6 ms·
I'd rather see the direct or marginal costs of the ambulance or paramedics billed to the user (so, if they expend saline, or bandages, or whatever, you pay for
by rdl 13y ago
I'd rather see the direct or marginal costs of the ambulance or paramedics billed to the user (so, if they expend saline, or bandages, or whatever, you pay for it), and the hourly wage and vehicle costs for the trip itself. That would price a routine EMT-B ambulance trip around $100 -- still enough that people who didn't need it would take a taxi or drive themselves to a doctor for a non-incapacitating problem, but cheap enough that it could be paid out of pocket.
The costs of keeping ambulances ready, training, etc. could be socialized somehow. I benefit by having 5-10 minute EMS response times even if I never use it for 70 years, so paying for that out of taxes or some other universal subscription fee to users makes sense, rather than putting all the costs on those unlucky enough to need it.
- JshWright 13y agoIn some areas (those with municipal ambulance services), that's exactly what happens. In my case, I volunteer with a combination career/volunteer fire/rescue/EMS agency. Our 'operating costs' are payed by taxes, but if you use the service, you get a bill ranging from ~$100 for a routine BLS transport to ~$500 for a 'significant' ALS call (lots of drugs and advanced interventions). We don't itemize, but we do adjust billing based on what was done.
- pyre 13y agoMy daughter had febrile seizures as an infant. The ride in the ambulance to the hospital was ~$1k, IIRC. I don't think that she was on any sort of IV or anything, but my wife was in the back (I rode up front). (This was in Portland, OR)
- lostlogin 13y agoIf you're prepared to socialise some of it, why not go the whole hog. Is there anyone who thinks that ambulances should e user pays? It simplifies things too, as a fair portion of accidents have a blameless victim, so the cost makes them a victim twice.
- rdl 13y agoThe problem is when it's totally socialized (like medicare), you end up with people abusing the service. If an ambulance ride costs you less than a taxi or even bus, and you're an asshole, you use an ambulance (in some places, provided by paramedics, so the direct costs are high -- in some places they also send a fire truck, so you end up with like 20 highly-trained guys and $500k of equipment) to go to a routine checkup. 3-5 times a week. You could probably waive charging direct costs if you had some other way of deterring abuse, but they essentially always have to respond to 911 calls, so the only way I could think of doing so would be to arrest someone who misuses the service. A policy of informally losing the bill for legitimate calls might work, or doing the standard drug dealer "first one's free" strategy. But I don't think $100-500 for an ambulance would break most people, particularly with insurance; a charity could also cover the bills for some people.
- warfangle 13y agoSimple solution: if a reasonable person would think the ambulance was unnecessary, the patient is billed for time. If necessary, it's socialized.
- dbpatterson 13y agoSome wilderness rescue services have an interesting take on it. If what you were doing was really stupid (like, hiking up and skiing a mountain in the middle of the night, during a storm), they bill you, but if you really just got screwed (fell and broke your leg), it's free.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- flexd 13y agoI do not mind paying some taxes so that anyone can get help when they need it. The thought 'Do I have enough money to call an ambulance?' should never be something someone should consider. If you need emergency services you should be able to call and get help. But I do understand what you are saying, I just do not think of it as spending money as my taxes most likely would not change regardless, they would just be used for something else.
- rdl 13y agoIn the US right now "spending marginally less money" probably means "borrowing marginally less money", which would actually be good. I don't think taxes would be lowered in response to cost savings, but deficit borrowing might be.
- antihero 13y agoNope, free is better. The NHS rocks. I am immensely proud that my tax goes towards maintaining an un-profitable but wonderful thing.