a business...then it seems a bit strange that many successful businesses have quite a bit of underlying passion. (Oh, and Steve Jobs and Steve Woz, just in case that wasn't already automatically accepted). In any case, my argument is not completely sound. While the most successful companies have been founded on passion, it's possible that the vast majority of passionate founders fail. In fact, this is probably the case. But in order for the OP's statement to have any validity to it, one must show that companies not built on someone's personal passion have a higher rate of success. This is extremely heard to quantify, but I'd be interested in just seeing a list of non-passion companies that are considered unambiguous successes.
- calinet6 14y agoOutlier was the wrong word. I think they meant "confirmation bias."
- ryanSrich 14y ago> Passion I'm now feeling like this is the wrong word and I'll refer back to the article: It's assumed anyone founding a startup is going to have passion. Whether they have passion about the solution, the problem, the market, etc. There is some level of passion and I agree with that. However I'm not going to concede to the idea that you need to be passionate about everything your startup does in order for it to be successful, nor should you base founding a startup purely on the fact that you have passion for an idea. > Ok, I'll use another example: Tumblr. You're using gigantic, successful, well regarded companies that get huge amounts of press. Right now I'm thinking of a local startup in my area (Western NY) and I'll refrain from naming them, but they were funded early last month. I've had several conversations with one of the co-founders and he actually founded the company based entirely on the lack of a solution in their market as pointed out by one of his friends. He didn't live in the space, work in the space, or have interest in the space. He took the idea, tested his hypothesis, found a technical co-founder, and launched all based on market viability, not passion.
- hrktb 14y agoThe way the OP put it's easily dismismissable. But really, you should think twice, and a few more times perhaps, before thinking about monetizing what you _really_ like. There are times where you can see good opportunities related to your passions, but the focus should be on what products you could build, and not just to mix money and fun. Just imagine the OP's passion is not lying on the sofa but raising his kids. Or preaching some religion, or doing things with his wife, or crushing bugs, or watching the sky change colors. There are ways to turn these into businesses, but it's not much related to the fun you had when doing them, and it might not motivate you anymore than digging holes in the desert.