3 ms·
I'm don't understand - how does the existence of alternatives prevent improvement? Could you clarify this point? It is very simple. If there are two somewhat
by btilly 13y ago
I'm don't understand - how does the existence of alternatives prevent improvement? Could you clarify this point?
It is very simple. If there are two somewhat separable programs, but one is much more heavily used by the constituents that politicians care about, the privileged one will consistently enjoy an advantage in resource allocation decisions. This eventually will cause them to be very unequal alternatives.
Also schools are in the habit of raising money from parents in a variety of ways. If all of the well-off parents go to one school, then that school will naturally enjoy a significant funding advantage. If this is what the parents want to do, then fine. But that should be a private school, rather than a charter school that received public funds on top.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoSweden has solved this problem. Resources are equal and follow the student.
- btilly 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Education_in_Sweden#Free_schools http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Education_in_Sweden#Free_school... says that Swedish free schools (the equivalent of charter schools) are not allowed to discriminate among students, or require any sort of admission exam. How does this fit with what you were saying? Furthermore while the amount of state money that follows students may be the same, when schools raise money from parents, having parents with money helps a lot.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoWhat I'm saying is that allowing money to follow students (which Sweden does) prevents politically favored schools from being allocated a disproportionate amount of resources. Thus, your first concern "the privileged one will consistently enjoy an advantage in resource allocation decisions" is invalid with this simple system. As for your second concern, it seems as if you want to prevent people from investing in their own children's education. Should children who attend publicly funded schools also be prevented from attending Kumon, and should the hiring of private tutors by their parents be banned? If not, why not?