4 ms·
There is a fundamental problem in everything that you say. The VCs may be private equity guys, but they have learned to pay attention to what is said by angels
by btilly 13y ago
There is a fundamental problem in everything that you say.
The VCs may be private equity guys, but they have learned to pay attention to what is said by angels and early seed investors. Who in turn frequently got that way by being in successful startups. Which really did compete on merit. And those people know plenty about programming.
As a case in point look no farther than ycombinator itself. I first heard of Paul Graham because he was a well-known Lisp hacker, and when I was starting in programming I was told to read a book of his to open my eyes to how much I did not understand. (I did read On Lisp and highly recommend it.) I first heard of Robert Morris because he famously accidentally took down the internet. They got the money with which they started ycombinator by running their own startup. And every year they identify dozens of unconnected but talented people as people who deserve a chance, and suddenly some kid whose main qualification is that they could impress some talented hackers is in one of the most prestigious inner circles in the Valley.
And yes, part of what they look for is the "social polish" that you deride. Because they've learned that you need some of that to make your business succeed. And yes, they will help you learn how to spin yourself successfully. Because that also helps in the real world.
But in the end they give a first step up to a lot of people who then go on to build everything from better online analytics to motorcycles that won't fall over.
- wging 13y ago>motorcycles that won't fall over Which company is this?
- jessaustin 13y agoThe 4th link down: https://www.hnsearch.com/search#request/all&q=motorcycle+fall+over&start=0 https://www.hnsearch.com/search#request/all&q=motorcycle...
- jamesaguilar 13y agoLit Motors. Which reminds me, I meant to reserve one.
- anonyfuss 13y agoYou've bought into the startup porn a little too much. YC is a startup mill -- they make a TINY investment, and it doesn't matter if most of them fail. The failed founders make a HUGE investment, and its on their head that the majority of the cost of failure sits. YC floats on a bubble of spit and polish and politics. They want people like you to buy into it, because they need to take advantage of people like you.
- michaelochurch 13y agoI don't think that's the right way to think of Y Combinator. It's Harvard++. What incubators and VCs and tech press sell, much more than money or exposure, is legitimacy. Once you're legitimized, you don't need to worry as much about money because it will seek you out. Being YC means you're already legitimate (it was the first of its kind, and is therefore highly prestigious) and require almost no further capitalization from YC itself.
- btilly 13y agoYou're the one who doesn't understand what is going on here. The failed founders are adults who walk into the project with risks understood. Yes, a large percentage fail. However the ones who fail wind up with invaluable experience, an excellent item on the resume, and a network of connections to help them either try again or get a job. This is not a horrible downside if nobody is depending on you. As for me, personally, I'm a married middle aged man who has been watching this from a distance. I have plenty of friends who have entered, gone through ups and downs, and mostly wound up reasonably well off. Unfortunately I have family commitments that have made the risk profile wrong for me. I also sat out the dot com crash and watched a lot of people lose a lot there. I've also seen a lot of people think they were entering the startup world without a clue about what they were doing. They go through the motions, then painfully lose their shirts. Anyone competent develops a radar for those unfolding disasters. I feel sorry for them, but learned a long time ago the dangers of trying to rescue people from self-inflicted injuries.
- anonyfuss 13y ago> The failed founders are adults who walk into the project with risks understood. Most of the YC founders are barely out of college. > However the ones who fail wind up with invaluable experience, an excellent item on the resume, and a network of connections to help them either try again or get a job. I'm curious, have you looked into "where are they now" for YC startups? eg, http://venturebeat.com/2012/03/27/y-combinator-demo-day-march-2012/ http://venturebeat.com/2012/03/27/y-combinator-demo-day-marc... You're really just pushing the startup religion; that somehow inexperienced people who failed at getting traction now have a resume bullet point and a great network? If that's true, then it just lends credence to the original article's point that we've replaced quantifiable quality with politics.