3 ms·
Guns are general purpose self-defense tools. Do you believe that self-defense is legitimate? If so, why not with guns? In the US at least, guns are used abou
by hga 13y ago
Guns are general purpose self-defense tools.
Do you believe that self-defense is legitimate?
If so, why not with guns?
In the US at least, guns are used about 2.25 million times a year in self-defense. Rather obviously, only a very tiny fraction of these incidents result in death, in fact, the vast majority don't even involve a gun being fired, e.g. the display of one with the obviously willingness to use it if pressed is sufficient. And legally, we and the police are not allowed to kill per se, only to stop (killing is reserved to the judicial system).
You've also left out the middle uses of rural areas, where guns are necessary tools to keep various wildlife, generally in the class of "varmints", in check, in part because we've killed off or driven off many predators in favor of keeping our children etc. safer. They're also used in a much more managed way to keep e.g. deer populations in check, that's win-win-win for all concerned (government has the private sector do it and pay for the privilege, the private individuals benefit, and the public e.g. has fewer deer to crash into, they are the most deadly animal in the US...).
- splawn 13y agoValid points, but even with the added value you mention its still debatable on if its worth the cost... I just don't buy into the whole "guns don't kill people" slogan because i don't see very many mass-stabbings...if we were all ninja, I might agree with it. However, this issue is complex. Way too many factors and not enough datapoints to know what direction to really go in,imo. We could take either side and cherry-pick facts and go round and round all day. I just hope violence overall continues its decline.
- hga 13y agoI'd fork the discussion at this point, there's the utilitarian debate on costs vs. benefits (although it's even more complicated that you may realize, you have to go all the way to figuring in the quarter billion disarmed people killed by their own governments in the previous century), then there's the "the 2nd Amendment acknowledges the natural right of self-defense" and the minor detail of degenerate case that the Right to Keep and Bear Arms is an enumerated Constitutional right and if you want to change any of this, you have to amend said Constitution first.