4 ms·
Adequate in 5-10. I doubt this. I have trained students for 10ish years. I have seen what very experienced ED nurses (and consultants, anaesthetists etc) do wit
by lostlogin 14y ago
Adequate in 5-10. I doubt this. I have trained students for 10ish years. I have seen what very experienced ED nurses (and consultants, anaesthetists etc) do with their 'diagnosis' from films, despite numerous courses and flash qualifications. This is without taking the film. Do it for years, see lots of things, make lots of mistake and then you'll get good.
Radiography students are generally competent for unsupervised chest radiography after about 6 months to a year. This is working 2 days a week, study for 3 days. You could probably produce a crap film but good enough to show ET tube in significantly less time, but a good operator has other ways to verify tube placement.
Portable x-ray in bigger towns provides a great service to rest homes, prisons etc and is fiddly and laborious. It's a niche market. The same (but less common) with mobile MRI. CT must be done somewhere in a mobile fashion, I haven't seen it.
It is easy to get a little twisted with terminology, but mobile x-ray generally means you push it around the hospital, portable meaning you carry it out the van, up the stairs, into the rest home (the 600kg mobile machine is not something you would carry easily).This terminology is widely abused though!
- JshWright 14y agoThose are fairly common uses of 'mobile' and 'portable' in general (the 'mobile' radio is attached to the truck, the 'portable' radio is on your hip). As far as '5-10' goes... rdl wasn't talking about interpreting films, he was talking about shooting them (and then transmitting them to a doc somewhere for interpretation). There are some interpretations that could be taught in minutes . Most importantly, the one rdl mentioned, "Does that radio-opaque wire stay straight in the trachea, or does it deviate?". Edit: I'm not sure the comparison to ED nurses is apt. Paramedics and nurses do very different jobs.
- lostlogin 14y agoYes to you and RDL - I see the point. I do dispute the 5-10 minutes though, but the point was that it could be learnt relatively fast. I'd assume some sort of weight versus exposure factors chart would hold 80% of the knowledge and when combined with a set 180cm tube-film distance and a digital system (forgiving!), things would be learnt quite fast. It is deceptive how hard it is to get a patient properly straight, and thereby prevent ET looking deviated.
- rdl 14y agoYou could probably combine a CCD/CMOS imager (i.e. cheap webcam) with an x-ray (and maybe mm-wave imager or something) to help with this. Something like an AED as applied to radiology, with safety interlocks.
- lostlogin 14y agoIt would definitely be possible to have very simple scans done by someone who was given a crash course training (knees, lumbar spines, brains). The problem is that the most complicated work always fails to advertise itself - I found a liver tumour yesterday while scanning a lumbar spine. It appeared on 1 image of the planning scan (a crap, low res image). The student was was present didn't see it and dismissed it as an artifact when I pointed it out, and she is a good student. I'm sure protocols could be made to avoid problems (send all imaging to the PACS, even the duds) like this however.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- JshWright 14y agoOne advantage is that you have a very fixed environment in the back of an ambulance. The stretcher is going to be in exactly the same place every time (I'd assume you'd have some sort of 'slot' to drop the 'film' in on the underside of the stretcher), and there are all sorts of fixed reference points in the back of the truck. Patient positioning is something that we're pretty good at to begin with (if you think it's a pain to get them lined up to shoot the ET... try lining them up to drop it in the first place...)
- lostlogin 14y agoThe bit where they are fighting you off is the bit I always watched with interest. The erect or supine images are sort of scripted in ones mind after a while. It's the semi erect child with ankylosing spondylitis or some such thing that cause distraction. I remember the situation like it was yesterday. It must have been 10 years ago. I never did manage to get a film where the poor guys knee caps didn't appear over the bases of his lungs on every attempt. We never did see his lung fields well.
- rdl 14y agoYeah, even shooting good x-ray films is hard (rather, you can probably learn the absolute basics of radiation exposure, etc fairly quickly, but there is enough art to it that a good tech does a much better job than a radiologist (usually) or a bad tech, just at very practical things like patient positioning. At least in my experience -- the other issue being the craziness of an entire trauma team plus potentially a patient's unit representative plus techs plus radiologist all in a small CT room, or in the case of enemy combatants, armed MPs plus sometimes "other" guys plus patient plus techs... But ETT and a few other things are the low hanging fruit. And with teleradiology you can even skip the "verify you got a decent image" step, particularly intra-hospital or for small images, because the rad can look at it immediately and tell you if you should reshoot. I'd almost bet you could take a zero-training nurse or paramedic and give him a telerad-enabled x-ray or CT and get acceptable results working interactively with a radiologist and/or real rad tech remotely. Ultrasound might be trickier, but I saw midwives (who couldn't read or write, although they were really smart otherwise) trained in 3 days. I've never actually seen an MR used in person (since metal fragments tend to not go well with them; they just magically appeared on the PACS from elsewhere), but I imagine the basics of operating the machine aren't too much more difficult than a CT.
- lostlogin 14y agoThis is what I do now, I used to do CT and X-ray. MRI and CT have very little in common. While the images, very broadly speaking, look similar, the background knowledge required is very different. And they have crap interfaces. Really bad one. I save the error messages that are funniest now. MRI scanners are unreliable, temperamental, hard to get consistent results from and require constant care to avoid screwing things up! MRI isn't very good with serious trauma - too slow. I do miss that work though.
- JshWright 14y agoUltrasound is actually gaining a lot of ground in field EMS (especially in flight). It has three primary uses: -FAST exams in trauma -IV access -Assessing for cardiac tamponade and guiding pericardiocentesis
- rdl 14y agoI meant "adequate for verifying chest tube placement", not " images which would actually be generally useful" (I saw plenty of skill differences among fully licensed rad techs, out of maybe ~50 military rad techs I observed, so I can appreciate the level of skill involved). (as for non-rads "reading"; it was pretty weird. Plenty of orthos were excellent, as expected, for the specific things they cared about, but there were a fair number of rad techs and GP doctors who got really good at some specific things. In working on PACS, I learned enough to be able to identify what was in the image, whether it was good, basic errors in shooting vs. later image corruption, etc., but beyond really obvious things like major fractures, it was really hard. The "look for violations of bilateral symmetry" cheat breaks down in a lot of cases where the body isn't symmetric :( But verifying ETT was one thing I could do pretty quickly. But even with trauma I think a lot of what the rad was for was to look for things like cancer or other less obvious issues, possibly pre-existing, even in trauma patients. Mobile CT are kind of interesting; I've only ever seen a mobile head CT, and that was designed to be wheeled into the OR to use in the middle of surgery, rather than sending the patient down the hall to the full body CT. But this was almost exclusively at hospitals designed around trauma care in a healthy 18-45 year old patient population. In most of the hospitals I saw, it was never "mobile vs. portable", but "the Philips" or "the GE" vs. "the MinXRay", and even those were essentially left on wheeled carts most of the time.
- lostlogin 14y agoI have never really considered imaging without interpretation. Sorry! This must be a legal nightmare - I'm imagining a missed pneumothorax, fluid collection (Not always obvious when supine). That said, something is often better than nothing. Were you in the military? I assume this would be more trauma type work, which tends to be a bit easier for identifying badness. However the working conditions would be somewhat worse I imagine (I have been hospital/clinic based). I would have thought that the most useful type of imaging I the fields would be ultrasound for finding a decent vessel to jab or guiding some sort of drainage (chest fluid, ascites etc). What was most your work?
- rdl 14y agoI worked for a small PACS vendor (mainly IT support and network engineering, and satellite network stuff, but also training rads, techs, and other doctors on how to use the image viewer, report writer, etc.) which was used for dod and others in iraq/afghanistan/kuwait/etc, and spent 2 years in Afghanistan (enh), Kuwait (awesome), and Iraq (been there, done that, was kind of boring by 2010). Also by the federal bureau of prisons, and some cruise lines. Before that I was doing satellite/wireless/etc. networking, and some of my customers were various SOF who had fairly badass medics (regular army SF 18D is probably better than a civilian paramedic, at least for trauma, and the "other" guys had people beyond that, including some actual MDs who were also shooters). I did "combat lifesaver" class and then spent a lot of my spare time hanging out with the SF or SOF medics (because they tended to be more interesting than the shooters). I got some of the rad techs to teach me the basics of how to get decent images from CR/DR/CT/US, since I was trying to figure out which problems were caused by technique, which were caused by emitters or tables, which were caused by plates or scanners, and which were caused by our system. I kind of want to do an EMT course when I have time here, although I'm not sure where I'd volunteer to keep the skills current after that. Before all of this I actually lived out in Baghdad for most of 2004/2005 with ~zero medical care or really any professional support (2 Americans, 100+ Iraqis), so it was mostly "learn anything you might possibly need well enough to do it yourself", and "don't get shot"). There were also civil affairs/outreach efforts, and some charity efforts (rotary club) to bring medical care to civilian population, which was weird, since Kabul had a private hospital with a 64-slice CT (when DOD had 16 and 32), and there was a private 2 Tesla MR in Jalalabad. Mostly I was in "role 3" facilities, which were essentially as good a level 2 trauma center and a little bit of additional facility in the US. Also went to "role 2" (which were essentially 5-10 doctors, plus nurses and techs, with a couple of trauma bays, and X-Ray and US but not usually CT, and some of the FSTs (who augmented role 2 with much better surgical capabilities). In general the equipment and staff were top-notch, and the only problems were physical facilities. CTs tended to be in shipping containers, and the Army CSHes were big tent farms (which sucked), while USN and USAF tended to build fairly decent hardstand buildings (not as good as Stanford, but better than most of the rural counties). On the issue of imaging without interpretation -- it's kind of funny. One of the big DoD pushes was to go back and have a radiologist read and issue an official report for every image shot of a US patient from the start of operations (2001/2002), in ... 2009 or 2010. There is the benefit that US people can't sue the government for malpractice, and Iraqis/Afghans aren't really in a position to sue, either (arguably the only ones with standing would be enemy combatants held in US custody).