10 ms·
How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome
- pjmlp 13y agoGood luck. There was a company in Redmond trying to do the same with IE.
- rogerchucker 13y agoDifference: IE was ugly and IE experience was ugly.
- claudius 13y agoChrome (okay, I only looked at Chromium) is ugly, has basically no way to adapt it to one’s needs, runs out of RAM quickly, is slow and needs updating all the time. Not really a difference to IE.
- k__ 13y agoI find it interesting that there are still people out there who think Chrome is ugly. Firefox and Internet Explorer have all bad tab and/or adressbar placement. Or do you just find any browser ugly by definition?
- pong_ 13y agoTry to open 100 tabs, first in Chrome, then in Firefox. Chrome doesn't even show the titles and runs quickly out of memory. Chrome's process model incurs in substantial overhead, opening tens of tabs in a low-spec PC it's a surefire way to freeze the system.
- k__ 13y agoI just open more than 10 tabs if I'm searching something. Like opening 20 results, than closing them after I visited every tab and found out that they don't have what I searched for. Yeah I know. Many of my friends, whos PC usage is 99% browser and nothing else, still get their 8GB RAM full with Chrome only, just because they spam tabs all over the place. I get crazy if I have too many tabs open for too long, don't know why...
- claudius 13y agoI’m using Opera, so Firefox and IE are not exactly gold standards of nonugliness to me. The biggest contributor to me finding Chrome ugly is certainly that the tab bar is placed on the top rather than the left (and me being too lazy to search for an appropriate extension to change that).
- k__ 13y agoI see, yeah this is probably nice, I know many people who abuse the tab-feature, because they don't like the bookmarks. (Never had a problem with it, but most people seem to think the bookmarks are "broken") I like Chrome over FFox and IE BECAUSE of the top-tabs. Firefox needs more vertical space and Internet Explorer just cripples them beneath the address bar :\
- claudius 13y agoOh, don’t get me wrong, of course tabs belong above the address bar (I think recent browsers get this right). Even better though is putting the tab bar on the right where it doesn’t eat precious vertical space.
- jsolson 13y agoFor me, bookmarks are a hole where content goes to die. Beyond about 5 of them which will get used more or less daily, I'm more likely to just search for content again than to think to check my bookmarks. Unfortunately this usually leads to 100-200 open tabs at any given time of things that are either "in-queue" for reading or research/reference for what I'm currently working on. I'm not going to claim it's the best system (or even a good one), but you really do get used to it and it works pretty well.
- k__ 13y agoI know what you mean, I only use a few bookmarks in the bookmarks-bar (sorted in folders) and the rest is lost... So you saying, the fact that you have about 100-200 open tabs is not because you need them (...just search for content again...), but you just don't close them when not needed anymore?
- abruzzi 13y agoMy second biggest gripe with the Chrome UI it the tabs shrink the size of the window title bar which makes it harder (read slower) to move windows around. (first biggest gripe is the single search/url field, but that is getter hard to get away from)
- sbuk 13y agoI personally find Chrome 'ugly'. Surely 'ugly' is an opinion? Also, I challenge your "IE experience was ugly." comment. Many seem to forget how revolutionary and influential IE 6 is. Google are very much standing on Microsoft shoulders here, like it or not.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- VikingCoder 13y ago> Google are very much standing on Microsoft shoulders here, like it or not. That's a fine point of view, but I think that it's more accurate to say that Google and Microsoft are standing on the same shoulders.
- sbuk 13y agoReally? I'd suggest that Microsoft development of XMLHTTP and by extension XMLHttpRequest were pretty big developments for the web as we know it today. They certainly enabled Google to produce many of their services that are taken for granted today.
- VikingCoder 13y agoAs I said, there's nothing wrong with your point of view. There's no denying that in the history of the web, those were important moments. I'd say the creation of the web browser, HTML, HTTP, were even larger moments. And in that regard, Microsoft and Google are standing side-by-side on the shoulders of giants. And I'd go further and say that when Google decided to make JavaScript performance a top-priority, and started pushing HTML5 standards, Microsoft has been the one playing catch-up. I'd say that those efforts enabled Microsoft to produce Metro, which is core to their new push.
- sbuk 13y agoNo.
- nivla 13y agoNeither IE nor the IE experience was ugly for that time, the time when they decided to introduce ActiveX. Infact, it was the hip browser. I used to remember being on Netscape (my fav/default browser) and unable to browse most modern sites as they were designed specifically for IE, similar to how you now come around those "works only on chrome/webkit" sites.
- pcwalton 13y agoIE was amazing at the time, far better than Netscape 4.
- stinos 13y ago"plans to rule the computing world through IE" serious overstatement, no? Should be "plans to rule the webbrowsing world through IE" probably..
- RobAley 13y agoNope, with the likes of ActiveX they wanted more than just web browsing, they saw that net-delivered apps were the future. They just weren't as advanced/ambitious with their plans. Still, this will fail for Google as it did with MS, if that is indeed what they are trying to do.
- gizzlon 13y agoIf we for a second assume this is happening, I can't decide if it's worrisome development or something I should try to exploit..
- abraininavat 13y agoI think it's the nature of business that those two opinions aren't mutually exclusive in any way.
- kijin 13y agoOr rather, how Google plans to rule the consumer computing world. It's been a while since the average Facebook addict really needed a computer anyway, they can all throw their laptops away and switch full-time to phones and tablets and I won't care. But businesses and professionals have different needs. I don't see web apps and NaCl apps replacing Office suites, IDEs, or 3D graphic design tools anytime in the next decade, no matter how much Google tries to advertise Google Drive (Docs) as an Office replacement. There's a lot more to "computing" than shiny new consumer-grade gadgets. Although I vaguely remember a Chrome add-on that can SSH into remote machines, why would I use it when I have GNU utilities running natively on my OS? > What does your desktop look like a year from now? Probably the same as it does now. Lots of terminals and text editors, maybe a browser window or two in the background.
- pyoung 13y agoI think there is going to be a big departure in what developers want, and what consumers want. For the most part, over the last 10 years, those two groups were largely using the same computers and OS's, but that has already changed, and will continue to do so. If Google can get their platform in front a ton of people, the developers will most likely follow (although they maybe using different machines than the consumers). On a random side note, just picked up a Samsung Chromebook. Loaded up crouton and Ubuntu. This thing definitely puts my 5 year old craptop to shame. If you already have a Macbook, you might not be as impressed, but for the price, this thing can't be beat. So to answer the question " What does your desktop look like a year from now?" Assuming the Chromebook holds up that long (although even if it doesn't, I can easily afford a new one), Ubuntu/Linux for dev(ish) work, and Chrome OS for browsing and non-work stuff (switching between the two is instant, and you can even stream music in Chrome OS and listen to it while in Ubuntu).
- hollerith 13y ago>On a random side note, just picked up a Samsung Chromebook. Which one: the one with the ARM (the Series 3) or the one with the Celeron (the Series 5)?
- millstone 13y ago> Both Packaged Apps and Native Client apps work on any computer that has the Chrome browser installed. Hmm. On my Mid 2011 MacBook Air, I searched for the referenced "Cracking Sands Racing" game on the Chrome Web Store, but found no results. I clicked on the link from the article, and am told "This application is not supported on this computer. Installation has been disabled." I guess they don't work on any computer after all. When I try the Chrome Web Store, I find it difficult to distinguish between apps and what I would call just links to websites. For example, the top result in the "Lifestyle" section is an "app" that is really just a link to a random shopping site, full of the usual tracking cookies and advertising crap. I feel tricked: if I wanted a shopping site, I'd have searched for it. Does Google just let anyone submit a link to their site and call it an app? Applications ought to have a higher quality bar.
- Shooti 13y agoThey're in the process of reorganizing the store to do exactly that. Preview is available on Dev/Canary channels: http://blog.chromium.org/2013/05/preview-new-chrome-packaged-apps.html http://blog.chromium.org/2013/05/preview-new-chrome-packaged...
- cromwellian 13y agoA bit overly dramatic. Long term, I think there will be a harmonization between Chrome packaged apps and Firefox OS apps, and maybe even Surface RT. I personally prefer 'drive by' apps and I think install should really mean "bookmark and pin my cache". The real issue is keeping the Web viable, as it is under attack from native platforms, and both Google and Firefox have to keep aggressively upgrading the platform to keep to competitive with what's available. We've seen an astounding amount of innovation in the browser in the last few years. As Larry Page said at I/O when asked, eventually developers should not have to think about the platform.
- Spearchucker 13y agoNot so sure. The Internet and the browser make many scenarios very easy (Joel Spolsky makes a great case). Jeff Attwood, with ego firmly in hand, named a law after himself that says any software that can be written, will be written for the browser. While entirely possible, that's an extreme view, and maybe not very realistic. The web's "viability" as you put it, will naturally shrink into its natural niche. First and foremost it's probably good to remember that the web relies on a transport layer. There are apps (web sites, email and so on) that live on top of that. That transport layer is what makes the web compelling, but that's not the only possibility (or future) that that layer affords us. I think the real viability question is not the web, but rather data ownership. Users' personal information created Facebook, user knowledge created Stack Exchange, and user behaviour generates Google's income (amongst many examples on the web). Users that are the raison d'être for these web sites have no power over, or control of their data. And it's that fact that will shift (and on mobile, already is shifting) focus back to native client apps that are completely decoupled from the browser. These apps use the Internet as a transport layer, in much the same way a browser does. The shift then, as I see it, is towards one in which the balance of power over data is maintained in a natural equilibrium. In that world, the Stack Exchanges will do well online because their acquisition of user knowledge benefits users directly. The Facebooks and Googles will (I imagine) remain relevant, but not in the way they'd like to be. In conclusion, what the article posits will probably come to be, to a degree and for a while. But it ain't the future.
- AutocorrectThis 13y agoThere are a lot of caveats to the stats. First, look at the browser marketshare table. Notice how Net Applications shows Chrome only at 16% while the others are close to 40%? Wonder why? Net Applications attempts to measure what individual users are using, while Statcounter tries to measure how much of browsing is done though a particular browser. That is, if you browse 1000 webpages a day and use Chrome, and your girlfriend browses only 50 but uses Firefox, Statcounter counts you as 20 times more marketshare than your girlfriend! In this hypothetical scenario, Statcounter will give Firefox 5% of marketshare and Chrome 95%, even though half of people use Firefox. This is like setting up a lookout on a road in a typical US city and concluding that the Ford Crown Victoria is the most popular car in America, based on the fact that you see it most since the taxicabs and police patrol cars drive back and forth all day(since you're not tracking the license plate) while the best selling cars like the Honda Civic/Accord, Toyota Camry/Corolla are not driven as much during a typical day. So, if you're writing a Chrome app, you're targeting only around 16% of people, not 40%. Google bundles Chrome by default with Flash, Acrobat and Java updates which are installed on 98% of computers by paying a lot for it, Mozilla has nowhere near the huge ad revenues like Google does. Not to mention how Chrome is pushed on Google properties like Gmail and Youtube. I keep seeing a "Slow browser? Upgrade to Chrome." message on Gmail sometimes while using the latest version of Opera. The biggest challenge Chrome apps will have is that they won't run on the hottest devices right now, the iPad and iPhones. Apple prohibits any sort of native API or dynamic code in iOS apps so Chrome apps will be confined to HTML5 and WebGL.
- ZeroGravitas 13y agoNet Applications count unique daily users, so if you surf all day you'll be counted as exactly the same as your friend who only surfs a little each day. However, you will both be counted 7 times more than someone who only surfs once a week. So both give weight to more regular web surfers, it's just that Net Applications caps it at the level of daily use.
- chadlundgren 13y agoIn addition to counting vistors rather than hits, Net Applications has a global number of 6.22% for Internet Explorer 6. No, that is not a typo, that is the number pulled today, because Net Applications performs geographic weighting of their data, and China has 24% usage. That inflates the global Internet Explorer numbers and is higher than IE7. Last time I looked at ie6countdown.com, the US and European numbers were 0.2%. Sources: http://www.netapplications.com/newsletter2/20090803/nanl.html http://www.netapplications.com/newsletter2/20090803/nanl.htm... http://netmarketshare.com/browser-market-share.aspx?qprid=2&qpcustomd=0 http://netmarketshare.com/browser-market-share.aspx?qprid=2&... http://www.ie6countdown.com/ http://www.ie6countdown.com/
- deepak-kumar 13y agoI used to be a Firefox fan but not anymore, I made chrome my default browser and I am highly satisfied. Now I use FF just to test while developing things. I love lightness of chrome and have shifted all dev related work to chrome. I wont be surprised if chrome becomes the first choice all the developers in next couple of years.
- venomsnake 13y agoOn a side note the only problem i had with chrome is that you cannot disable disk cache. The problem was easily solved with junctions to /Device/Null for the Cache and MediaCache folder.
- robocat 13y agoNot sure if this is valid but: User Bapabooiee: Well, you guys are in luck (BTW, great work-around, Xenofon), since Chrome now has two startup switches that you can use: --disk-cache-dir and --disk-cache-size Simply close Chrome, right-click your Chrome shortcut, click Properties, and then in the field labeled "Target:", make it look something like this: "...chrome.exe" --disk-cache-dir="CACHE_DIR" --disk-cache-size=N Where 'CACHE_DIR' is the new cache location, and 'N' is the cache size limit, in bytes. Use whichever switch you need, or both. Keep in mind, however, that these features may not be completely stable yet. But you probably shouldn't have any problem with using them. And to anyone who's interested, I caught gander of the existence of these switches directly from a source code file for Chrome. See here: http://src.chromium.org/svn/trunk/src/chrome/common/chrome_switches.cc http://src.chromium.org/svn/trunk/src/chrome/common/chrome_s... Hope this helps!
- forgotAgain 13y agoThanks! I'm trying it now. The caching directives work. Hopefully this will fix the performance issues I've been seeing with Chrome the past two months. The issues I'm talking about are constant disk access and freezing the entire machine when I open multiple tabs simultaneously.
- jonknee 13y ago
- jlgreco 13y agoI don't think I could disagree with the author more, and I am coming from the perspective of someone who also bought a pixel. (Actually we agree there, it is the best put together machine I've ever used... more on that later.) I'm not running ChromeOS on my pixel right now. I tried it for a weekend, it wasn't my cup of tea, and I slapped Debian onto it instead. No big surprise there, I have different needs from most computer users. I want a web browser, a tiling window manager, and a metric fuckton of urxvt's on my screen at once... it doesn't surprise or concern me that I didn't like ChromeOS. I also don't like OSX and Windows 7/8; clearly I have minority interests. Who is the target user of these systems then? Well, I may not like OSX or Windows, but I certainly understand at least a segment of their market. If my mother asks me for an opinion on what computer to get, I'm going to tell her to get a mac, or to stick with the windows Thinkpads she's traditionally gotten. Either of those are great for her, great for browsing the web, watching videos, and viewing pictures from her camera. Now, as I understand the marketing materials, this should make ChromeOS (probably not the pixel, considering the cost, but ChromeOS) a perfect choice for her. I wouldn't even consider recommending ChromeOS to her though, the reality of ChromeOS does not seem to fit the marketing materials or the author of this article's described reality. I tried browsing pictures from my phone on it. My android phone. Fucking awful experience. All of the shine but none of the grace of OSX. Wasted screen-space everywhere, piss-poor file navigation, the works. Alright then, how about watching some videos? Plug in my portable harddrive only to discover that the video player on the thing has all the codec/container support of a bargain-brand smart-tv from 2007. My stock android phone does video a thousand times better than this shit. Fine, maybe I was expecting too much of the default video player. I don't expect my preferred mplayer to be available, but my brothers got my mother hooked on VLC a few years ago. Can I try that? Hahahaha no, what was I thinking? Alright, alright, what about webbrowsing? Well I guess it works exactly as you would expect. You open chrome and browse the web... nothing to complain about, nothing to get excited about. So score one for ChromeOS I guess? The Pixel's hardware though.. my god it is fantastic. Well, aside from the absurdly tiny harddrive which would cripple any offline user with usage patterns terribly dissimilar from mine (for example: my mother). And aside from the uninspired RAM and processor offering... Those are not big complaints though, those failings don't represent significant technical challenges. They are things that could easily be fixed in the next revision. If those things are resolved the next generation of Pixel could be a serious contender, as a piece of hardware, to any of Apple's offerings. They just don't have the software to do it though. If this ChromeOS crap does end up taking off in a few years it will be despite the current state of affairs, much like Android's current popularity is despite the abysmal quality of earlier versions. The market for desktop OS's is entirely different from the 2007-era smartphone market though; ChromeOS isn't "that thing you use if your executives shit their pants when the iPhone was unveiled." Who would I recommend a pixel to? Nobody... nobody except for a very small list of users that I know have usage patterns very similar to my own (and to them I could not recommend the computer strongly enough). This could easily be fixed though. Their hardware could have a future for itself. Who would I recommend ChromeOS to, with any imaginable hardware? I honestly have no idea, and I don't see that changing anytime soon.
- venomsnake 13y agoThe precedent of Microsoft + DOJ and in Europe about IE means that some walled garden vendors will be somewhat reluctant to restrict browsers - especially if google has big enough legal guns. Which could give a (complicated) holes in the wall for vendors and users that like the hardware but hate the appstores.
- dochtman 13y agoThis stuff seems like an excellent reason to go back to Firefox.
- sbuk 13y agoI've been toying with this. Their developer tools are looking rather neat.
- davesims 13y agoI tend to agree. Google is looking more and more like the MS of the new century. Chrome's performance advantage has all but been erased by FF (and in some cases FF is better in my anecdotal experience), and I find FF's add-on ecosystem still better than Chrome's for development. FF is OSS (as far as that goes) and certainly not sitting still. Seems like the obvious dev choice to me these days.
- ericssmith 13y agoThis observation brings some potential context to the rationale for the Dart language.
- squozzer 13y agoWell thought-out post, but probably a little sanguine on the timeline. People are still digesting App Store and other platforms.
- netcan 13y agoGoogle is missing a key thing in its personality or repertoire. The ability to create god solid concepts that everyone understands. A nice tight category of thing that can have a name and a meaning. Apple is the example of a company that did/does. iOS apps were a clear concept of day one. What are they? Where are they? How do you get them? How do you get rid of them? The average user is much less likely to be confused by that question on iOS than any other platform. They're one indivisible thing with one icon and no hair. Google's exploratory Failure is OK, Let The Users Figure It Out mentality is good too. It produces some really good stuff. But, for a lot of the things that google is trying to do, the ability to create really strong concepts is important. "Packaged web app" or "chrome app" or even "web app" are not clear concepts. Users don't understand them. Is it a website? Is it a Link? Is it on my computer? It's not just here that this ability would make a difference. Hangouts. Plus. Wave (rip). They all had definition problems.