3 ms·
“Bitcoin is basically based on mistrust rather than trust” In some ways, but when we're talking about the reversability of transactions we're really just putti
by Nursie 14y ago
“Bitcoin is basically based on mistrust rather than trust”
In some ways, but when we're talking about the reversability of transactions we're really just putting trust in different places. I trust the bank waaaaaaay more than I trust any online vendor. Particularly one with whom I don't have an existing relationship, but even then. For the folks that love BTC at the moment that seems to be reversed.
--edit-- I'm also not sure how doing two trades on an international currency transfer is supposed to be cheaper than one....
- hnolable 14y agoTotally agree with you on that. But let's compare your trust of your bank vs your trust of your mattress or your safe or your brain password that no one but you can produce.
- Nursie 14y agovs mattress - bank wins vs home safe - bank wins and I'm always forgetting passwords! These are places to store stuff though, not transaction systems, which is what I was driving at. Bitcoin as a transaction system requires me to place trust in a vendor (or potentially an escrow service). I trust my bank's payment systems and chargeback facility more than either of those things. Bitcoin as a store of money? Well I still prefer the legal protections afforded me in a regulated bank.
- gamechangr 14y agoYour last line gets right to the heart of the problem. " I still prefer the legal protection afforded me in a regulated bank". What system can provide legal protection without governmental abuse?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- hnolable 14y agoHere's something to ponder... Sure once in a while your bank/CC payment system protects you from a shady merchant... saving you what... 100$ (max?). Personally in my entire life I can't remember charging back once due to a shady merchant but let's assume you've saved 1000$ because of chargebacks. Here's one of the risks you have to bear to enable your chargebacks: http://mashable.com/2011/01/28/identity-theft-infographic/ http://mashable.com/2011/01/28/identity-theft-infographic/ ... worth it? Think how many insecure databases your name and address and credit card # (and sometimes phone number) are stored in across the net...
- Nursie 14y agoAnd how many shady merchants have I not had to chargeback to because they are deterred? Also I'm not in the US, I get the impression that I'm much better protected by consumer law here in the UK.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- oleganza 14y agoChargebacks are useful to consumers not because of evil merchants who can steal their money (merchants in general are not evil and care about reputation). The real problem is giving away full access to your credit card. Someone can steal your CC number from any shop you used it before and then make a purchase. Since CC is so fragile, Visa offers you a chargeback capacity putting merchants under huge risk of fraud. With bitcoin you don't show your whole wallet to anyone. You only make a single transaction to a single address. Merchant cannot possibly leak anything that will give someone ability to spend your money. Instead of spreading your identifying information to 1000s of shops you only keep it in a single place that you control directly (but you should be careful here). So you don't need chargebacks if no one can easily steal your money. To avoid fraud from merchants, people use "reputation" and escrows. Typically, you will be okay to risk paying 3 bucks almost anyone, but you'd pay 300 dollars only to people you already trust (think Apple Store, WalMart etc.) For very rare cases when you need extra security, go to an intermediate escrow service. (E.g. ebay.)
- Nursie 14y agoUmm, no. I exactly want protection from unscrupulous merchants. Stolen CC detail fraud is on the decline thanks to the likes of EMV cards, and I also have legal protection from it via my bank for when that fails. Reputation and escrows are really no equivalent to legal protection from merchant fraud and instant refunds on dispute. We have centuries of history with shysters and scammers (CAVEAT EMPTOR) to show us why this stuff is useful and it's pretty trivial to fake reputation and to fake escrow. >> you'd pay 300 dollars only to people you already trust Nicely cementing the big boys in the market and locking out smaller vendors forever. I'm sorry people feel so affronted by consumer protections and chargeback, but without them I wouldn't buy stuff off the net at all.
- gamechangr 14y agoTrust is central to all net purchases. No way around that.
- socillion 14y ago