3 ms·
Care to share links? If not then I still consider the national weather service to be more definitive. Particularly since what it says agrees perfectly with th
by btilly 13y ago
Care to share links? If not then I still consider the national weather service to be more definitive. Particularly since what it says agrees perfectly with the physics courses that I took 20+ years ago, which indicated that the taller and pointier a metal object is, the better a target it becomes for static electricity discharges of all kinds - including lightning.
- eaurouge 13y agoThey actually INCREASE it by making your house TALLER. the taller and pointier a metal object is, the better a target it becomes for static electricity discharges of all kinds... I'm not disputing any of the above. But how much more likely or "better a target" does the rod make it? I couldn't find any quantitative measure of the increase in odds. Do you have any? If the odds of a strike are increased by just 1%, that statement by the NWS is still correct. Would you discount the use of a lightning rod because it ever so slightly increases the odds of a strike, when you know it also offers the additional benefits of dissipation and a safe path to ground?
- btilly 13y agoI do not discount the value of lightning rods. Exactly because having a safe path to the ground is a real benefit. But I am discounting the reality of "dissipation" as an advantage. In fact the opposite should be true. To the extent that you create a cloud of negative charge, you should attract lightning, not avoid it.