4 ms·
Google abandoning open standards is nothing new. It seems they'll use open standards only as long as it serves them, but when they've grown big enough to domin
by josteink 13y ago
Google abandoning open standards is nothing new.
It seems they'll use open standards only as long as it serves them, but when they've grown big enough to dominate the competition, they'll turn around in a heartbeat and exploit that.
Just look at what they did to the open web with Chrome.
First they said "Web standards are important, so here is a good, fast and web-standards compliant browser. Feel free to try it". After a while that was not enough, and on every single web-page they had they had a big "Use Chrome!" ad for every visitor not using it already.
Once they had gained enough dominance, suddenly Google started using non-W3C HTML in their production web-sites. HTML which had not been fully drafted or ratified and which was only available as they saw fit in web-kit.
And then all the other non-Google browsers were suddenly "slow" on "adopting new HTML standards". Basically through its internet dominance, and now its browser, Google pushed through its own implementation of proprietary HTML features as standards other browsers had to implement, without any discussion, feedback or other input.
Google just decided that they alone should dictate how the HTML-standard is from now on.
After seeing that happen, I lost all belief in Google as a company which I will rely on for anything more than I strictly need to.
- lucian1900 13y agoThis is not the case at all, though. WHATWG is a good example of several browser makers cooperating. The only thing entirely Chrome-only is NaCl and it's not exposed to web pages (just extensions).
- Kequc 13y agoAre you from the future? Because Chrome is leaving webkit in the coming weeks but they still haven't yet. Chrome uses the full set of W3C standards in use though webkit and not any custom version of it. http://www.theverge.com/2013/4/5/4186302/google-chrome-blink-coming-to-chrome-28-in-10-weeks http://www.theverge.com/2013/4/5/4186302/google-chrome-blink...
- StavrosK 13y ago> It seems they'll use open standards only as long as it serves them To be fair, how did XMPP serve them? They weren't really benefitting from it, they did it mostly for the good of the community.
- msbarnett 13y agoIt let people seamlessly move to gchat from compatible chat services, which led to quick uptake (it's the only reason I started using pretty much as soon as it was available) and got Google a lot of chat logs to datamine.
- munificent 13y ago> It seems they'll use open standards only as long as it serves them, but when they've grown big enough to dominate the competition, they'll turn around in a heartbeat and exploit that. I don't see how Google is dominating the competition. Gchat used to be a dominant player, I believe, but that was before mobile existed. I think the dominant players now are: iMessage. Propriety, only runs on Apple devices, can only communicate with other iMessage users. Facebook Messenger. Proprietary, only runs in Facebook site and app, can only communicate with other Facebook users. WhatsApp. I think based on XMPP? Only runs in WhatsApp application, can only communicate with other WhatsApp users. Notice that every single one of those is a walled garden.
- jadyoyster 13y agoUnlike WhatsApp, Facebook chat is accessible via standard non-federated XMPP, so you can use it with any XMPP client.
- brent_noorda 13y agoEmbrace, Extend, Exterminate, Exmpp.